Public Health Flashcards
What are the determinants of health?
- Genes (Age, Sex, Genetics)
- Environment (Physical and socioeconomic)
- Lifestyle (Smoking, exercise, alcohol, diet)
- Healthcare
Wider determinants = inequalities in health, primary, secondary and tertiary prevention
What are the structural determinants of health?
Socio-economic context that someone is born into
- governance
- Policies
- Social and cultural values communities place on health
What factors determine someones socio-economic position in society?
Education Occupation Income Gender Ethnicity Social class
What are the intermediary determinants of health?
- Material Circumstances (Housing, clothing, food)
- Psychosocial living circumstances
- Behavioural and biological factors
Define Equity
What is fair and just - “Health equity is defined as the absence of unfair and avoidable or remediable differences in health among population groups defined socially, economically, demographically or geographically”.
Define horizontal equity
equal treatment for equal need (Ie. individuals with the same disease should be treated equally)
Define vertical equity
Unequal treatment for unequal need (Ie. individuals with common colds need different treatment to those with pneumonia)
- Areas with poorer health may need higher expenditure on health
Vertical equity – is the unequal treatment of unequals and can be justified on the basis of morally relevant factors, however, morally irrelevant factors should not be the basis for employing vertical equity:
Morally relevant factors:
Need
Ability to benefit
Autonomy
Deservingness
Morally irrelevant factors:
Age/sex*
Ethnicity
Income, class
Disability, genetics
How can health equity be classified?
(i) Spatial = geographical
(ii) Social = Age, gender, class, ethnicity
How can we examine health equity?
- supply of healthcare
- Access to healthcare
- Utilisation of healthcare
- Health care outcomes
- health status
- Resource allocation (Health services, education, housing)
- Wider determinants of health (diet, smoking, healthcare seeking behaviour, socioeconomic and physical environment)
What are the three domains of public health practice
- Health improvement
- Health protection
- Healthcare (Improving services)
What is meant by health improvement domain
Concerned with societal interventions aimed at preventing disease, promoting health and reducing inequalities through engagement with social determinants such as housing,education, employment, lifestyles, family and community)
What is meant by health protection domain
Concerned with measures to control infectious disease risks and environmental hazards
(infectious disease, chemicals and poisons, radiation, emergency response, environmental health hazards)
What is meant by the healthcare domain
Organisation and delivery of safe, high quality services for prevention, treatment and care (clinical effectiveness, efficiency, service planning, audit and evaluation, clinical governance, equity)
Give some examples of the health improvement domain
Addressing inequalities Education Housing Employment Lifestyle Family/community
Give some examples of health protection domain
Infectious disease Chemicals and poisons Radiation Emergency response Environmental health Hazards
Give some examples of the health care domain
Clinical effectiveness Efficiency Service planning Audit and evaluation Clinical governance Equity
What are the three levels that a public health intervention can occur at
- Individual level
- Community level
- Ecological (Population) Level
Give an example of an individual level public health intervention
Childhood immunisations where injections are delivered to each individual child to stop them getting ill
Give an example of an community level public health intervention
Similar to ecological level interventions but delivered at the local or community level (ie. Playground set up for local community, more cycle paths, outdoor gym)
Give an example of an ecological level public health intervention
Clean air act - legislation to ban smoking in enclosed public places
Putting iodine in salt to prevent iodine deficiency)
Define health psychology
Emphasises the role of psychological factors in the cause, progression and consequences of health and illness and promotes healthy behaviours and prevents illness
What are the 3 behaviours related to health?
- Health behaviour
- Illness behaviour
- Sick role behaviour
Define health behaviour
A behaviour aimed at preventing disease (Eating healthily)
Define an illness behaviour
A behaviour aimed at seeking remedy (Going to the doctor)
Define a sick role behaviour
Any activity aimed at getting well (Taking prescribed medication)
Give some examples of public health campaigns at population level
Awareness campaigns (Healthier you, change 4 life, every mind matters)
Screening and immunisation (Smear and MMR Vaccine)
What is unrealistic optimism
When individuals continue to practice health damaging behaviour due to inaccurate perceptions of the risk and susceptibility
What factors influence an individuals perception of risk?
Lack of personal experience with the problem
Belief that the risk is preventable by personal action
Belief that if something hasn’t happened by now then its not likely to happen
Belief that the problem is infrequent
In terms of health needs assessment, define need
Ability to benefit from an intervention (Ie. Minimum unit pricing for alcohol)
In terms of health needs assessment, define demand
What people ask for (ie. Cosmetic surgery)
In terms of health needs assessment, define supply
What is provided (Tamiflu stockpiles for influenza)
What is a health needs assessment
Systematic method for reviewing the health issues facing a population leading to agreed priorities and resource allocation that with improve health and reduce inequalities
Define health need
Need for health - concerns measures of mortality, morbidity and socio-demographic measures
Define healthcare need
Need for healthcare and the ability to benefit from healthcare - potential for prevention, treatment and care services to remedy health problems
What three things might a healthcare assessment be carried out for
- Population or subgroup
- A condition (COPD)
- An intervention (Coronary Angioplasty)
Define felt need
Individual perceptions of variation from normal health
Define expressive need
Individuals seeks help to overcome variation in normal health (Demand)
Define normative need
Professional defines intervention appropriate for the expressed need
Define comparative need
Comparison between severity, range of interventions and cost
What are the three approaches to health needs assessments
- Epidemiological
- Comparative
- Corporate
Describe the epidemiological approach to health needs assessment
- Define the problem
- Size of the problem (Prevalence and incidence)
- Services available (Prevention/treatment/care)
- Evidence base (Cost effectiveness and efficacy)
- Models of care (Quality and outcome measures)
- Existing services (Unmet need, services not needed)
- Recommendations
What are the 4 sociological perspectives of need?
