PUBLIC HEALTH/PPD Flashcards
What is the population perspective?
Think in terms of groups rather than individuals
3 ways of gathering information
Data
Surveys
Studies
What does information relate to in a population?
Demography
Sociology
Epidemiology
Give some determinants of health? (4)
Genes - age, sex
Environment - physical and socioeconomic
Lifestyle
Healthcare - resource allocation
More specific/wider determinants of health? (7)
Agriculture and food production Education Work environment/unemployed Housing Water/sanitation Diet, smoking Healthcare seeking behaviour
Define equity vs equality?
Equity is what is fair and just - give people in more need more help
Equality is concerned with equal shares - give everyone the same
What is horizontal equity?
Equal treatment for equal need - people with pneumonia given same treatment
What is vertical equity?
Unequal treatment for unequal need - areas with poorer health may need more money spending on health
Different forms of health equity? (5)
Equal expenditure/supply Equal access Equal utilisation Equal health care outcomes Equal health
2 dimensions of health equity?
Spatial - geographical
Social - age, gender, class, ethnicity
How is health equity assessed?
Assess inequality
Decide if inequitable
Measure utilisation, health status, supply
3 domains of public health practice?
Health improvement
Health protection
Improving services
What is health improvement?
Concerned with social interventions aimed at preventing disease, promoting health, reducing inequalities
What is health protection?
Concerned with measures to control infectious disease risks and environmental hazards
What is improving services?
Concerned with the organisation and delivery of safe high quality services for care
Examples of health improvement?
Tackling inequalities Education Housing Employment Lifestyle
Examples of health protection?
Infectious disease control
Chemicals/poisons
Emergency response
Environmental hazards
Examples of improving services?
Clinical effectiveness
Efficiency
Audit and evaluation
Clinical governance
Types of health improvement interventions? (2)
Health service or public health interventions
Non health interventions which have an impact on public health
How may interventions be delivered? (3)
Individual level
Community level
Population level
Example of individual, community and population interventions?
Individual - referring individual to smoking cessation nurse
Community - new park or cycle paths to promote exercise, smoking cessation posters in a GP
Population - minimum alcohol pricing, sugar tax
What is the needs assessment and planning cycle?
Needs assessment - planning - implementation - evaluation
2 main ways health of patients can be improved?
Treating individual patients
Influencing the services available to patients
What is need?
Ability to benefit from an intervention
What is demand?
What people ask for
What is supply?
What is provided
What is health needs assessment?
Systematic method for reviewing the health issues facing a population
Leading to agreed priorities and resource allocation that will improve health and reduce inequalities
What is health need?
Need for health - general, measured using morbidity and mortality
What is health care need?
Need for health care - more specific, ability to benefit from health care
Depends on potential of a treatment to remedy problems
For who/what may a health needs assessment be carried out for? (3)
Population or sub group
A condition
An intervention
Who defines need? (5)
Individual, family, community, professionals, society
What are Bradshaw’s 4 types of need?
Felt need
Expressed need
Normative need
Comparative need
What is felt need?
Individual perceptions of variation from normal health
What is expressed need?
Individual seeks help to overcome variation in normal health (demand)
What is normative need?
Professional defines intervention appropriate for the expressed need
What is comparative need?
Comparison between severity, range of interventions and cost
3 types of approaches to health needs assessment?
Epidemiological
Comparative
Corporate
What is the epidemiological approach to health needs assessment? (6)
Define issue, assess the size (incidence/prevalence)
Assess services available for the issue
Assess evidence base - effectiveness, cost effectiveness
Assess models of care, including quality and outcome measures
Assess for any unmet need or un needed services
Make recommendations
Problems with epidemiological approach?
Required data may not be available or of bad quality
Evidence base may be inadequate
Does not consider felt needs of people affected
What is the comparative approach to health needs assessment?
Compares the services received by a population with others
Spatial, social
May examine health status, service provision, service utilisation, health outcomes (mortality, morbidity, QOL)
Problems with comparative approach?
Neither may be giving most appropriate care!
Data may not be available/of variable quality
May be difficult to find comparable population
What is the corporate approach to health needs assessment?
Collect the views of the “stake holders” e.g. The patients/service users, GPs, other health professionals, commissioners, politicians – ask them what they think is needed
Problems with corporate approach?
May be difficult to distinguish need from demand
Groups may have vested interests
May be influenced by political agendas, dominant personalities
Example of an intervention that is supplied, but not needed or demanded?
