Q&A Chapter 1 - Ethics / legal Flashcards
Cash Error (even if not material)
always treated as Money Laundering susp. see ‘money laundering’
Materiality - total assets
Material to financial
5% profit before tax
0.5% revenue
1% gross assets
Leasing of a property
This is a related party transaction... Allowed as long as arrangement is: - in the ordinary course of business - on an arms length basis (e.g. market rate) - not material to either party
wife is apart of the management team of company that has bought >20% stake in an audit client
self ineterest and famiiliarity threat
- ethics partner consider how much influence the wife has
- may need to withdraw
Benefits for a company stat audit
- confirmation of profits
- assurance of compliance with Companies Act
- Recommendations via management letter
- credibility
- helps business decisions
Why should auditor be objective and independent?
- use of sceptical judgement
- audit opinion must be unbiased
- public confidence
- required by ethical standards
- independence = objective
Substantial fees
ETHICAL ISSUES
- 15%/10%
- SI - fear of losing client
- Intimidation - audit team reulctant to find errors/give modified opinion
SAFEGUARDS
- regularly review fees (only on going engagements)
- disclose fee to EP and IP review
- consider reducing the amount of non audit services
Customer pays twice
ETHICAL ISSUES - this is a crime - criminal offense for auditor not to report ACTIONS - report to MLRO officer - Report to National Crime Agency (NCA) - Avoid tipping off client - recommend repayment - double payment should be a liability
Impact on cyber crime on audit procedures
- get an IT guy
- could corrupt data - so maybe more time (analytical procedures… e.g. diff years)
- check for data back up, and viral protection
Info gap - detecting fraud
a) auditors responsibiltiy
b) management responsbility
c) potential affects of fraud on business?
a) Auditors repsonsibilty
- not to prevent fraud (auditing involves sampling)
- auditors may not find material frauds
- fraid = harder to detect
- detect misstatements
- must keep documentation, and report to MRLO
- must not tip off
- see engagement letter
b) prevent, detect, implement controls, safeguard assets
c) could affect indemnity insurance, reputation
Auditor leaving in a month to become finance director
a) ethical issues
b) safeguards
ETHICAL ISSUES
- objectivity/independence
- manager was carrying work whilst gaining position
- could overlook errors
- familiarity threat - maybe intimidation of audit team once moves over
SAFEGUARDS
- remove manager immediately,
- review and reperform the work he has done
- look at the audit team… anyone close to her?
- audit resignation?
Money Laundering
ETHICAL ISSUE - STATE THAT IT COULD BE ML - no de minimus (all material) ACTIONS - report to MLRO - do not tip off (comm. with govern., auditors report, resigning, mentioning,) - keep documentation - consider implications on revenue, taxation, VAT
police request to disclose info
- ask for more information
- firm owes confidentiality
- do not disclose any info unless court order or legal duty
- ask client permision (unless MLRO or fraud - dont tip off)
- seek legal advice
- reputational risk?
- ICAEW hotline
Shares are going to be sold in the business sooon….
- alert! could lead to windowshopping - trying to impress
- increased risk
- reduce materiality thresholds/bigger samples
- emphasis on income overstatement
- be more sceptical
Current auditor requests info from you, as the ex auditor
- ask clients permission first
- if the firm refuses, then should report that fact to the auditors (lips sealed… but cheeky nod)
- give info if not… BE TIMELY and ALL THE FACTS
- explain matters honestly
- explain any differences of opinion
LEARN: Audit partner rotation - long association
ETHICAL ISSUES
- issue of long association
- familiarity threat, self interest, self review
- audit partner may be too trusting
- unlisted company, rotation is 10 years, listed =5, for key audit partners =7 years
- Listed = four years but may continue another two (safeguards required) (- can be requested for 2 years if Audit committee feeel it necessary to safeguard quality of audit extra, but no more… must alert shareholders and must have a quality control review)
- if becoming listed you dont start again
SAFEGUARDS
- IPR + EP
- Document reasons
- tell the client