Professional Responsibility Flashcards
Lawyer and Client Conflict: General
A lawyer may not represent a client if there is significant risk that the representation will be materially limited by the lawyers own interests, unless (1) the lawyer reasonably believes they can provide competent an diligent representation, (2) the representation is not prohibited by law, (3) there is no direct adversity, and (4) the affected client gives informed written consent (CRPC) or informed consent, confirmed in writing (MR)
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Related Opposing Counsel
A lawyer may not represent a client when the lawyer is related to opposing counsel unless (1) the lawyer believes they can provide competent and diligent representation and (2) provides written disclosure to the client under CA or receives informed consent from the affected client under ABA.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: CA Written Disclosure Requirement
Regardless of whether a conflict of interest poses a significant risk of materially limiting representation, an attorney must still provide written disclosure of their personal relationship with a party or witness to the client.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Sexual Relationships With Client
A lawyer may not have sexual relations with a client, unless there is an on-going consensual relationship that predates the representation.
This is personal and cannot be imputed on to other lawyers in a firm.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Lawyer as a Witness
A lawyer may not act as both lawyer and a necessary witness in an action, unless the lawyer’s testimony relates to an uncontested issue or the nature and value of legal services rendered.
CA: A client can waive with informed written consent
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Lawyer Proprietary Interest In Client’s Claim
Under the ABA, a lawyer may not acquire a proprietary interest in the cause of action of subject of the litigation, with the exception of contingent agreements and liens to secure payment.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Lawyer Financial Assistance
Under MR, a lawyer generally may not provide financial assistance to the client if made in connection with ongoing or expected litigation. Under CRPC, no payment of any personal or business expense is permitted.
However, a lawyer may advance court costs and litigation fees, the repayment of which may be contingent on the outcome of the case.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Business Transactions with Clients
A lawyer may not enter into a business transaction with a client, or knowingly acquire an adverse ownership or financial interest, unless (1) the terms are disclosed in writing, (2) the terms are fair and reasonable, (3) the client gives informed written consent, and (4) the client is encouraged to seek independent counsel and given an opportunity to do so.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Literary or Media Rights
Under ABA, prior to the conclusion of representation, a lawyer may not make nor negotiate an agreement giving the lawyer literary or media rights based on the representation.
Under CA, one applies a business transactions analysis.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Solicitation of Gifts
A lawyer may not solicit or draft an instrument that gives substantial gift to the lawyer or the lawyers relatives, unless the client is related to the lawyer by blood or affinity, or, in CA, has been advised by independent counsel.
A lawyer or their relative may accept a gift if it is not the product of undue influence.
Lawyer and Client Conflict: Malpractice Waiver
A lawyer may not make an agreement with a client to limit malpractice liability. Under the ABA, a lawyer is permitted to do so if the client is represented by independent counsel.
Conflicts between Current Clients: Generally
A lawyer may not represent a client whose interests are directly adverse to another client, or if there is a significant risk that representation would be materially limited by the lawyer’s responsibilities to another client, unless (1) the lawyer reasonably believes they will be able to provide diligent and competent representation, (2) the representation is not prohibited by law, (3) the representation does not involve one client against another client in the same litigation or other proceeding, and (4) each affected client give informed written consent (CRPC) or informed consent confirmed in writing (MR).
Conflicts between Current Clients: Directly Adverse Clients
A lawyer may not represent opposing parties in the same lawsuit or transaction.
Conflicts between Clients: Current and Former Clients
A lawyer may not represent a client in the same or substantially related matter as a former client if their interests are materially adverse to each other, unless the former client gives informed written consent.
Conflicts between Clients: Current and Prospective
Under CA, a conflict of interest exists between a client and prospective client if the lawyer acquired material confidential information from the prospective client.
Under ABA, a conflict of interest exists between a client and prospective client if the lawyer acquired information that would be significantly harmful to the prospective client.
Not imputed if disqualified attorney is properly screened.
Conflicts between Clients: Lawyer Switching Private Firms
A lawyer who joins a new law firm may not represent a client in the same or substantially similar matter if (1) the client’s interest is materially adverse to a client of the former firm and (2) the lawyer acquired material confidential information about the former client.
Unless, the former client gives informed written consent.
Conflicts between Clients: Switching form Government to Private Practice
A former government lawyer may not represent a client in a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially.
Unless, the government agency gives informed written consent.