Property Flashcards
5 Theories of Property Rights
- First Possession
- Encourage Labor
- Utilitarian Theory
- Ensure Democracy
- Personhood Theory
First Possession
“first come, first serve”; “first in time, first in right”
Lockean Labor Theory
ownership arises with the mixing of one’s labor with natural resources
Utilitarian Theory
recognizes property rights in objects when it will promote the welfare of all members of society
Civic Republican Theory
ensure democracy, economic security through private property ownership, political independence through private property ownership
Personhood Theory
facilitate personal development; property is necessary for an individual’s personal development; property is an extension of ourselves
Framing Standards for Possession
- Control
- Relativity of title
- Constructive ownership
- Custom
Rule of Capture
property in animals ferae naturae is acquired by occupancy only
Occupancy
kill, capture, or mortally wound without abandoning pursuit; mere pursuit does NOT constitute occupancy; efficiency rule
Efficiency Rule
everyone is better off, efficient allocation of resources
Coase Theorem
If property rights are well defined and tradeable, and transaction costs are low, then
efficiency will obtain through voluntary trade, regardless of initial allocation.
Invisible Hand Theory
competitive market will lead to the efficient allocation of resources regardless of
the initial distribution of wealth
Central Myth of American Property Law
“In the beginning, all the world was America…” (Locke), big wasteland, void, humans impose labor on land to make it theirs, start in world which no one has rights to anything
What is Property?
Rights among people concerning things; property as a bundle of rights
4 Key Implications of Property Rights
- legal positivism
- rights are relative
- rights are divisible
- rights evolve over time
Legal Positivism
property rights are defined by the government
Relativity of Property Rights
property rights are not absolute
Divisibility of Property Rights
property rights are divisible and may be split among multiple holders
Evolution of Property Rights
property rights evolve as law changes; property law is a dynamic process
Stability of Title
property rights should be certain and predictable
Bundle of Rights
- Right to Transfer
- Right to Use
- Right to Exclude
- Right to Destroy
Right to Transfer
owner may freely alienate any of her property to anyone; scope sometimes limited for public policy reasons; vital to market economy b/c property is devoted to its most valuable resource
Doctrine of Discovery
Europeans can discover land that is occupied only by Indians or non-Christians, not “civilized” people; acquire right via conquest; Johnson v. M’Intosh
Status Property/Whiteness as Property
Property is linked to identity, evolutionary trajectory of whiteness as property; identity–>status–>property; Sally’s Guardian v. Beaty
Critical Characteristics of Status Property
- Whiteness as a traditional form of property
- Modern views of property as defining social relations
- Property and expectations
- The property functions of whiteness
Property Functions of Whiteness
- Rights of disposition
- Right to use and enjoy
- Reputation and status property
- The absolute right to exclude
Right to Exclude
The law protects an owner’s right to exclude subject to privileges such as consent and necessity
Right to Use
owner is entitled to use her property as she wishes, as long as she does not injure the rights of others
Nuisance
non-trespassory invasion of another’s interest in the private use and enjoyment of the land
Elements of a Nuisance Claim:
- Intentional
- Nontrespassory
- Unreasonable
- Substantial Interference
- Use of enjoyment of land
Right to Destroy
scope of owner’s right to destroy is unclear, law rarely intervenes to prevent destruction, but concerns arise when an owner seeks to destroy property that has substantial value to society
Adverse Possession
trespassing on someone else’s land that can result in ownership of the land without buying it or obtaining a deed for long enough time with the right behaviors
Reasons for Recognizing AP
- No public record in England before the 20th century
- encourage improvement of land
- punish those who sit on their rights
- help establish disputed property rights
- settle boundary disputes
- protect lengthy reliance
3 Common Cases of AP
- AP believes he or she owns the land, but there is a defect in chain of title.
