Qualitative Research Flashcards

1
Q

What is qualitative research?

A

Go check table on PP

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Factors influencing research topic

A

Time, theoretical perspective, areas of expertise, curiosity, availability of subjects, status characteristics, ethics

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Key consideration for research topic selection

A
  • Honesty and Accuracy: set aside preconceived notions, avoid data to fit theory
  • Record Keeping: Ensure those who come after can follow your research process
  • Assessing Limitations: One should understand the limitations placed on one’s research
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Selecting a problem

A
  • Starting point: Curiosity is aroused by something we encounter
  • Literature Review: Review to establish what research has already been done
  • Clarifying the Problem: “Unpack” major concepts through consultation with others
  • Stating the problem: A hypothesis asserts a relation between concepts and phenomenon
  • Research Objective: An objective to guide some research (such as qualitative research)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What is a sample?

A

A sample is the group of people who your research draws upon to acquire information on the research topic

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Selecting a sample

A

There are various sampling methods
that can be used to decide what kind
of sample to use; different sampling
methods are appropriate to different kinds of research topics.

Qualitative Analysis relies mostly on
non-probabilistic sampling methods

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Accidental/Convenience Sampling

A

Accidental (or Convenience)
Sampling involves studying
those who are immediately
available, although the
study only applies to
those who studied.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Quota Sampling

A

Quota Sampling selects individuals
or groups for study on the basis of
some certain criteria.

The amount of people and their
characteristics are determined in
the research design, with a focus
on those likely to have insight on
the topic (e.g., green party voters).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Purposive sampling

A

Under Purposive Sampling,
the researcher attempts to
identify ‘typical’ instances of
the group or individuals the
research is focused on (e.g. a
‘typical’ example of Bieler
School Students).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Snowball Technique

A

Under the Snowball
Technique, suitable people
are initially approached
regarding the study who
then nominate additional
people to be interviewed,
with no public listing.
e.g., fisherfolk in community

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Systematic matching sample

A

Participants are matched with
others who possess a similar
attribute. This method is useful
for controlling for a certain
variable, or comparing groups
of different sizes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Obtaining an adequate sample

A

You want a high response rate

Survey method determines response rate

Survey costs money, and porr response rates are a waste of time and money

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is a response rate

A

Number of people participated / Number of people asked to participate

70% = very good

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Data Generating procedures

A
  • Surveys (inc. Interviews)
    – Observation
    – Focus Groups
    – Ethnography
    – Content Analysis
    – Discourse Analysis
    – Case Studies
    – Mixed Methods
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What is the goal of a survey?

A

To gain rich qualitative data on the topic you are researching
from the perspective of people who are experiencing/knowledgeable
on the topic you are researching.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What are the beginning stages of a survey

A
  1. Whom to survey and why?
  2. Outline topics to explore in survey
  3. What questions should one ask?
  4. What type of survey is the best?
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What are the types of surveys?

A

Personal interviews: high cost/time, but high quality of information

Telephone

Mail/Email

Other (web, fax, kiosk)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Interviews

A

Interview Guide: Sets out the questions or themes to cover in an
interview. For unstructured/in-depth interviews do not show it to the
participants and use only as a reminder to consult at the end.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Structured/Unstructured Interviews

A

Unstructured: Less standardization of structure, time, or other aspects.

Structured: Standardized questions and timing.
– Don’t deviate from the standard explanation of the study.
– Don’t deviate from the sequence of questions or the wording.
– Don’t give interviewees any of your personal views.
– Don’t interpret the meaning of a question or provide clarifications.
– Don’t improvise by adding answer categories or changing words.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Personal Interview Survey

A

High response rate, but time consuming, interviewer bias and willingness to provide accurate info

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Advantages and Disadvantages of Mail / Other Surveys

A
  • Convenient, standardized, anonymous,
  • no interviewer bias
    Vs.
  • Static, non-responsive, simplistic
  • Has lower response rate
  • – Length α 1/response rate
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

How does survey design affect response and how?

A

A well designed survey has higher response rates:
* Objective of survey must be clear
* A few short, well defined questions

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

What are the 2 types of question structure

A

Close vs Open-ended Questions

Close ended: Yes / No response, Likert Scale Questions and Categorical Choices

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Likert Scale Questions

A

The course content of ENVR301 is repetitive and boring:
* Strongly Agree
* Agree
* Neutral
* Disagree
* Strongly Disagree

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Q

Categorical Choices

A

Select your MSE Domain from the list below:
* Environment and Development
* Ecological Determinants of Health in Society
* Economics and the Earth’s Environment
* Other ______________

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
26
Q

Open-ended questions (short/long answers)

A

What is your MSE Domain?

