public law final exam Flashcards
Who has power to create courts
federal and provincial
who has the power to appoint judges
provincial to all lowest provincial courts
federal to all other provincial and federally created courts
must be a lawyer for 5-10 years first
highest court in ontario
ontario court of appeal
what is an intervener
an individual or group that are not a party to the case but are allowed to provide legal arguments to the court on an issue related to the case
composition of Canadian Govt: Legislative
house of commons and senate (fed) legislative assemblies (prov)
composition of Canadian govt: executive
Prime minister, federal cabinet, governor general (fed) premieres, provincial cabinets, lieutenant governor (prod)
composition of Canadian govt: judicial
supreme cour of canada, federal courts, military and tax courts(fed) courts of appeal, superior courts, lowest provincial court (prov)
power to create courts what sections
sec 92 (14) for provincial sec 101 for federal
key functions of courts
resolving disputes
interpresting legislation
overseeing administrative decision-making
determining constitutionality
key features of court system
formality and decorum, open court, adversarial system
Provincial court order
court of appeal for ontario
ontario superior court of justice
ontario court of justice
federal court order
supreme court of canada
federal court of appeal
federal court: tax court and military court
trial court
hear facts of the case for the first time
appellate court
sees if law has been interpreted correctly
court of appeal and supreme court are always appellate courts
superior court is a trial and appellate court ex murder has to go to appellate court
appeal as of right vs appeal as of leave
appeal as of right you can pursue a further appeal without getting permission from court
appeal as of leave- need to get permission
how many judges in trial court vs appellate
trial court is heard by one judge
appellate is heard by 3 5 7 or 9
how many judges at scc
usually 7 or 9 can have 5
how many women on scc
4 women
what is process for provincial judges appointment
screening and recommendation by an independent committee, selection and appointment of candidate by a provincial executive
what is process for federal judge appointment
screening by an independent committee, recommendation to the federal minister of justice, further recommendation to the federal cabinet, executive chooses who they want from that list
judicial independence and ethics
guarantees of ethics: principle of judicial independence, security of tenure, adequate financial compensation, administrative independence
ethics: selections process, canadian/ provincial ethics council
professionalism: continuing education, codes of ethics
judicial misconduct
complaint and investigation process
conducted by canadian/ provincial judicial council
sanctions: reprimand(express sharp disapproval), suspension, and removal
misconduct hearing is to discipline, appeal is to correct their mistakes
Legal factors that influence decision making
precedents, legislative intent
Role orientation and policy preferences affecting decision making
activist vs restraint
liberal vs conservative
other influences of judicial decision making
personal attributes, influences inside the court (discussion with colleagues), influences outside court (media, public opinion,interest groups,legislature and executive)
activist position
vigorous review of actions of other branches of government, willingly striking down laws that are unconstitutional, use of far-reaching remedies
restraint position
deference to legislature or executive, correcting only what is absolutely necessary, reluctant to use far reaching remedies
Lobbying vs Litigation
lobbying (directed at politicians, and civil servants): direct talks, indirect pressure through media and awareness campaigns, submissions to parliamentary committees
Litigation: launching a case or participating as an intervener
executives role in the legislature
executive drafts and introduces bills: most pf legislatures time in dedicated to govt bills
MP/MPP vote according to party lines: easy passage of govt bills
Legislature impact on executive
powers of many executive departments are granted and can be amended by legislation
Accountability (executive to the legislature): daily question period, debate of the bills, vote of no confidence