- AP is encroaching neighbor’s boundary
- AP intends to steal
Elements of AP
- Actual Possession
- Exclusive Possession
- Open and Notorious Possession
- Adverse and Hostile Possession
- Continuous Possession
- For the statutory period
Additional State Requirements for AP
claim of right, good or bad faith, payment of property taxes, color of title
Justification for AP
- Prevent frivolous claims
- Correcting title defects
- Encouraging development
- Protecting personhood
4 Ways to Acquire Rights
- Capture
- Find
- Adverse Possession
- Gift
Rule of Capture
awards property rights to the person who brings a wild animal under her certain control
Control (State v. Shaw)
confinement in own private enclosure, subject to use at his own pleasure, and maintains reasonable precautions to prevent escape; State v. Shaw
Control (Popov v. Hayashi)
When a person completes a significant portion of the steps to achieve possession of an item, but is prevented by the unlawful conduct of another, that person is entitled to a prepossessory interest in the item
Popov v. Hayashi
prepossessory interest constitutes a qualified right to possession
State v. Shaw
control must be pretty certain the animal will not escape; animal must be deprived of its natural liberties
Control
confinement in own private enclosure, subject to use at his own pleasure, and maintains reasonable precautions to prevent escape
What is Property?
Rights among people concerning things
animus revertendi
habit of return
partus sequitur ventrem
the offspring follows the condition of the mother
ratione soli
by reason of the soil
Johnson v. M’Intosh
Land title transfers are only valid when made under the rule of the currently prevailing government
Trespass
- intentional entering of land
- possessed by another
- or causing a third person or thing to do so
- regardless of if any harm was caused
Right to Use
owner is entitled to use her property as she wishes, as long as she does not injure the rights of others
Spite Structure
- no purpose
2. strictly to harm another
Doctrine of Prior Appropriation
first user to appropriate the resource has the right of the continued use to the exclusion of others
Right to Destroy
scope of owner’s right to destroy is unclear; law intervenes to prevent destruction, but concerns arise when an owner seeks to destroy property that has substantial value to society
Qualified Right to Destroy
rational person’s decision to destroy should be assumed to be in service of further expressive objectives
Eyerman v. Mercantile Trust Co.
When a landowner attempts to compel his successor in interest to do to the land something against public policy, a court may deem the condition void.
Gravity of Harm Test
gravity of harm can’t outweigh the utility of the conduct
Actual Possession
physically use land in same manner the owner would
Exclusive Possession
possession cannot be shared with owner or with the public in general
Open and Notorious Possession
possession must be visible and obvious, so owner could become aware of A.P.
Continuous Possession
possession must be continuous as a reasonable owner’s would be
Adverse and Hostile Possession
not authorized by the owner; 3 mental states (good faith, bad faith, or mind is irrelevant)
Preventing Frivolous Claims
bars lawsuits on stale, unreliable evidence, protecting the occupant from frivolous claims; security of title encourages productive land use
Correcting Title Defects
resolves technical mistakes occurring in conveyance of land by protecting title of the person who actually occupies the land
Encouraging Development
reallocates title from idle owner to industrious squatter, thus promoting the productive use of land
Protecting Personhood
a thing you have enjoyed and used for a long time takes root in your being–OWH
Finders
A finder of property acquires no rights in mislaid property, is entitled to possession of lost property against everyone but the true owner (and prior finders), and is entitled to keep abandoned property
Gifts
Immediate transfer of property rights from the donor to the donee without any payment or other consideration
Elements of a Gift
- donative intent
- delivery
- acceptance
Inter Vivos Gift
ordinary gift of personal property that one living person makes to another; present interest in future estate
Testamentary Gift
future interest in present estate; only valid if its satisfied the statute of wills
Causa Mortis
gift of personal property made by a living person in contemplation death; must actually die of what death was contemplated
Elements of Causa Mortis
- donative intent
- delivery
- acceptance
- donor’s anticipation of imminent death
* donor may revoke the gift before his death