What is your opinion regarding the structure of MSE courses for your
domain?

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
27
Q

Advantages and Disadvantages of Open Ended Questions

A

Advantages:
* When not all categories are
known
* Can answer in detail with
clarification
* Used if too many categories
* Used if issue complex,
exploratory, preliminary
* Allows expressiveness

Disadvantages:
 Worthless, irrelevant responses
possible
 Statistical Analysis difficult
 Requires time to respond
 Looks longer to respondent

28
Q

Advantages and disadvantages to Close Ended Questions

A

Advantages:
* Standardized
* Easier to respond to
* Easier to code
* Clearer about meaning of
question
* Better with sensitive topics
(multiple choice)

Disadvantages
* Easy for respondent to “just
guess”
* Respondent may not find the
right category

29
Q

Take into consideration with question wording

A

Avoid double-barrelled questions:
* Questions containing “and”/”or”
* What do you think about climate change and how do you think our
government is responding to it?

Avoid leading questions:
* Given that cars generate a large amount of greenhouse gases, what do you think of the level of public transit funding in Montreal?

Surveys are not about advocacy – they are about gathering information
There are other means to get information out to the public

30
Q

Question Ordering in Surveys

A
  • Factual, demographic first (easy to answer)
  • General to specific
  • Related questions together, in logical order
  • Use same scales throughout (or separate the scales
  • Don’t alienate: sensitive questions last
  • Open-ended (opinions) last
  • DON’T PUT IMPORTANT QUESTIONS LAST!
31
Q

Final Points about Surveys

A
  • Keep it simple and straightforward
  • Write a cover letter
  • For personal and telephone interviews:
  • Send out an introductory letter first
  • For mail-in and web surveys:
  • Send reminders and offer prizes
  • Conduct pretests
  • Establish a coding framework
32
Q

Advantages and Disadvantages of Observation

A

Advantages
- Observation can assist understanding of physical, social,
cultural, and economic contexts of people, as well as the relationships
between subjects, ideas, events, behaviours, and actions.
– Observation avoids subjective influences affecting people’s reports of their own behaviour.
– Observation can help one to understand and interpret data collected by other methods.

Disadvantages
- Can be time consuming
- Difficult to write down notes
or remember everything that occurred in the moment
- Difficulties remaining objective in one’s observations.

33
Q

How is observational data used?

A

1 – Alongside other methods, like interviews or focus groups.
2 – To improve relationships with key participants.
3 – To improve or sharpen other research methods being used.
4 – When determining who to recruit for one’s study.

34
Q

2 Types of Observational Research

A

– Direct Observation: This avoids people altering their behaviour since they are being observed, and can be done covertly or overtly.

– Participant Observation: A researcher joins the community they are observing,either covertly or overtly. There is the advantage of contextual understanding.

35
Q

How to design a Focus Group

A

– Project Level: Researcher must decide on the structure of the group, the sampling method, and how to standardize data collection.
– Group Level: Researcher must decide their role in the groups, the degree of moderation, and the structure and flow of topics

36
Q

What is a Moderator in a Focus Group?

A

A moderator can be the researcher or hired professional, but
regardless they must balance control of the conversation

37
Q

Data Analysis in Focus Groups

A

Individual Level – Same process as in an individual interview.

Group Level – Examine the group narrative (e.g. agreements/disagreements/thoughts), participant interactions, interruptions, etc.

38
Q

What is an Ethnography?

A

Aims at an in-depth understanding of cultures and subcultures.
Attempts to offer a detailed accounts of their everyday practices and customs.

39
Q

Ethnography

A
  • Research Design: Choose a research question informed by theories and topics
    of personal and political interest. Choices are informed by accessibility.
  • Gaining Entry: How a community is accessed is critical to determining the type of data received. One way is to make a personal connection with a liaison.
  • Gatekeepers: Those whose approval is needed to gain access to a community.
    Often informal gatekeepers hold key positions or influence in a community.
40
Q

What is the role of the researcher in an ethnography?

A

A researcher can have degrees of participation in the society (e.g. complete observer; observer-as-participant; participant-
as-observer; complete participant).

41
Q

What are the types of observers in an ethnography?

A
  • complete observer;
  • observer-as-participant;
  • participant-as-observer;
  • complete participant)
42
Q

Complete Observer and Advantages / Disadvantage

A

The researcher’s identity is hidden, and that they do not interact with those in the setting.
Advantage: allows a researcher to
study without interference. Disadvantage: researcher not
being able to clarify meanings and questions not readily understood.

43
Q

Observer-as-participant

A

Here the researcher reveals their identity, but only has a limited engagement with the participants.

44
Q

Participant-as-observer

A

The researcher participates fully in activities of the setting, and the identity of the researcher is known.

