POLI 324 Flashcards
Comparative Politics of Africa
What is Chimamanda Adichie’s main argument?
- There has been a recurrent single story and impression of Africa in the West, a story of poverty, pity, and negativity
- False story of everyone in Africa dying of poverty and AIDS, and unable to speak for themselves and waiting to be saved by a white foreigner
- John Locke: referred to Africans as ‘beasts who have no houses’, his writing represents the beginning of a tradition of telling African stories in the West
- It is impossible to talk about the single story without talking about power
- Power is the ability to tell the story of another person and make it the definitive story of that person
- The single story creates stereotypes, which are not necessarily untrue but rather incomplete
When did Sudan gain independence from Britain?
1956
What is the difference between North and South Sudan according to John Lee Anderson?
- South Sudan: tropical climate, inhabited by African Christians
- North Sudan: desert climate, inhabited by Muslims of mixed Arab and African descent (but identify as Arab)
- The North and South have historically been divided with their own tribes, traditions, and loyalties
What happened to Sudan after independence?
- The new regime became dominated by northern elites and discriminated harshly against the South, causing decades of civil war
- The British governed the north and south separately which reinforced their differences
- Government refused to grant autonomy or political participation to the south, led to violent resistance
- Gov also pushed for the Arabization and Islamization of the country, seen by southerners as an attack on their identity, traditions, and autonomy
What happened in 1989 in Sudan?
- General Omar Al-Bashir seized power in a military coup
- Attacked the main southern rebel group, the SPLA
- Conflict killed over 2 million people, many by starvation and displacement
- South of Sudan became a disaster area sustained by foreign aid
What happened in 2005 in Sudan?
UN got Bashir to sign a peace agreement with the SPLA, ended the long civil war
Describe Sudan post civil war according to John Lee Anderson
- Undeveloped wasteland, high child mortality rates
- Most citizens poor and illiterate
- Real source of conflict: racial and tribal identity. Northern Sudanese regard themselves as Arab and look down on the South. South Sudan also has over 40 tribes and is a highly divided society
- 2011: the State of South Sudan was officially created
Africa has often been described as a kleptocracy. Explain this.
Government by thieves, defined by corruption, lack of laws and regulations, government that chronically steals from its people and exploits the population
What is Severine Autesserre’s main argument?
-3 central narratives dominate public discourse on the Congo
- These narratives benefit Western policymakers because they offer clear explanations to complex violence
- Focus on these narratives has led to unintended consequences such as increases in human rights violations
- Autesserre critiques the way public discourse has been shaped by simplified narratives- they prevent a more nuanced understanding of the conflict
What is Narrative 1 according to Severine Autesserre?
- Primary cause of violence = the illegal exploitation of mineral resources
- Congolese minerals fund armed groups who commit atrocities against the population
- PROBLEM: focus on mineral exploitation overlooks other causes of violence such as land conflict, poverty, and corruption
- Congolese intellectuals argue violent competition for power among Congolese leaders as a more accurate cause of violence
- Advocacy of the mineral problem has forced companies doing business in Congo to consider whether their actions fuel the conflict (eg tech companies that export coltan)
- Unintended consequence: international efforts regarding minerals have deprived vulnerable populations of their sole means of livelihood
What is Narrative 2 according to Severine Autesserre?
- Main consequence of the mineral problem: sexual abuse of women and girls
- Journalists and aid workers have labelled the Congo as the most dangerous place on earth to be a woman
- Sexual violence has become a buzzword for the international community
- Narrative of sexual violence dominates because the emotional impact is particularly strong, it resonates with audiences worldwide
- PROBLEM: women and girls are singled out as the only victims of violence at the expense of others, eg child soldiers or victims of nonsexual torture
What is Narrative 3 according to Severine Autesserre?
- Central solution to violence in Congo: extending state authority
- UN peacekeeping mission wants Congo to extend its authority in unstable provinces
- Belief that contemporary problems are domestic issues that Congo would be able to resolve if it were not a failed state
- PROBLEM: The Congolese state remains a predatory structure that commits the majority of human rights violations against the population
What is Severine Autesserre’s proposed solution to the conflict in Congo?
Resolving land conflict, promoting inter-community reconciliation and economic development, ensuring state authorities respect human rights, fighting corruption
When did the Congo transition to peace and democracy?
2006: new constitution implemented and democratic elections
- However, insecurity has increased, there are more internally displaced people, widespread human rights abuses by armed groups, worsening poverty
What western assumption does Congo disprove?
The assumption that once a country becomes democratic, all subsequent problems go away. Congo is a prime example that this assumption is false because democratic government continues to coexist with ongoing violence and instability