Property Offences Flashcards
What Act is burglary included in?
Theft Act 1968 (s9,10)
What section is Burglary at entry?
s9 (1 a)
What is the AR for Burglary at Entry?
AR: Enters as a trespasser
What is the MR for Burglary at Entry?
MR: Intention or recklessness as to trespass, intention to commit theft, GBH or unlawful damage
What was the OLD R v Collins test?
‘an effective and substantial entry’
R v Brown (1985)
There has to be an “effective” entry
Brown broke the window of an Argos shop and stuck his upper body through
The entry does not need to be “substantial”
Withdrawal of permission
R v Collins (1973)
Has to be a reasonable amount of time before the entrant becomes a trespasser
R v Jones; R v Smith (1976)
Argued they had unconditional consent to enter their father’s house
The court held that they waived this right through theft
AR of traspassing
AR: enters a piece of land without legal authorisation from the owner or a member of the owners family
MR of trespassing
MR: intention or recklessness as to the entry
What section is Burglary while inside?
s9 (1b)
Burglary while inside AR
AR: Once in building there is theft/attempted theft, GBH or attempted GBH
This does not include criminal damage
Burglary while inside MR
MR: Wilson and Jenkins (1983) suggests that there does not need to be proof of an MR
However this is contended by Spencer and Vigro (1983) that at least subjective recklessness needs to be present to be convicted of GHB
What section is Aggravated Burglary?
s10 (2)
What is the AR of Aggravated Burglary?
Burglary + the possession of a firearm, weapon or explosive/ the appearance of a firearm
R v Russell (1985)
Does not need to be shown that the firearm was to be used in the course of the burglary, but it has to be shown that it has to be used at some point
Theory: Maguire ad Bennet
Violation of the victim’s private home
Theory: Cook and Ludwig
In burglary increased likelihood of harm and violence
What is Robbery?
Theft + Force / Threat of Force
R v Dawson 1976
The force only needs to be minimal. In this case a nudge of the shoulder to take a wallet
R v Hale (1979)
The force has to occur at the time or immediately after the theft
Broke into a woman’s home, took jewellery and then tied her up. This was robbery
Theory: Lacey, Wells and Quick
The law not only defends property, but also defends a social order
Hence Proudhon
famously declared that property was theft