Property Rules Flashcards
Who owns property? 5 policy theories.
(1) First Possession
(2) Labor theory
(3) Utilitarian theory
(4) Civil Republican theory
(5) Personhood theory
What is principal of first possession?
First person to possess a property owns the property
Can trespassers hold first possession of animal over your land?
No, they give you constructive possession
Tresspass must be:
Voluntary
Holding example for first possession
‘Post’ Holding
What is Locke’s labor theory of property?
Whoever’s labor created a property owns the property
Name a holding that exemplifies labor theory of property
Dissent from post
Utilitarian theory of property
Greatest good for the greatest number of people
Name a case where utilitarian theory comes into play
Any if you are creative enough tbqh, but also;
Eyerman Holding, with the historical house they prevented being destroyed
Civil Republican Theory
The owning of property in necccesary for a functioning democracy
Example of case with civil republican theory
Don’t know yet, ask in office hours.
Hegel Personhood theory
Certain property is neccesary for development of the self
Case example of personhood theory
Don’t know yet, ask in office hours
Rights in the “bundle of sticks”
(1) Right to transfer
(2) Right to exclude
(3) Right to use
(4) Right to destroy
Adverse possession elements
(1) Actual
(2) Exclusive
(3) Open and Known
(4) Adverse and Hostile
(5) Continuous
Verticleness; English common law, What is the historic common law rule?
“Owners property rights extend from the center of the earth to the heavens.”
Verticleness; 3 Zones approach, What case explains this one?
Causby
Causby Facts
(1) Causby had a farm next to a military airport
(2) The airport had to fly through his property boundaries at ~ 83 feet
(3) Flight noise killed his chickens and disturbed him
Verticleness; 3 Zones approach, explain it
There are 3 zones of airspace
(High) Public Highway
(Mid) A taking if intrusion is:
(1) Immediate
(2) Direct
(3) Subtracts from the owners enjoyment
and;
(4) Limits owners exploitation
(Low) Obviously a taking
Finally (5) It is not obvious where each zone starts and ends.
Subsurface Ownership; BP chemicals test
Property owner owns what is beneath them where they might
(1) reasonably
and;
(2) foreseeably use it
BP chemicals facts
(1) BP was shoving chemicals into the ground
(2) BP’s chemicals were probably seeping into the other guy’s subsurface
(3) Even so, it was not a trespass because they weren’t going to use the land as deep as the chemicals maybe, probably were.
Water Law; Surface water, what are the 3 Surface water approaches?
(1) Riprarian System
(2) Prior Appropriation
(3) Permit System
Water Law; Surface water, What is a Riparian system?
If;
(1) your property adjoins a water source
then;
(2) you get reasonable use
Water Law; Surface water, What is the prior appropriation system?
(1) The first person
(2) to divert the water for
(3) beneficial use
(4) gets water rights
Note: Not exactly sure what this looks like in practice
Water Law; Surface water, What is a permit system?
(1) The government regulates water use.
(2)People gotta apply for a permit to use the water
Water law; ground water, What is the reasonable use system?
Surface owner of a property can use ground water for a reasonable use
Water law; ground water, What is the Correlatve rights system?
Property owners get a proportional share of the ground water
Note: not exactly sure what this looks like in practice - is it proportional to the amount of surface you own??
Water law; ground water, What is a permit system?
Government regulates water use, people gotta apply for a permit to use the water
Estates; definitons, What is an estate?
To hold an estate is to hold current property rights in a piece of land
Estates; definitons, What is a Future Interest?
To hold a future interest is to hold future property rights in a piece of land
Estates; definitons, What is a Grantor?
An:
(1) alive person that
(2)conveys/grants land to
(3)a Grantee
Estates; definitons, What is a Grantee?
One who gets land
(1) conveyed or granted to them
(2) by an alive person called
(3) a grantor
Estates; definitons, What is a Testator/Testatrix?
A:
(1) Dead person
(2) With a will who
(3) Devises land to
(4) a Devisee
Estates; definitions, What is a Devisee?
One who gets land
(1) Devised to them
(2) From a dead person
(3) with a will called
(4) a testator/testatrix
Estates; definitons, What does it mean to descend land?
When:
(1) A dead person
(2) Gives land to
(3) their Heir
(4) By Intestate succession
Estates; definitons, What is Intestate succession?
When someone
(1) Without a will
(2) Dies and
(3) Descends property
(4) according to state statutes
Estates; definitons, What are Words of purchase
Word which designate who gets the estate
Estates; definitons, What are words of limitation
Words that designate the type of estate
Estates; definitons, What does it mean for a property interests to be alienable, devisable, and/or inheritable
(1) Alienable: Giftable or sellable
(2) Devisable: to give through a will
(3) Inheretable: To give through Intestate succession
Estates; Types, What are the 6 major types of estates?
Estates; language, What words create a Fee Simple?
(1) Any, since it is the presumptive estate given
or;
(2) “to Q and their heirs”
Estates; Presumptions/rules of interpretation; Waste, When is the Doctrine of Waste used?
(1) Where there is a land dispute and;
(2) That dispute is between a person in possession of land and another holding a future interest
Ex: Lessor/Lessee and Life tenant/Remainderman
Estates; language, What words create a Life Estate
(1) For Life
or;
(2) For as long as Q lives
or;
(3) While Q is Alive