Routine C section for women with previous C sections
Example of an intervention that is supplied and needed, but not demanded?
Cervical smears/screening
Example of an intervention that is supplied and demanded, but not needed?
Prescription of antibiotics for viral URTIs
Example of an intervention that is needed and demanded, but not supplied?
NHS drug rehabilitation
Intervention that is demanded, but not needed or supplied?
Treatment for mild illnesses - cough, pain with no underlying sinister cause
Intervention that is needed but not demanded or supplied?
NHS rehab for drug addicts (may or may not be demanded)
Intervention that is needed, demanded and supplied?
Insulin for diabetes
3 ways of defining health?
Biomedical - ABSENCE OF DISEASE
Psychosocial - STRESS AND FUNCTION
Lay - FELT AND EXPRESSED NEED
Define evaluation?
The assessment of whether a service achieves its objectives
…by systematically and objectively determining the relevance, effectiveness and impact of activities
Examples of health evaluation? (4)
Single intervention - e.g. RCT of a cancer drug
Evaluation of public health interventions - e..g epidemiological studies of health after smoking ban
Health economic evaluation - cost effectiveness of an intervention
Health technology assessment - systematic review, economic evaluation, mathematical modelling
4 things that can be evaluated
Projects
Processes
Programmes
Services
Donabedian framework for health service evaluation?
Structure
Process
(OUTPUT)
Outcome
How is structure evaluated?
What is there - buildings, staff, equipment
i.e. no. of ICU beds or vascular surgeons per 1000 people
How is process/output evaluated?
What is done - number of patients seen in A+E, the process they go through in A+E, number of procedures performed
How is outcome evaluated?
Classification of health outcomes
Mortality, morbidity, quality of life, patient satisfaction
5 Ds classification of outcome?
Death Disease Disability Discomfort Dissatisfaction
What is PROM?
Patient reported outcome measures - questionnaire i.e. oxford hip score
What are some issues with evaluating health outcomes? (4)
Link between service provided and outcome may be influenced by many factors
Time lag between service provided and outcome
Large sample size may be needed
Data may be unavailable/bad quality
How is data quality assessed?
Completeness Accuracy Relevance Timeliness (CART)
What are maxwell’s dimensions of quality of healthcare? (6)
Effectiveness Efficiency Equity Acceptability Accessibility Appropriateness
2 methods of evaluation?
Qualitative
Quantitative
Qualitative methods of evaluation? (4)
Observation - participant and non participant
Interviews
Focus groups
Document review
Quantitative methods of evaluation? (4)
Routinely collected data
Review of records
Surveys
Epidemiological studies
General steps of evaluating health services? (5)
Define what the service is What are the aims of the service FRAMEWORK (structure, process, outcome) Methodology (qual/quant) Results and recommendations
What is epidemiology?
The study of the frequency, distribution, and determinants of diseases and health related states in populations in order to prevent and control disease
What is incidence?
NEW cases in a population during a specific time period
What is prevalence?
EXISTING cases at a specific point in time
How to work out relative risk?
Risk of one group/risk of another i.e. risk of lung cancer in smokers 15%, risk in non smokers 0.7%, 15/0.7 = 21.4
So 21 times more likely to develop lung cancer if a smoker
How to work out attributable risk?
i. e. amount of lung cancer specifically due to smoking so take away naturally occurring cases
0. 15-0.07 = 0.143
How to work out number needed to treat?
Number needed to treat to prevent one death from lung cancer = 1/attributable risk
1/0.143 = 6.99 = 7 people need to stop smoking to prevent one death
What is sensitivity?
% correctly identified WITH DISEASE
100% = correctly identifies everyone with the disease but may cause false positives
What is specificity?
% correctly identified WITHOUT DISEASE
100% = correctly excluded everyone without the disease but may miss people who do have it
What is the positive predictive value?
% of those with a positive test who actually have the disease
true positive / (true positive + false positive)
What is the negative predictive value?
% of those with a negative test who are actually disease free
true negative / (true negative + false negative)
What is absolute, relative and attributable risk?
Absolute - actual numbers involved i.e. how many deaths per 1000
Relative - ratio of risk of disease in the exposed to the risk in the unexposed
Attributable - rate of disease in the exposed that may be attributed to the exposure
What can association be due to? (5)
Bias Chance Confounding Reverse causality True association! (causal)
What is bias?
Systematic deviation from the true estimation of the association between exposure and outcome
Main groups of bias?
Selection bias
Information bias
Publication bias
What is selection bias?