45
Q

Complete participant

A

The researcher participates actively in the community, covertly passing as an authentic member of the setting.

46
Q

Data collection in observational setting

A

It is crucial to determine what type of data you want to collect, and the method of collecting data. When using observation and participation ongoing data collection is necessary.

Field Notes: Data gathered to make sense of research setting and aid
in writing findings. Includes various forms of research recordings.

47
Q

Content Analysis

A

Documentary Research: Research based in written texts, like historical
documents, official publications, official reports, government records,
mass media, novels, personal documents (e.g. diaries), etc.

48
Q

Public and Private Documents: 4 categories of document accessibility

A

– Closed: Secret Government Documents
– Restricted: Medical, Personnel Files
– Open Archival: Census, Hansard
– Open-Published: Books, Articles, Pamphlets

49
Q

Solicited and Unsolicited Documents in Content Analysis

A

Classifying documents on the basis
of the purpose of creation. Some documents (e.g. government surveys) were created with research in mind, others (e.g. diaries) were not.

50
Q

Practical Impediments of Content Analysis

A
  • Lack of time, funding, or resources. - Access may be refused by gatekeepers;
  • A document can be damaged or difficult to read;
  • Publication can negatively impact people.
51
Q

What are the 4 criteria for assessing the quality of evidence available from document sources

A
  1. Authenticity
  2. Credibility
  3. Representativeness
  4. Meaning
52
Q

What is the authenticity criteria for assessing the quality of the available evidence?

A

Authenticity:
- Is the document consistent?
- Do different versions of a text exist?
- Are internal inconsistencies style or content? Written by someone with vested interests?
- Does it derive from a suspect source?
- Inconsistent with other texts?

53
Q

What is the credibility criteria for assessing the quality of the available evidence?

A

The extent to which evidence is undistorted and sincere, free from
error and evasion. Are people who record the information reliably translating it from a source? To assess this, use other sources and question their politics.

54
Q

What is the representativeness criteria for assessing the quality of the available evidence?

A

Whether a document is “typical” depends on aims of the
research. If one intends to argue that one account predominates, this is key.

55
Q

What is the meaning criteria for assessing the quality of the available evidence?

A

The clarity and comprehensibility of a document. While meanings
and use of words vary, social contexts facilitate understanding.

56
Q

Content Analysis vs Discourse Analysis

A
  • Content analysis looks at the content of the communication, while
    discourse analysis looks at the context.
  • Content analysis is best used to uncover trends and patterns in
    communication, while discourse analysis is best used to uncover
    underlying power structures and ideologies.
57
Q

What is Discourse?

A

Discourse is:
* language above the sentence or above the clause
* a continuous stretch of spoken language larger than a sentence, often constituting a coherent unit
* a stretch of language perceived to be meaningful unified, and purposive; language in use
* (viewed) as social practice determined by social structures

58
Q

Structural approach to discourse

A
  • Find the constituents that have particular relationships with each other and that can occur in a restricted number of arrangements;
  • Problems: units in which people speak do not always look like sentences, or grammatically correct sentences.

Example 1:
(From “The Colour Purple”, Alice Wharton): Jack is tall and kind and don’t hardly say anything. Love children. Respect his wife, Odessa, and all Odessa Amazon sisters (Celie’s Diary)

59
Q

Case Studies

A

Not a method but an approach to research that involves using other methods. Can be theory or problem based, descriptive or explanatory.

60
Q

Classification of case studies

A

– Generalizability: Some researchers conduct case studies with the goals
of generalizing to a larger population of cases.
– Transferability: “Thick Descriptions” produce one’s working hypotheses which can be transferred to other cases. This facilitates generalizations.
– The Particular: Some ague against generalizations and say cases to be
examined as closed systems. Uniqueness of cases can be examined through “thick descriptions,” avoiding essentialism.

61
Q

What are Mixed Methods?

A

The use of multiple quantitative and/or qualitative
methods in a study.

62
Q

Types of Methods to Blend

A

Interviews, Observation, Ethnography, Case Studies,
and/or Content Analysis

63
Q

Advantages and Disadvantages of Mixed Methods

A
  • Advantages: They can complement each other, be used to examine
    different viewpoints, increase validity, or inform further research.
  • Disadvantages: Could be mutually exclusive; lean towards the scientific
    method; problems with publishing; lack of training in different methods
64
Q

Approaches to Mixing Methods

A
  • Pseudo-Combination: There is one main method, and one which is secondary and supportive.
  • Concurrent Approach: Both methods are used in
    different studies at the same time.
  • Sequential Approach: One qualitative or quantitative method is used first, then a second is deployed.
65
Q
A