Q + A Flashcards
Is the Summary Offences Act the only enactment that specifically deals with assault on Police?
No.
When considering what type of assault charge to lay on an offender, should you consider previous behaviour by the offender?
No.
When considering what type of assault charge to lay on an offender, should you consider any weapons or how much force was used by the offender?
Yes.
When considering what type of assault charge to lay on an offender, should you consider words spoken by the offender?
Yes.
When considering what type of assault charge to lay on an offender, should you consider the degree of injury suffered by the victim?
Yes.
When considering what type of assault charge to lay on an offender, should you consider any admissions made by the offender?
Yes.
To “disfigure” someone, do their injuries have to be visible for life?
No - they can be healed and no longer visible.
If someone attempts to assault a person, but in the process of doing so assaults another, unintended victim, is this indirect assault or transferred malice?
Transferred malice.
In a scenario where a person makes a threatening gesture (eg punching motion), and has the intent, capability and opportunity to effect their purpose, can they be charged with assault?
Yes - if the victim has reason to believe that the offender can harm them.
What is the age bracket in which someone is considered a “child” in terms of assault?
14 years and under.
In a scenario where a person makes a threat in circumstances where it is sufficient to be charged with assault, does placing a condition on that threat negate it?
No.
What degree of harm would losing a digit be considered?
Maiming.
What degree of harm would a fractured skull be considered?
Grievous bodily harm.
What degree of harm would a serious laceration be considered?
Wounding.
What degree of harm would serious scarring be considered?
Disfiguring.
What degree of harm would loss of consciousness following an assault be considered?
Injuring.
Why aren’t people charged with assault when contact injuries occur during sport?
Implied consent - the victims consent to undergo the risk of assault by playing the sport.
Is there such a thing as attempted assault?
No - an attempt to assault someone satisfies the ingredients of the full offence.
If a person is horsing around and seriously injures someone unintentionally, how would their actions be described in a criminal context?
They acted with reckless disregard for the safety of others.
If two people are horsing around and one tells the other to punch them (giving consent) and they do, causing minor injury, should the person throwing the punches be charged?
No.
What would be the most appropriate charge to be laid for an assault with a sharp object where during which, the offender has commented that the victim “deserves it” and they suffer serious lacerations as a result?
Wounding with intent.
What is the definition of “to injure”?
To cause actual bodily harm to a person.
What would be an appropriate assault charge when two offenders are decamping from a scene and one punches someone who is trying to stop them getting away?
Aggravated assault.
Can a person be charged with aggravated assault if that person punches a police officer attempting to execute a WTA for failing to appear?
Yes.
What is the key characteristic of a “wound”?
Breaking of the skin.
Would a stab would resulting in laceration of a lung be considered a “wound”?
Yes.
Is threatening a person with a weapon and saying “I’ll get you with this” as they try and decamp from the scene of an offence sufficient to meet the threshold of “by any violent means renders any person incapable of resistance”?
Yes.
If someone intends to cause GBH to their victim but they only injure them, can they be charged under S189 of the Crimes Act despite not carrying out their intent?
Yes.
If someone suffers trauma that would regularly meet the criteria of “injures” but there is a lot of blood, does this automatically upgrade their injury to a “wound”?
No.
Does a psychiatric injury meet the definition of “actual bodily harm”?
Yes, if it is some identifiable clinical condition.
Does hurt or injury calculated to interfere with the victim’s health/comfort meet the definition of “actual bodily harm”?
Yes.
Does a black eye meet the definition of “actual bodily harm”?
No.
Does knocking a person unconscious meet the definition of “actual bodily harm”?
Yes.
Does a small bruise after a person has been gabbed meet the definition of “actual bodily harm”?
No.
What are two of the qualifying criteria that a charge under S191 or 192 of the Crimes Act needs to be successful?
The offender foresaw that the actions undertaken were likely to expose others to the risk of suffering harm,
and
The offender meant to cause the specified harm to the victim.
Can a person be charged with any form of aggravated assault if they assault a person while attempting to flee the scene of an incident that is not a “crime”?
No - there must be proof of the commission or attempted commission of a crime.
When a person tries to assault someone, but misses and hits someone else, is this an intentional application of force (and therefore an assault)?
Yes.
When a person accidentally pushes one person into another, is this an intentional application of force (and therefore an assault)?
No.