Pretrial Procedures Flashcards
A complaint must contain what three elements?
1) Grounds for Subject Matter Jurisdiction
2) Statement of Facts
3) Demand for Judgment and Relief
In a complaint, what must the statement of facts contain?
Facts sufficient to show that the plaintiff is entitled to relief (> than a shot in the dark).
In a complaint, what must be shown in a statement of facts alleging fraud or mistake?
The facts must describe the fraud with specific particularity.
More Info: Fraud or Mistake
How long does a party have to unilaterally amend a complaint?
- A party can unilaterally amend a complaint within 21 days of filing
- If an answer or motion to dismiss has been filed, then within 21 days of that filing
- A party can amend an answer within 21 days of filing it
What are the methods for amending a complaint?
- As a matter right
- With permission
What are the ways to amend a complaint with permission?
- Permission of the Opposing Party
Or
- Permission of the Court
What factors will a court weighwhen grantingpermissionfrom the court toamendacomplaint?
- The reason for the amendment in the context of timing (≠ blameworthy)
- If the amendment will prejudice the other party
Which types of amendments do not relate back to the original filing for statute of limitations purposes?
Amendments seeking to add:
- A new claim
Or
- A new party
When will the filing date of amendments seeking to add a new claim relate back to the original filing date?
When the new claim arises out of the same transaction or occurrence.
When will the filing date of amendments seeking to add a new party relate back to the original filing date?
The filing date will only relate back to filing date of the complaint if all three of the following elements are met:
1) The party to be added knew of the lawsuit soon enough not to be prejudiced in defending against it and in no case later than the time permitted for service and process
2) The party to be added should have expected to be named as a defendant in the original complaint
3) The party to be added was originally left out of the case because of a mistake in identity
* More Info:* https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_15
When is a party to be added to a complaint originally left out of the case because of a mistake in identity?
When the plaintiff sued the wrong legal entity out of a group of entities
What does processfor service and processrequire?
1) A copy of the complaint
2) A summons, a court document that informs the defendant that the complaint has actually been filed and that he must respond to it, or else be held in default.
* If both are not served, then process has not been completed.*
When must process be served?
Within 120 days of filing the complaint
Who can serve process?
Any person at least 18 years old and who is not a party to the action can serve process
How can process be served?
- State Courts: Serve process in the manner prescribed by the state court in the state where the federal suit has been filed OR by the state court in the state where the defendant will be served
Or
- Serve process in the manner specified in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4
List the ways to properly serve process pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4 when suing a human being?
- Deliver the process to the defendant himself wherever he may be
- Leave process at the defendant’s home with someone of suitable discretion
- Serve the defendant’s registered agent
- Mail process to the defendant with a letter requesting that the defendant waive service in person
List the ways to serve process pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4 when suing a business entity?
- Serve process on an officer
- Serve process on a managing agent or general agent
- Serve process on any other agent authorized by appointment or by law to receive service (e.g. registered agent)
If the agent is one authorized by law to receive service and the law requires service by mail, then what must be done to properly serve process?
Serve by
- Hand
and by
If a court has the power to assert personal jurisdiction over a party, that power becomes activated at what moment?
When the defendent is served with process
To what does the constitutional right to due process entitle a defendant?
- Notice of the claims against him
And
- Opportunity to be heard
How can the notice requirement of due process be fulfilled?
- Effective service and process
Or
- The plaintiff taking steps that are reasonably calculated to inform the defendant of the action against him
* More Info:* Notice Requirement of DP
When new claims are filed during a lawsuit, when must process be served?
Service of process need only be accomplished when a new party has been added to the lawsuit (≠ new claims)
What happens if a defendant fails to deny an allegation in a plaintiff’s complaint?
Defendants must specifically admit or deny the allegations or raise defenses. If they do not, then the ruling will be for the plaintiff
After process is served, the party sued must decide how to respond. What options do the Federal Rules offer?
A defendant to a suit can file:
- An answer
- A motion for a more definite statement
- A motion to strike
Or
- A motion to dismiss
What happens if a Defendant fails to include a defense in his answer?
The defendant forfeits that defense.
What defenses are not waived if not included in an answer?
- Failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted
- Failure to join a necessary party
And
- Lack of subject matter jurisdiction
* More Info:* Unwaivable Defenses
When is a motion to strike appropriate?
If a complaint or answer contains redundant, immaterial, or scandalous matters, then the court may on its own or by motion order the improper material stricken.
