Professional Responsibility Flashcards
Duties to Clients
- Competence
- Diligence
- Loyalty
Duty of Competence
Lawyer must have legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary to Client.
- [CA] Lawyer may not intentionally, recklessly, with gross negligence, or repeatedly fail to perform legal services.
- Lawyer may gain competency by associating with lawyer reasonably believed to be competent or acquiring sufficient learning and skill performance w/o undue expense or delay.
- Competency cannot be waived by client under any circumstances.
Duty of Diligence
- Lawyer must act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing Client
*[CA] Lawyer not intentionally, repeatedly, recklessly, or with gross negligence fail to act with reasonable diligence in representing Client
Duty of Loyalty - Conflict of Interest
- Lawyer may not accept or continue representation of Client if (1) the rep is directly adverse to another Client’s interest; (2) there is a significant risk that representation of Client will be materially limited by Lawyer’s responsibilities to another Client or former Client, or by personal interest of Lawyer
Concurrent COI (joint clients)
Exists where the representation is directly adverse to another Client’s interest or there is a significant risk that representation of client will be materially limited by lawyer’s responsibilities to another client or former client or personal business -> Lawyer cannot represent client if there’s concurrent coi with another client unless lawyer reasonably believes he can competently and diligently represents both clients + each affected client gives informed written consent
Imputed disqualifications
One Lawyers COI disqualifies entire firm unless:
- Due to lawyer’s personal interest;
- Lawyer is screened from participation in subject, given no fee, and former client notified in writing;
- Lawyer is leaving the firm
Business Transactions
Lawyer must not enter into a business transaction with client unless :
- Terms are fair and reasonable to client and fully disclosed in writing;
- Client advised in writing to seek counsel;
- Informed consent in writing by Client
Gift from Client
Lawyer cannot induce or solicit a substantial gift from a client. Cannot prepare instrument giving himself a gift unless related to client.
Sexual Relations with Clients
Lawyer may not have sexual relation with client , unless existed, before attorney-client relationship. Lawyer’s conduct is not imputed to firm. If Client is an organization, rule applies to any constituent of the organization who supervises, directs, or regularly consults with lawyer concerning organization legal matters.
Proprietary interest in Client’s property
Allowed as lien to secure fees, reas contingency.
[CA] not allowed
Loans (advancing money to client)
Lawyer cannot provide financial assistance to Client in connection w/ litigation, except for advancing litigation expenses, or paying litigation expenses for indigent client
Former Clients
If relationship with former Client will substantially affect relationship with new Client, must give written disclosure to new client.
Substantially affect: law or facts overlap or confidences would hurt one to help another
Fees
Fees cannot be unreasonable/illegal/ unconscionable
Factors include novelty and proportion to value of services, informed consent to fee
Fee Agreement
PREFERABLY in writing, except for regularly represented clients with same basis or rate.
Contingency Fee
Contingency fee agreement must be in writing
- NOT ALLOWED for criminal or domestic relation cases - divorce, alimony/support, property settlement
Third Party Compensation
May accept compensation from someone other than Client only if:
- Client gives informed consent (CA + written)
- No interference with lawyer’s independence of professional judgment or with AC relationship; and
- Client information is kept confidential
Retainer Fees
Lawyer may not keep unearned fees. Lawyer may recover unpaid fees if fired by Client
[CA] : Lawyer and client may agree in writing to to non refundable fee to ensure Lawyer’s availability
Referral Fees
Referral fees generally prohibited. Lawyer may divide fees with another lawyer.
CA: Pure referral fee permitted. Lawyer may be compensated without involvement in the matter.
Fee Splitting
Fee splitting must only happen between lawyers only if:
- Division is proportional to work done by each lawyer,
- Client agrees in writing, and
- Total fee reasonable
CA: Lawyers enter into agreement into written agreement, client gives written consent, total fee not increased
CA Arbitration
Client may elect arbitration of dispute of Lawyer’s fees unless agreed in writing to mandatory arbitration.
Duty to Safekeep client property
Must keep funds in separate trust account.
Commingling with Lawyer’s funds permitted to the extent reasonably necessary to pay bank charges. Any disputed portion must remain in the trust account.
CA Exception: Advance flat fee may be deposited in operating account with written disclosure to client; if flat fee under $1k, agreement and notice to deposit are written and signed by Client
Confidentiality
Lawyer must not reveal information relating to the representation of client without informed consent of client.
EXCEPTION:
1. Lawyer may reveal to extent lawyer reasonably believes necessary to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm (CA - to prevent criminal act that L believes will happen)
2. Attorney-Client privilege: evidentiary privilege that allows client to refuse to testify and prevent lawyer from testifying in court about communications. unless client seeks services to enable future crime/fraud, suit v. client, formerly joint clients, competency
CA - to prevent substantial bodily injury or death.
Organization as Client
Lawyer represents the organization and must conform representation to the idea that client is the organization.
- Lawyer must report to the higher authority, if this fails and there is substantial risk of harm to the org, lawyer may reveal information relating to representation to extent necessary
- CA: Lawyer must not violate duty of confidentiality, if this fails lawyer can withdraw
- When lawyer is dealing with organization’s constituents, and reasonable knows the orgs interests are adverse to those of constitutes, lawyer must explain adverse interest - must obtain consent of orgs counsel before communicating with a constituted of org
Duty to Communicate
Lawyer must communicate with and keep client reasonably informed of all significant developments in representation.
- If settlement offer is made lawyer must convey offer to all clients and get agreement
- Lawyer must abide by client’s decisions regarding objectives of representation and reasonably consult with client as the means pursued. Lawyer must abide by client’s decision
- Lawyer may limit scope of representation if reasonable under the circumstances and client gives informed consent