Politics and Law WACE Questions Flashcards
What is a constitutional monarchy?
- System of gov where HOS is monarch, powers limited by CW Constitution 1901 + unwritten constitutional rules
- HOS: King Charles III
How is the executive appointed in another political system?
- Executive - Presid, Vice Presid, Cabinet secretaries
- Elected presidential elections held every 4 years
- “Electors” EC, determined gen election, choose President
- Electors distributed according state population (Cali 55 votes) + FPP majority
- Win Presidency more receive 270 college votes
Discuss two differences between the powers of the Australian Prime Minister and the head of government in a non-Westminster system
- US - Presidential Veto (President Obama vetoed Restoring Americans’ Healthcare Freedom Reconciliation Act 2015)
- AUS - no need veto, invariably introduced party
- US - commander in chief US
- AUS - commander chief armed forces GG (S72)
What is the role of the Speaker?
- Interpret + apply Standing Orders (S50 - right Parliament create own Standing Orders)
- Speaker - Milton Dick
Discuss the effectiveness of Opposition in blocking government legislation?
- Define Opposition
- FOR: No majority (77, 58, 16) - vote party lines, assured majority pass legislative agenda
- AG: Senate no party majority, block gov leg (Ensuring Integrity Bill)
What is the ministry?
- Collective of ministers, assistant ministers + PM
- Inner (Sen) + outer (assistant/junior)
Outline three roles/powers of Cabinet ministers
- Answer questions Question Time relating Portfolio
- Ensure portfolio implementing gov policy
- Adhering conventions cabinet solidarity
Discuss one strength and one weakness of CMR in upholding representative function Commonwealth Parliament
- CMR - executive is responsible + maintain confidence LH
- PRO: most citizens vote for party + its values, cab solidarity united + unlikely neglect values
- EXAMPLE: first 2018 leadership spill, 5 voted against MT resigned to allow gov remain united
- CON: prevents views electorate aired
- EXAMPLE: Gary Punch/Stuart West
Outline powers that Governor-General has in S64 Constitution
- Ministers must be members
- Appoint ministers CW Parliament
- Seen justified remove Whitlam - assumed power to remove
Explain one reason for Sir John Kerr’s intervention in the ‘1975 Crisis’
- Ensure supply as money bills blocked Liberal-led hostile Senate
- Lost confidence of Parliament + run money guarantee salaries public servants/service provisions
- Kerr justified reserve power due political crisis
Discuss two issues associated ‘1975 Crisis’
- Define: Kerr using reserve powers dismiss Whitlam - first time Fed sitting PM dismissed GG
- Whitlam, elected figure confidence House, dismissed unelected figure. Undemocratic, GG unaccountable figure.
- Two vacancies filled indep, broke WM conv Senate vacancy filled member given party, 1977 Referend
Outline what is meant by a ‘federal system of government’
- LM powers divided one central branch gov + 2 or more regional branches
- CW
Discuss two reasons for the increased strength of States in AUS Federation in recent years
S51 (ix) temporarily passed States
- > legislative power beyond intended CW
- S51 (ix) concurrent “exclusive nature”- CW only health power
- S51 (ix) handballed states - lack confidence CW administer quarantine + gave power states manage public health emergency
High Court cases
- Allowed WA restrict trade/commerce “national health emergency” (Closing the Borders Direction)
- HC found S92 freedom trade/commerce justified health/life WA citizens
Evaluate the extent to which financial powers of the Commonwealth Parliament allow it to dominate states
FOR:
- Power raise Y tax under S51 (ii) concurrent power exclusive through Uniform Tax Cases (1942/57), deprive revenue
- 57% income tax - collect + creating VFI (imbalance taxing/spending obligations b/w two levels gov within fed)
- Reliant CW transfer funds SPP S96 - tied grants CW use coercive financial powers attached conditions
- 2017 - attach conditions distribute 2.1 billion Perth Freight Link + threaten reallocate conditions not met
AGAINST:
- GPP - spend out own discretion, without coercion (GST)
Discuss two reasons why constitutional change through referendums is difficult
- Referendums: S128 formal method change wording Constitution
Difficult to reach high standard pass referendums - Double majority - federal majority (majority in all states 4/6) + democratic majority (majority of all voters)
- 8/44 successful, “labour of Hercules
- 1937 - aviation CW power leg aircraft/air navigation, 53.36% Mindset:
- Reluctant voting perceived power grabs CW
- 1999 Republic referendum - 55% no (well-governed)
Explain the difference between VFI + HFI
- Define VFI
- HFI - CW Parliament uses financial services equalise public delivery ea. state
- Difference - VFI coercive federalism, HFI encourages cooperative fed equalise financial powers VFI
What is the role of the High Court?
Outline three jurisdictions High Court
- Original (S75) - court first instance matters conflict b/w states
- Appellate (S73) - financial court of appeals, hear cases arising AUS lower state, territory, fed court hierarchy
- Additional original jurisdiction (S76) - CW Parliament exclusive power make laws conferring original jurisdiction HC (Constitution)
With reference to one reform proposal, discuss one reason why it might succeed/fail
- Proposal - recognise Indigenous Australians body Constitution, replace S25 spent section (allows states ban voting based race) w S51A (preserve ability gov make laws benefit Aboriginal people)
- FOR: “right think to do” - 1967 allow Constitution reflect national identity + work reconcilation
- Professor Beherendt - “alter way Australians see history”, AUS national values
- AG: perceived as too radical, anyone Aboriginal heritage incentive claim actions constitutional protected/favoured non-indigenous people (sus)
Opposition impact on legislative process
- Opposition limited impact
- 90% Bills introduced Gov + assured majority block Private Minister members
- 2015 - Bill Shorten/Tanya Pilibersk’s Marriage Amendment Bill blocked Tony Abbot Liberal-National Coalition majority
- Gov in minority - work with crossbench pass/block disrupts Gov agenda
- 2018: 76 seats, Medevac Bill Zali Steggall - first 109 bill passed without support GOV in LH
- Senate - no gov majority, ‘bloc’ w crossbench make impact
Outline purpose of Chapter 1 Constitution
- Establish jud/leg/exec branches SW
- SOP
Compare the Australian executive with that of non-Westminster system
- AUS - C2, S61 vests exec pwr in Queen, exercisable GG
- US - Art 2, S1 vests exec pwr in Presid + VP
- Diff - flexib pwrs than spec, declare war/app fed judges Cab app (more ratified exec pwr)
Outline role of the Governor-General performed under Section 57
- Dissolve both houses in event house deadlocked bc Senate refuses pass them in current form HOR
- ABCC Bill 2016