Price Control, Government Intervention and Unintended Consequences Flashcards
What are the two reasons governments intervene in a market?
To help consumers To help producers
What is it called when the government sets a price that is different to the equilibrium price?
Price control
When do the government help consumers?
When they perceive the price to be too high
How does the government help consumers?
They put a price ceiling. This is a disequilibrium price.
What is a price ceiling?
A price that by law you cannot go above
What are the necessary conditions of a price ceiling?
It must be set below the PE
What happens if the price ceiling is set above the PE?
Nothing, in this market PE will prevail
When do the government help producers?
When they perceive the price is too low
How do the government help producers?
They put a price floor. This is a disequilibrium price.
What is a price floor?
A price that by law you cannot go below
What are the necessary conditions of a price floor?
It must be set above the PE
What happens if the price floor is set below PE?
Nothing happens, in this market PE will prevail
When their is a price ceiling set, is there an equilibrium between Qd and Qs?
No, they are in disequilibrium. Qd > Qs
What are the five unintended consequences of a price ceiling?
- Excess demand or shortage
- Line up for the product
- Dead weight loss
- Black market
- Search activity
What is it called when Qd > Qs?
Shortage, or excess demand
Will shortage last?
Yes, as long as the government is in control
Why does excess demand occur with price ceilings?
Producers reduce their quantity supplied while quantity demanded increases as the price is lowered. Therefore quantity demanded is greater than quantity supplied and there is shortage.
Do the government mean to create shortage?
Obviously not. It is the first unintended consequence.
What mechanisms can to government put in place to combat shortage?
Put in place other non-market mechanisms such as queing (putting people on waitinglists) or rationing (sharing the product in some way between customers).
What else can the government do to reduce shortage?
The governemnt can subsidize the product. This will shift the supply curve to the right and reduce excess demand.
What is the downside of subsidies?
The taxpayers are the ones subsidising the consumers of the good when they may not consume the good themselves.
What is consumer surplus?
The difference between how much consumers are willing and able to pay for a good or service and the amount they actually pay.
How can you calculate consumer surplus from a graph?
The area above the PE, below the demand curve
What is the producer surplus?
It is the difference between the minimum amount a producer is willing to receive and the actual amount they receive.
How do you calculate producer surplus?
The area below the PE, above the supply curve.
How do you calculate consumer surplus before government intervention?
1 + 2 + 3 The area above the PE below the demand curve
How do you calculate producer surplus before government intervention?
4 + 5 + 6 The area below PE, above the supply curve
How do you calculate consumer surplus after a price ceiling?
1+2+4 The area above the price ceiling below the demand curve, where the new Qs is.
How do you calculate producer surplus after a price ceiling?
6 Above the supply curve, below the price ceiling where the new Qs is.
How do you calculate GTS after a price ceiling?
1+2+4+6 CS after + PS after
What happens to area 3+5?
They are lost. This is called dead weight loss.
What is dead weight loss?
The loss to society, coming from CS and PS.
When is there dead weight loss?
Every time you move away from QE.
What is the black market?
Illegal markets in which the the price is higher than the legally imposed price ceiling.
How much do you pay on the black market?
The highest possible price, your original willingness to pay. This means as a result of the price ceiling you have lost as you pay more than the original price equilibrium.
What areas represent search activity?
2 + 4
What is search activity?
The maximum amount you are willing to pay (in time) to find someone to do business with.
What is the total cost of a good with a price ceiling?
The total cost of the good is equal to the price you pay for it (the price ceiling) plus the cost of the time and other resources spent searching.
Why is search activity bad then?
It means that the total cost can end up being higher than the unregulated market price you would have paid without the price ceiling.
What does search activity mean for CS after?
It could end up being just area one.
What are the solutions to the unintended consequences of the price ceiling?
- To remove the price ceiling (not happening)
- Increase supply
- Decrease demand
How can you increase supply?
- Subsidies
- Increase imports
- Provide their own housing
- Lower the price of raw materials
How can you decrease demand?
- Decrease population
- Limit quantity (e.g. share accomodation)
- Rationing
- Lower the price of substitutes
- Increase the price of compliments
- Increase taxes
- Decrease income
Is decreasing demand or increasing supply a better solution to the price ceiling?
Increasing supply makes more sense
What are the fourunintended consequences of a price floor?
- Surplus
- Dead weight loss
- Informal sector
- Search activity
What is surplus?
When Qs>Qd
What are the benefits of the informal sector to the employers?
They pay less
Laws don’t apply
No payroll taxes
No insurance
What are the benefits of the informal sector to the producers?
They have a job
They don’t pay taxes
They can still get unemployment insurance
What is GTS before and after price floor?
before 1 2 3 4 5 6
after 1 2 4 6
(same as price ceiling)
Solutions to the price floor?
Get rid of minimum wage (don’t do that)
Get rid of surplus
How can you get rid of surplus?
Increase demand
Decrease supply
How can you increase demand of employment?
Governement creates projects (creates demand for jobs)
Subsidise employers
Shorten work hours
How can you decrease supply of employment?
Decrease population
Increase working age
Decrease retirement age
Decrease tuition fees, offer scholarships, make school affordable
In the case of agriculture how can you increase demand?
Increase the population
Buffer stock
Dumping
What are buffer stocks?
The government buys stocks to keep P at PF and sells them during shortage.
What is the problem with buffer stock?
It requires storage which requires taxpayer money that could be spent on other projects
some goods are perishable
What is dumping?
Put all the surplus in one country at low price
What is the problem with dumping?
It trashes the local economy as the farmers cant make money and everyone is dependent on aid
In the case of agriculture how do you decrease supply?
Set aside
Quota
What is set aside?
The governement pays people to not work
What is the problem with set aside?
It is a burden on taxpayers, paying people to sit at home
What is a quota?
It means the supply line is straight, the same supply at any price
What is the problem with quotas?
It limits production
People tend to chear