Proportional Voting 2.0

Question 1

What is proportional voting system

Answer 1

A proportional voting system is where the percentage of seats won in an election is roughly the same as the percentage of votes received.

The nearest we have to proportional voting systems used in the regional party list system and Single Transferable Vote, which is used in elections to the Northern Irish Assembly.

Question 2

Advantages of Proportional voting

Answer 2

Advantages of proportional voting systems argue that there are

1. fewer wasted votes, helping smaller parties and making governments more legitimate,
2. that Parliaments are likely to be more sociologically representative and less regionally based than under FPTP, and also that PR can reduce the dominance of an over-mighty executive as more coalitions and negotiations are necessary.

Question 3

Disadvantages of proportional voting

Answer 3

Disadvantages include that it can undermine strong and stable government as no party is likely to receive a majority, it can give disproportionate influence to small parties, can break the link between Mps and their constituencies, the coalition formed between parties may not mean those parties’ voters approve of the coalition, it can let extremists into Parliament, it is harder to hold by-elections, and it isn’t as simple to understand and operate as First-Past-the-Post.