Prop I Flashcards
Five Theories of Property
Protect First Possession Encourage Labor Maximize Societal Happiness Ensure Democracy Facilitate Personal Development
Bundle of Sticks
The right to transfer
The right to exclude
The right to use
The right to destroy
Real Property
Rights in land and things attached to land (i.e. Buildings, fences, trees) and fixtures
Personal Property
Rights in moveable items (I.e. Chairs, pens, computers) and intangible things (I.e. Patents and shares of stock)
Three ways to transfer estates
Deed
Will
Interstate Succession
Deed
Completed transfer is a conveyance
Usually transferred intervivos
Intervivos Transfer
While living
Will
Transfer made by a decedent
Completed transfer is a device
Interstate Succession
Property distributed b/c no will
Hierarchy of Estates
Fee Simple
Few Tail
Life Estate
Leasehold
Feeehold Estates
Fee Simple Absolute
Life Estate
Fee Tail
Fee Simple Defeasible
Fee Simple Absolute common law
"To A and his heirs" The holder has all the rights with potentially infinite duration No future interest Freely ADD If ambiguous, presumes life Estate
Fee Simple Absolute modern law
“To A” or “To A and his heirs”
Has all the rights with potentially infinite duration
No future interest
Freely ADD
If ambiguous, presumed fee Simple absolute
Life Estate common law
“To A for life” or “To A”
Presumed without words of inheritance
Measured by the lifetime of a particular person
Eminent Domain
Allows federal, state, and local governments to take property from a private owner who refuses to sell voluntarily and providing in return the marketable price on the land
Public Use
Limit that prevents government from using eminent domain power to take property for a purely private use, even if it is willing to pay fair market value
Just Compensation
The price that a willing seller would accept and a willing buyer would pay for a particular property on the open market
4 Ways to Escape a Zoning Ordinance
Amendment
Variance
Special Exception
Spot Zoning
Spot Zoning
Singles out a small parcel of land for different treatment
Primarily for the benefit of a private owner
In a manner inconsistent w/ the general plan for the community
Amendment to Zoning
Review the constitutionality of rezoning and allow it unless unreasonable
Usually by change or mistake
Change or Mistake Approach
If the conditions in the zone have significantly changed; OR
A mistake was made in the original Zoning ordinance
Nonconforming Use Doctrine
Before, or at the time of, the adoption of a new Zoning ordinance, the property was being used in a then-manner for a Use that, by later legislation, became non-permitted
Cannot be expanded for use
Nonconforming Use
Any lawfully existing use of a structure or of land that does not conform to the applicable use regulations of the district in which it is located
2 Ways to Eliminate Nonconforming Use Doctrine
Amortization
Abandonment
Amortization
Requiring its termination over a reasonable period of time
Abandonment of Nonconforming Use
Intends to relinquish his rights to use
Voluntarily ceases Use for a set period of time varied by jurisdiction
Zoning
Regulation of the use of land by government action as opposed to regulation by agreements between private persons
Created by state statutory law, county ordinances, and city ordinances
2 Tests for Zoning
Rational Basis Test
Strict Scrutiny Test
Rational Basis Test
A law is unconstitutional only if it is clearly arbitrary and unreasonable, having no substantial relation to the public health, safety, morals, or general welfare
Strict Scrutiny Test
A law is constitutional only if it is narrowly tailored to accomplish a compelling state interest
2 Components Required For Zoning
Text of the ordinance
Maps that implement the ordinance
Termination of Covenants
Expiration Release Merger Destruction of Servient Tenement Adverse Possession Eminent Domain Foreclosure Abandonment
Abandonment of Covenant
When the existing violations are so great that an average person would reasonably conclude that the covenant was _____ .