- Felt need
- Expressed Need
- Normative Need
- Comparative Need
What are the potential sources of data for an epidemiological health needs assessment
- disease registry
- Hospital admissions
- GP databases
- Mortality data
- Primary data collection (Postal/patient survey)
What are the advantages of an epidemiological health needs assessment
- Uses existing data
- Provides data on disease incidence/mortality/morbidity
- Can evaluate services by trends overtime
What are the disadvantages of an epidemiological health needs assessment?
Required data not available
Variable data quality
Evidence based may be inadequate
Does not consider the felt needs or opinions/experiences of the people affected
Describe a COMPARATIVE approach to a health needs assessment
Compares the services received by a population with others
- Spacial
- Social (Age, gender, class, ethnicity)
ie. Compares the services for a particular health issue in two different areas
What factors might a comparative health needs assessment examine
- Mental status
- Service Provision
- Service utilisation
- Health outcomes (Mortality, morbidity, QOL, patient satisfaction)
What are the advantages of a comparative health needs assess
Quick and cheap data available
Indicates whether health or derives provision is better/worse than comparable areas (Gives a measure of relative performance)
What are the disadvantages of a comparative health needs assessment?
- May be difficult to find a comparative population
- Data may not be available or of a high quality
- Data may not yield what the most appropriate level of provision or utilisation should be
What does the corporate approach to health needs assessment involve
Asks the local population what their health needs are
Uses focus groups, interviews and public meetings
Involves a wide variety of stakeholders including teachers, healthcare professionals, social workers, charity workers, local businesses, council workers and politicians
What are the advantages of corporate health needs assessments
Based on the felt and expressed needs of the population in question
Recognises the detailed knowledge and experience of those working with the population
Takes into account a wide range of views
What are the disadvantages of a corporate health needs assessment
Difficult to distinguish need from demand
Groups may have invested interests
May be influenced by political agendas
Dominant personalities may have undue influence
Define primary prevention
Preventing disease before it has happened
Give an example of primary prevention
Change4life
5 a day
Define secondary prevention
Catching a disease in its early pre-clinical phase
Give an example of secondary prevention
Breast screening
Define tertiary prevention
Preventing the complications of a disease
Give some examples of tertiary prevention
Diabetic foot care
Attending physio/rehab after a stroke to prevent immobility and aspiration pneumonia
What is the definition of an evaluation of health services
Assessment of whether a service achieves its objectives or not - a process that attempts to determine as systematically and objectively as possible the relevance, effectiveness and impact of activities in the light of their objectives
What can an evaluation of health services include
- Single intervention (RCT evaluating effectiveness of new cancer drug)
- Public health interventions (impact of smoking ban on health using epidemiological studies)
- Health economic evaluation (Evaluating cost-effectiveness of a medical intervention)
- Health technology assessment (Incorporate systematic review, economic evaluation and mathematical modelling
A health service evaluation is based upon which framework
DONAEDIAN (Structure, process, output and outcome)
What three things make up the framework for a health service evaluation
- Structure
- Process
- Outcome
What sort of things would be evaluated for the structure part of a health service evaluation
Buildings (number of ICU beds per 1000 population)
Staff (Number of vascular surgeons per 1000 population)
Equipment (Locations where screening is provided)
What sort of things are evaluated for process part of a health service assessment
What is done
ie. Number patients seen on A&E
Process through which patients go into A&E
(Where and when patient is first seen, who carriers out triage, how priority is assessed)
Number of operations performed
What sort of things would be evaluated to assess outcomes in a health service assessment
Classification of health outcomes
- Mortality (30 day mortality rate)
- Morbidity (Complication rate)
- QOL/Patient reported outcome measures (PROMS)
- Patient satisfaction
What is another way to assess OUTCOMEs in a health service assessment
the 5D's Death Disease Disability Discomfort Dissatisfaction
What are some examples of Patient reported outcome measures (PROMS) questionnaires used in primary care?
Oxford hip score
Oxford knee score
EQ-5D
Aberdeen varicose vein questionnaire
What are some of the condition specific questions found on the Oxford hip score
- During past 4 weeks, how would you describe the pain you usually had from your hip?
- During the past 4 weeks, have you had any sudden, severe pain (Shooting, stabbing) from the affected hip?
- During the past 4 weeks, have you been troubled by pain from your hip in bed at night?
What are some issues with health outcomes in an evaluation
Link between the health service provided and the health outcome may be difficult to establish as there may be other factors involved (Severity, confounding factors)
Time lag between the service provided and the outcome may be long (Healthy eating in childhood and T2DM incidence in middle age)
Large sample sizes needed to detect statistically significant effects
Data not available
Issues with the quality of data
When assessing the quality of health services, what are 6 dimensions of Maxwell’s classification
3 A’s and 3 E’s
- Effectiveness (Does the intervention produce the desired effect)
- Efficiency (Is the output maximised for a given output)
- Equity (Are the patients being treated fairly)
- Acceptability (How acceptable is the service offered to the people needing it)
- Accessibility (Geographical access, costs for patients, information available, waiting times)
- Appropriateness (Is the right treatment being given to the right people at the right time)
What are the 2 different methods which can be used for a health needs assessment
- Qualitative
- consult relevant stakeholders (Staff patients, relatives carers
Methodology
- observation (Participant observation, non-participant observation).
Interviews
Focus groups
Review of documents - Quantatative Methods
- Routinely collected data (Hospital admissions/mortality)
- Review of records (Medical and administrative)
- surveys
- Other special studies using epidemiological methods