Qualitative Research Methods Flashcards
What is the definition of qualitative data?
Gives a ‘feel’ for what something is like
What type of sociologists favour qualitative data and why?
Interpretivists
They reject the idea of any objective social reality and they seek to gain a subjective understanding of actors’ meanings and ‘life worlds’
What are some examples of qualitative research methods?
- Interviews
- Participant observation
- Documents
What are the issues of interviews?
- Practical issues
- Reliability and validity
- Access and response rate
- The interviewer as ‘teacher in disguise’
- Improving the validity of interviews with pupils
- Group interviews with pupils
What are some of the practical issues when using interviews?
- Young people’s linguistic skills are less developed than those of adults and this may lead to them not understanding the questions asked
- This leads to misunderstandings and incorrect answers and this undermines the validity of the data
- Powney and Watts–> young children tend to be more literal minded and often pay attention to unexpected details in questions
- The response given by the interviewees may be influenced, reducing the validity of the data
- Time consumption
What are the issues surrounding reliability and validity?
- Structured interviews produce reliable data because they are standardised
- Structured interviews don’t produce valid data because young people are likely to respond favourably to a formal style
- Bentley–> began each interview by showing students a ‘jokey’ image of her and her daughter and she maintained a relaxed atmosphere during the interview (hard to replicate)
What are the issues surrounding access and response rate?
- Powney and Watts–> the lower down the hierarchy the interviewee is, the more approvals that have to be obtained
- Schools may be reluctant to allow sociologists to conduct interviews during lesson time because of the disruption it causes
- Parental permission (Field’s study of pupils’ experience of sex and health education in schools had a refusal rate of 29%)
What are the issues surrounding the interviewer as ‘teacher in disguise’?
- If interviewees have less power than the interviewer they may see it as being in their own interest to lie, exaggerate or conceal information when answering questions, which reduces the validity of the data
- Children are more likely to change their original answer when the question is repeated because they think it must have been wrong
How can interviewer’s improve the validity of their interviews?
Greene and Hogan–> use open-ended questions, not interrupt pupils, tolerate long pauses, recognise that children are more suggestible and avoid repeating questions
Why are unstructured interviews seen as more suitable?
Their informality can establish rapport more easily and this produces more valid data
What are the issues surrounding group interviews with pupils?
- Pupils may be strongly influenced by peer pressure and this reduces the validity of the data
- The free-flowing nature makes it difficult to standardise the questions and this reduces the reliability of the study
What are the issues of observations?
- Practical issues
- Ethical issues
- Validity
- The Hawthorne Effect
- Representativeness
- Reliability
What are the practical issues when using observations?
- Time consumption (Eggleston–> took 3 months to set up cover)
- Easier to gain permission to observe lessons conduct interviews (Fuller–> headteacher decided that parental permission was non required)
- Personal characteristics affect the observation (Wright–> white teachers were antagonising towards her)
- The observer may find it difficult to find the privacy to record observation (Hemmersley)
What are the ethical issues when using observations?
- The pupils’ vulnerability and limited ability to consent means that observation normally has to be overt
- Delamont–> ‘guilty knowledge’
What are issues surrounding validity when using observations?
- It gives an authentic understanding when researching issues e.g. classroom interaction or labelling in schools
- Pupils may present a false image when being observed by an adult researcher, thus undermining the validity of the study
- Observation gives the researcher the opportunity to gain acceptance by pupils
- Teachers may be skilled at disguising their feelings and altering their behaviour when being observed