More Info: Motion to Strike
Define a motion to dismiss.
A motion that seeks the dismissal of a claim and can be filed by any party defending against a claim.
If defendant was actually served with process (regardless of the method), how long does the defendant have to respond to a complaint?
21 days to respond
If the defendant has waived service of process, then how long does the defendant have to respond to a complaint?
60 days to respond.
If the defendant responds to the plaintiff’s complaint by filing a motion for a more definite statement, a motion to strike, or a motion to dismiss, then what must the defendant do if the motion is denied? The defendant must file an answer within what time period?
14 days of the motion’s denial
Rule 11 sanctions are appropriate for violations what principles?
- Good Faith
- Good Facts
- Good Law, unless advocating for good faith change to existing law
* More Info:* Rule 11 Sanctions
How should a party seek sanctions for Rule 11 violations?
- Draft a motion and give it to offending party
Then
- Wait 21 days after service for offending party to withdraw. Then, if not withdrawn, file it with the court.
What must be the goal of sanctions?
To deter the repetition of such conduct by anyone similarly situated
Who is subject to Rule 11 sanctions?
- Any person or entity that has committed a Rule 11 violation or is responsible for a Rule 11 violation is subject to sanctions, except that parties may not be subject to monetary sanctions for violating the good law requirement.
- When an attorney is found to have violated Rule 11, the attorney’s law firm must be held jointly liable absent exceptional circumstances.
When is a party not subject to Rule 11 sanctions?
- When the violation occurs in discovery
- There are no monetary sanctions for violations of the rule requiring “good law”
What elements are required for a preliminary injunction?
1) Notice on adverse party
2) Likelihood that the plaintiff will succeed on the merits
3) Irreparable Harm to the plaintiff is imminent
4) Balance of hardships favors an injunction (harm to plaintiff if denied > harm to defendant if granted)
5) Injunction is in the public interest
6) Payment of security deposit (plaintiff must put up a security deposit to compensate the defendant for harm against him due to the injunction).
What elements are required for a temporary restraining order?
1) Notice on adverse party
2) Likelihood that the plaintiff will succeed on the merits
3) Irreparable harm to the plaintiff is imminent
4) Balance of hardships favors the injunction (harm to plaintiff if denied > harm to defendant if granted)
5) Injunction is in the public interest
6) Payment of a security deposit (plaintiff must put up a security deposit to compensate the defendant for harm against defendant due to the restraining order).
What is the duration of a preliminary injunction?
The entirety of the lawsuit
What is the duration of a temporary restraining order?
14 days
What are the notice requirements for a temporary restraining order (TRO)?
A TRO can be granted ex parte. For ex parte granting of a TRO, the plaintiff must show that they:
- Tried to give notice
And
- There will be an immediate irreparable harm to the plaintiff without the TRO.
* More Info:* TRO Notice Requirements
What does joinder allow a plaintiff to do?
If a plaintiff has numerous claims against a single defendant, she is free to bring all of those claims in the same lawsuit regardless of if they are related or not. However, the plaintiff is not required to bring them all at once in the same lawsuit.
What is a permissive counterclaim?
A claim that does not arise out of the transaction or occurrence underlying any of the plaintiff’s claims against the defendant. A defendant may file a permissive counterclaim against a plaintiff.
What is a compulsory counterclaim?
What is the effect of failing to bring a compulsory counterclaim?
A claim that does arise out of the transaction or occurrence underlying any of the plaintiff’s claims against the defendant.
Failure to bring a compulsory counterclaims precludes the defendant from bringing it later from the law of joinder.
If a party has multiple counterclaims against a plaintiff, what can that party do?
The defendant may bring them all together regardless of whether they are related.
Who files a cross claim?
A party against a co-party (i.e., someone on the same side of the v).
Cross claims may be filed only for what types of claims?
The cross claims must arise from the same transaction or occurrence of the plaintiff’s underlying claims.
Once a defendant files an appropriate cross claim against a co-defendant, the defendant may file what claims?
Join with the appropriate cross claims any additional claims, even if those claims are unrelated to the transaction or occurrence underlying the plaintiff’s suit.
Once a defendant files a cross claim against a co-defendant, that co-defendant is free to file what claims?
Counterclaims. Like an ordinary counterclaim, a counterclaim filed in response to a cross claim can be compulsory or permissive.
What is an impleader claim?
An impleader claim is brought against somebody not yet involved in the lawsuit.