Poli Midterm 2 Flashcards
Barron v Baltimore
Barron sued the city of Baltimore because under the fifth amendment, he had been unconstitutionally deprived of his property. The debate asked the question of whether the Bill of Rights also limits the actions of state governments seem to have been settled in this case.
What did Barron v Baltimore confirm?
Dual citizenship- that each American was both a citizens of the national government and separately a citizen of the United States
Amendment 1- Bill of Rights
Freedoms, petitions, assembly
Amendment 2- Bill of Rights
Right to bare arms
Amendment 3-Bill of Rights
Quartering of soldiers
Amendment 4- Bill of Rights
Search and arrest
Amendment 5- Bill of Rights
Rights in criminal cases
Amendment 6- Bill of Rights
Right to a fair trial
Amendment 7- Bill of Rights
Rights in civil cases
Amendment 8- Bill of Rights
Bail, fines, punishment
Amendment 9- Bill of Rights
Rights retained by the people
Amendment 10- Bill of Rights
States’ rights
Define Civil Rights
Regulations on who can participate in the political process and civil society and how they can participate Ex: the right to vote
Define Civil Liberties
Protections of citizens from improper governmental action Ex: freedom of religion
Citizens United (2010)
In Citizens United v Federal Election, the court ruled that corporate funding of independent election ads could not be limited under the first amendment, corporations and unions could spend an unlimited amount of money on ads and political tools
Dual Citizenship
That each American was both a citizen of the national government and separately a citizen of the United States
Establishment Clause (1st Amendment)
The first amendment clause that states “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion”
Later this lead to the lemon test
What are the different interpretations of the Establishment Clause?
- First amendment author’s view: The clause only prohibits the government from establishing an official church
- A “accommodationist view”: holds that the government may not take sides among competing religions, but it is not prohibited from providing assistance to religious institutions or ideas so long as it shows no favoritism
- The most commonly held view today that is the “wall of separation” between church and state that the government cannot breach
First Amendment Define
Freedom of speech and the press, “Congress SHALL make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people to PEACEABLY assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.”
Fourteenth Amendment
Suggest that it was almost perfectly designed to impose the Bill of Rights on the states and reverse Barron v Baltimore
“All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside”
Explanation of quote: provides for a single national citizenship, which at a minimum means that civil liberties should not vary drastically from state to state
Equal protection clause: Separate but equal, applied to Plessy v Ferguson
The Spirit of the 14th amendment
To nationalize the Bill of Rights by nationalizing the definition of citizenship
-created in response to the Barron v Baltimore case- due process clause, gave rights to the states
-no state shall make or enforce any law which shall restrict your rights
-no state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges of the citizens of the United States
-the last clause, the equal protection clause, has transformed the civil rights in the United States by creating the foundation for equal rights for women, African Americans, etc.
Free Exercise Clause (1st Amendment)
Protects the right of citizens to believe and practice whatever religion they choose, and protects the right to be a nonbeliever “or prohibiting the free exercise thereof”/ have not drawn a test for it yet
Free Speech
First amendment, in 1939 freedom of speech was given extraordinary constitutional status when the Supreme Court declared that any legislation attempting to restrict these fundamental freedoms would be “subjected to a more exacting judicial scrutiny…than are most other types of legislation.” By establishing this principle, the court in effect signaled that the democratic political process must be protected at almost any cost.
Griswold v Connecticut
Violated the 14th amendment, the sphere of privacy was drawn in earnest in 1965, when the Court ruled that a Connecticut statue forbidding the use of contraceptives violated the right of marital privacy
Lemon Test
A rule articulated in Lemon v Kurtzman that says governmental action with respect to religion is permissible if it is secular in purpose, does not lead to excessive entanglement of government with religion, and neither promotes nor inhibits the practice of religion. This is generally used in relation to governmental aid to religious schools
Prior Restraint
An effort by a government agency to block publication of material by a newspaper or magazine, censorship
Right to Privacy
The right to be left alone, which has been interpreted by the Supreme Court to entail individual access to birth control and abortions
Selective Incorporation
Adding provisions to the bill of rights such as freedom of press, religion, assembly
This one-by-one application of the provisions of the Bill of Rights
Double Jeopardy: helped establish the principle of selective incorporation of the Bill of Rights
Strict Scrutiny
the strictest standard of judicial review of a government’s actions, in which the government must show that the law serves as a “compelling state interest”
It implies that speech will be protected almost absolutely
15th Amendment
gives African Americans voting rights, and during Reconstruction the federal government enforced those rights.
Black southerners had little hope of changing their state laws because the laws worked in the favor of state legislators. Also, congress was reluctant to pass federal legislation to enforce the 15th amendment. The supreme court finally took action which struck down the White primary in Smith v Allwright, asserting the federal government’s power to intervene in the state’s conduct of elections in order to protect the voting rights of Black Americans.
19th Amendment
legally guarantees American women the right to vote
Civil Rights v Civil Liberties
civil liberties are restrictions on government, and they restrain the collective decision making of the people as expressed through the decisions of governmental institutions, civil rights are rules that government must follow in regard to the treatment of individuals, especially concerning participation in political and social life. Civil rights also shape collective action and decision making but in a different way. Civil rights regulate who can participate in the political process and civil society and how they participate. Ex: who can vote, serve in office, granted a trial, or serve on juries, and when and how citizens can petition the government. Civil rights also encompasses how people are treated in employment, education, and other aspects of American society.
Civil rights are guaranteed in both federal and state constitutions. The federal constitution provided the right to be represented in Congress, established who can serve in congress and become president, and guaranteed habeas corpus for all people. The Bill of Rights helped define civil rights further, especially the right of all persons to due process of law, guaranteed in the 5th amendment.
Civil rights are not only defined by laws or constitutional interpretation but are highly contextual.
Civil rights are the rules that the government must follow in regard to the treatment of individuals when making collective decisions.
Who, what, and how much?
Cognitive Liberation
A transformation of consciousness within a significant segment of the aggrieved population- McAdam
Collective Action
American women began to engage in collective action to advance their political and social rights, including the right to vote.
Declaration of Sentiments
asserted that women were entitled to rights in every way equal to those of men. Key women present at the meeting were individuals who would later lead the movement for women’s civil rights: Elizabeth Stanton, Lucretia Mott, Mary Ann McClintock, and abolitionist leader Frederick Douglas
Desegregation/ Segregation (de facto/ de jure)
De jure segregation: racial segregation that is a direct result of law or official policy.
De facto: racial segregation that is not a direct result of law or governmental policy but a reflection of residential patterns, income distributions, or other social factors
A decade of frustration followed Brown v Board of education and that adjunction alone would not succeed in desegregating American society.