Property Flashcards
Pierson v Post
Fox, pursuit alone does not equal possession, have to deprive ferae naturae of their natural liberty
Rule of Capture
First to capture is the possession, first in time is first in right
Ferae Naturae
Wild animal, qualified property right once they are deprived of natural liberty
animum revertendi
trained animal makes its return to nature, no longer possessed
Corporal possession
possession of something’s body
ratione soli
having ownership because it is on your land
Buster v Newkirk
Wounded deer abandoned. Wounding is not enough, there must be mortal wound and no suspension of pursuit
Keeble v Hickeringill
Interfere with bird pound. Interfering with livelihood is a tort, but doesn’t create property rights.
Actionable interference
Interference bya non-competitor
Non-actionable interference
Interference by a competitor
Dapson v Daly
Unlicensed hunter does not get killed animal because the state holds title to animals in trust for public
State of Ohio v Shaw
Fish stolen from net. Fish in a net are deprived of their natural liberty. trade-based reasonable precaution
Ghen v Rich
bomb lance determined ownership of whale due to custom
Establishing legal custom
Used for a long time, no contrary methods, relevant general usage within a recognized community, reasonable/can’t be gross deviation from common law standards
State of ND v Dickinson Cheese
River fish killed by whey. Fish are res nullias, even when regulated. State doesn’t own the fish, and can’t collect damages.
res nullias
belonging to nobody
Abandoned property
owner manifests an intent to abandon and actually abandons the object. Goes to finder. Land cannot be abandoned.
Finder
holds claim of ownership against everyone except the true owner.
Statute of limitations for abandoned property
Doesn’t start until a third party takes it.
Eads v Brazelton
P found shipwrecked boat and marked trees to come back. D took property in meantime. P can’t recover as no actual possession. Marking not enough
Chattel
personal property
Real property
land
Fixtures
attached to land, pass with the land
Fructous naturalis
plants growing on land, pass with the land
fructous industrialis
harvested plants do not pass with the land
Haslem v Lockwood
Manure on road. Plaintiff who gathered the abandoned manure came back for it after 24 hours, he maintained possession.
Deposits and accretions
ratione soli
manure dropped on farmland
ratione soli
Goddard v Winchell
meteor that falls on land is an accretion
Lost property
goes to the finder
Mislaid property
goes to the owner of the locus in quo
Armory v Delamarie
Chimney sweep finds a ring, stolen by goldsmith. sweep gets damages because he found it.
Clark v Maloney
Logs on river. Prior possessors have greater rights than subsequent possessors
Specification
Change in the species itself (lumber to boards, whale to oil). Can only recover value of original, not the new object.
Accession
If value is added in good faith, you do not have the right to the added value.
Barker v Bates
Lumber found embedded in P’s property, D takes it. Owner of the locus in quo has constructive possession prior to finder. Owner always prevails when finder is a trespasser.
S. Water Co. v Sharman
contractor finds gold rings in pool when hired to clean it. Rings go to land owner, where finder is on premise for limited purpose.
When Finder is employee of the owner
he usually cannot keep the object
Objects in the ground
owner of locus has greater right
Limited purpose finder
When you are on the premise for a limited purpose, especially to find things for the owner, the owner has greater right
Hannah v Peel
soldier finds brooch in house. If owner lives in house where the object is found, owner has greater right.
McAvoy v Medina
X mislaid pocket book in D’s store, P picks it up, D offers to hold onto it in case X comes back. Because it is mislaid, P cannot recover from D.
Anderson v Goulberg
Unauthorized possessor hires P to cut timber off of lot, D takes it. P gets it back, even though not authorized. Thieves can recover from subsequent thieves
Russel v Hill
Thieves cannot recover from subsequent thieves
Bailment
Itenm delivered to the bailee, and bailee has limited right of possession. possession of goods owned by another
Bailee must have
control and intent to possess