Systematic error in selection of study participants or allocation of participants to different groups
What is information bias?
Systematic error in the measurement or classification of exposure or outcome
Sources of information bias?
Observer
Participant - recall bias, reporting bias
Instrument - wrongly calibrated
What is publication bias?
Trials with negative results less likely to be published
What is confounding?
Situation where a factor is associated with the exposure of interest and independently influences the outcome
When an apparent association between an exposure and an outcome is actually the result of another factor e.g. grey hair associated with back pain, confounder is age
What are the Bradford hill criteria for causation? (evidence for a causal relationship) (6)
Strength of association Dose response Consistency between studies Temporality (exposure preceding outcome) Reversibility (removal of exposure reduces risk) Biological plausibility
What is a cohort study?
Longitudinal study in similar groups but with different risk factors/treatments i.e. exposed and not exposed, follows up over time
Pros/cons of a cohort study?
Pros: Can follow up rare exposure, can identify risk factors, is prospective
Cons: large sample needed, impractical if rare, expensive, people drop out
What is a case control study?
Observational study looking at the cause of a disease, compares similar participants with the disease to controls without, looks retrospectively for a cause
Pros/cons of a case control study?
Pros: Quick, good for rare outcomes
Cons: difficult to find appropriately matched controls, prone to selection and information bias
What is a cross sectional study?
Observational study collecting data from a population at a specific point in time, snapshot of a group
Pros/cons of a cross sectional study?
Pros: large sample size, provides prevalence data, quick, repeat studies can show changes over time
Cons: risk of reverse causality (which came first), less likely to include quick recoveries
What is a randomised control trial?
Similar participants (selection criteria) are randomly assigned to an intervention or control group to study effect of intervention
Pros/cons of randomised control trial?
Pros: low risk of bias and confounding, comparative
Cons: high drop out rate, little incentive for controls (ethical?), time consuming and expensive
What is an ecological study?
Looking at disease prevalence correlation with geographical location or over time
What is odds ratio?
Measure of association between exposure and outcome
= (Odds of exposure in cases) / (Odds of exposure in controls)
What is the population approach to prevention?
Preventative measure delivered on a population wide/subgroup (i.e. all over 60s) basis and seeks to shift the risk factor distribution curve
i.e. dietary salt restriction through legislation and advice to public should shift blood pressure curve
What is the high risk approach to prevention?
Seeks to identify individuals above a chosen cut off and treat them
i.e. screening for people with high BP
What is the prevention paradox?
A preventive measure which brings much benefit to the population often offers little to each individual
How can prevention be classified?
Primary
Secondary
Tertiary
Criteria a screening programme must fulfil? (6)
Important disease
Natural history of the disease must be understood e.g. detectable risk factors, disease marker
Simple, safe, precise and validated test
Acceptable to the population
Effective treatment from early detection with better outcomes than late detection
Agreed policy of who should receive treatment
Achievable with facilities, inexpensive
What is primary prevention?
Aims to prevent disease before it occurs, for example education about healthy living/not smoking
What is secondary prevention?
Aims to reduce the impact of a disease that has already begun to occur, by detecting and treating as soon as possible
i.e. screening to detect early cancer, daily aspirin/clopidogrel after MI
What is tertiary prevention?
Aims to soften the impact of an established, ongoing illness to improve QOL
i.e. stroke rehabilitation, support groups
What is screening?
A process which sorts out well people who probably have a disease/disease precursor/disease susceptibility from those who probably do not
NOT DIAGNOSTIC
5 types of screening?
Population based screening Opportunistic screening Screening for communicable diseases Pre employment medicals Commercial screening
What is lead time bias?
Early identification does not alter outcome but appears to increase time of survival e.g person knows they have the disease for longer
(e.g. diagnosed earlier)
What is length time bias?
Disease that progresses more slowly is more likely to be picked up by screening as the person is around for longer, making it seem like screening prolongs life
What is health psychology?
Emphasises the role of psychological factors in the cause, progression and consequences of health and illness
Puts theory into practice by promoting healthy behaviours and preventing illness
3 main categories of health behaviours?
Behaviours related to health…
Health behaviour
Illness behaviour
Sick role behaviour
What is health behaviour?
A behaviour aimed to prevent disease i.e. eating healthy
What is illness behaviour?
A behaviour aimed to seek remedy i.e. going to the doctor
What is sick role behaviour?
Any activity aimed at getting well i.e. taking medication
What are health damaging behaviours?
Smoking, alcohol or drug abuse, sun exposure, risky sex, risky driving