Foreclosure of a Covenanted Property
Enforcement of a lien terminates a covenant that is junior in priority
Eminent Domain Covenant
When a government buys out a covenant, it is terminated
Adverse Possession Covenant
The Possession of the servient tenement must be hostile to the rights of the owner of the benefits of a land use covenant that burdens the servient tenement terminates a covenant
Destruction of Servient Tenement Covenant
Destruction of real property other than land terminates a covenant
Merger Covenant
When the dominant and Servient lands to a covenant become owned by the same person the covenant is terminated
Release Covenant
The transfer of the full benefits of the covenant to the owner of the servient tenement terminates the covenant
Expiration Covenant
The natural end of the covenant
Defenses to Covenants
Unclean Hands Waiver by Acquiescence Laches Statute of Limitations Estoppel Doctrine of Relative Hardship Changed Conditions Unreasonableness/Public Policy
Unclean Hands Covenant
A person cannot complain of a violation if that person is also in violation or has engaged in unfair or deceitful conduct with the particular issue
Waiver by Acquiescence Covenant
A party is seen as waiving their right to enforce a covenant where there was a violation of the covenant, which had a negative impact on the complaining party’s land, but no action to enforce the violation was taken
Laches Covenant
A person who does not assume rights within a timely fashion is barred from enforcing those rights
Statute of Limitations Covenant
Lack of commencement within the time prescribed by the statute
Estoppel Covenant
Reasonable reliance by a covenantor or successor upon the words or conduct of the covenantee to a legal detriment of the covenantor or successor
Doctrine of Relative Hardship Covenant
The owner of the burdened or Servient land must show it would be unjust or unfair to allow the covenant to be enforced.
At the time close to expiration
Changed Conditions Covenant
When the change within the subdivision was substantial; OR
When the change outside the subdivision will make all lots in the subdivision unsuitable for the uses permitted or required by the restrictions
Unreasonableness/Public Policy Covenant
Arbitrary or Spiteful
Unreasonably burdens a constitutional right
Imposes an unreasonable restraint on alienation
Unreasonable restraint on trade or competition
Unconscionable
Common Interest Community (CIC)
A planned residential development where all properties are subject to comprehensive private land use restrictions and which is regulated by an HOA
3 Theories to Determine Restrictions w/ in a Subdivision
Declaration of CC&Rs
Implied Reciprocal Servitudes Theory
Third Party Beneficiary Theory
Declaration of CC&Rs Theory
HOA established in writing
Imposed CC&Rs
Monetary Assessments
Implied Reciprocal Servitudes Theory
When a person buys into a subdivision, it is implied that the person is subject to any restrictions set forth by the common plan and scheme because of their duty to check title of the neighboring lots, even if not set out in that particular deed
Chain of Title Theory
Every deed to every lot in a subdivision is part of the deed chain to every individual lot therefore an individual is required to look up every deed to every lot
Third Party Beneficiary Theory
In order for a particular lot to be burdened, the Covenants must be w/ in the deed chain to that particular title
Equitable Servitude Burden Side to Run
Intent
Touch and Concern
Notice
Equitable Servitudes Benefit Side to Run
Intent
Touch and Concern
Standing to Enforce by vertical privity, 3rd Party Beneficiary Theory, or agency law
Covenant Real Burden Side to Run
Intent Touch and Concern Horizontal Privity Vertical Privity Notice
Covenant Real Benefit Side to Run
Intent
Touch and Concern
Vertical Privity
Intent to Run
Intent to Bind successors
Express or implied
Touch and Concern Tests
Physical Use Test
Economic Value Test
Restatement
Physical Use Test
If the promise impacts the scope of the use of the burdened land then Touch and Concern is met
Economic Value Test
If the limitation placed on the promisor lowers the value of the burdened land, touch and Concern is met
Restatement Test T&C
Constitutionality
Legality
Public Policy
Reasonable
Horizontal Privity Tests
Common Law
Mutual Interest
Successive Interest
Horizontal Privity Common Law
Only a landlord/tenant relationship recognized
Mutual Interest Test
Original parties of a covenant must both have mutual interests in the affected land (I.e. Non possessory future interests, liens, cotenants)
Successive Interest Test
Grantor/Grantee
Transferor/Transferee
Vertical Privity Tests
Whole of the Estate
Any Interest
Whole of the Estate Test
Whatever Interest the transferor has at the time of transfer must be transferred to get vertical Privity
Majority
Any Interest Test
A transferor may transfer any part of their estate to get vertical Privity
Minority
Types of Notice
Actual
Record
Inquiry
Actual Notice
Had actual knowledge of the covenant
Record Notice
Notice based on a title search
Inquiry Notice
Reasonable inspection of the property and can make a reasonable inference.