POL113 Study Flashcards

1
Q

. What populists support and what they oppose

A

Populists generally support policies and rhetoric that appeal to “the common man” versus what they perceive as a corrupt elite. They often oppose the current political establishment, globalization, and immigration policies that they consider threatening to national integrity or identity.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Definition of populism. What are its main features?

A

Populism is a political approach that strives to appeal to ordinary people who feel their concerns are disregarded by established elite groups. The main features include: - A dichotomous view of society (the pure people vs. the corrupt elite) - A general opposition to the established political system - A direct connection between the populist leader and the people, often bypassing traditional media and political institutions

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

The reasons why populism is on the rise?

A

Reasons for the rise of populism may include: - Economic dislocation and inequality - Perceived loss of national sovereignty - Reaction to rapid social changes, including immigration and cultural shifts - Distrust in traditional political institutions and elites

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

How populist political parties govern once they come to power? According to Mueller.

A

According to Jan-Werner Mueller, populist political parties can be characterized by an anti-pluralist stance when they govern, claiming they alone represent the people. They often undermine checks and balances, disregard the rule of law, and delegitimize political opposition.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What are the core/main claims of populism according to Mueller?

A

Mueller identifies the core claims of populism as the idea that they, and only they, represent the will of the people. This leads them to view all opposition as illegitimate and to believe that they have a moral monopoly on political representation.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Mueller’s definition of discriminatory legalism

A

Discriminatory legalism refers to a technique used by populist leaders to selectively enforce legal norms and rules to punish political opponents while ignoring illegal actions by their allies.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Mueller’s definition/account of how populists colonize the state once they gain power.

A

Mueller argues that populists colonize the state by placing loyalists in key positions, dismantling systemic checks and balances, and creating an environment in which state resources are used to maintain political power.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

According to Friedman, what principles allows us to benefit from government/minimize its negative/dangerous impact?

A

Friedman suggests that principles which limit the role of government and ensure individual freedoms—such as a free-market economy, a rule of law, the decentralization of power, the protection of individual rights, and a clear and limited scope of government—help to minimize the potential negative impacts of government.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Proper role of government according to Milton Friedman.

A

Milton Friedman believed that the proper role of government is to protect the freedom of individuals, enforce the rule of law and property rights, and control the money supply to prevent inflation. Apart from these, the government should have a minimalistic intervention in economic affairs.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

The markets vs. the state. What are markets able to supply? The virtues/strengths of relying on the markets.

A

Markets are typically able to supply a wide range of goods and services efficiently due to competition. The virtues of relying on the markets include:

Efficiency: Resources are allocated based on supply and demand.
Innovation: Competitive pressures encourage innovation.
Consumer Sovereignty: Consumers ultimately drive what is produced by their purchase choices.
Flexibility: Markets can adjust more readily to changes in consumer preferences and technology.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Hayek’s criticism of conservatism (the two slides at the end of the lecture on libertarianism)

A

Friedrich Hayek’s criticism of conservatism centers on its potential to impede progress and innovation. While conservatism may defend liberty from rapid changes, it can also resist necessary reformations. Hayek argues that conservatism, by being bound to traditions, may limit the growth fostered by a dynamic market economy and the spontaneous order that he advocates.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

The main features of Schumpeter’s account of classical democracy

A

Joseph Schumpeter’s account of classical democracy emphasized the role of the common will and the common good in guiding political decisions. According to this view, democracy is a process where the people determine their political leaders, who act in the best interests of the populace, supposedly reflecting a collective will. Classical democracy rests on the political virtue and participation of the citizenry.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Schumpeter’s account of human nature in politics and why Schumpeter thinks it does not support classical democracy?

A

Schumpeter criticized the classical model, arguing that it was premised on an unrealistic understanding of human nature. He held that average citizens lack the specialized knowledge, emotional detachment, and interest level required to make the continuous, informed, and rational decisions classical democracy demands. This led him to conclude that classical democracy was an unattainable ideal.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Why the classical account (democracy) survived despite its shortcomings/defects?

A

The classical account of democracy has endured, partially because of its inherent appeal—it emphasizes noble ideals such as political equality, citizen participation, and the common good. This model also persists in political discourse and educational curricula due to its historic root in the democratic practices of places like ancient Athens.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Why does Schumpeter criticize the classical model of democracy? What arguments does he make against it?

A

Schumpeter criticizes the classical model for being idealistic and unachievable. He argues that individuals are not necessarily driven by the rational pursuit of the common good, but rather by individual interests and emotions. Furthermore, he suggests that citizens are ill-equipped for the direct governance the classical model requires, lacking the time, resources, and inclination for such engagement.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Schumpeter’s account of minimalist democracy and its main features

A

Schumpeter describes minimalist (or “realist”) democracy primarily as a method for selecting leaders. Key features of this model include: - Free, competitive elections - Institutional checks and balances - The electorate’s role reduced to choosing among competing leaders or parties - The professionalization of policy-making, leaving complex decisions to elected officials and bureaucrats - Reduced emphasis on the “will of the people” as a concrete policy guide

17
Q

Citizens’ rationality in different contexts (human nature in politics)

A

Citizens may exhibit rationality differently in various contexts due to factors such as information availability, cognitive biases, influence of mass media, and the complexity of political decisions. Schumpeter and others suggest that citizens behave more rationally as consumers in markets than as voters in political processes, since market choices are often more directly linked to their personal interests and have more immediate and tangible consequences.

18
Q

Schumpeter’s commitment to minimalist democracy

A

Schumpeter supported minimalist democracy because he believed it was a more practical and realistic governance system than the classical ideal. It limits the demand on citizens’ time and expertise and leverages the specialized skills of elected officials and bureaucrats to make complex policy decisions.

19
Q

Main features/aspects of minimalist democracy

A

Key aspects include: - Electoral competition as the defining characteristic - A pragmatic view of politics as an arena for competing interests - Emphasis on procedures for selecting leaders rather than the direct implementation of the popular will - A focus on individual freedoms and rule of law over the concept of a common will

20
Q

Different models of democracy discussed in the first part of the democracy lecture.

A

1.Pluralist and neo-pluralist models
2.Participatory democracy
3.Legal democracy
4.Competitive elitism (minimalist)

21
Q

Why does G.A. Cohen find socialism attractive?

A

G.A. Cohen admired socialism for its ethos of equality, community, and fairness. He argued that socialism allows for a society organized around the welfare of all its members and oppresses neither the workers nor the consumers because it eliminates the power dynamics and exploitative nature inherent in capitalist systems.

22
Q

Different versions of the equality of opportunity discussed by Cohen

A

Cohen discussed the concepts like “bourgeois equality of opportunity,” which requires eliminating formal and legal barriers to success, and “left-liberal equality of opportunity” or “fair equality of opportunity,” which also entails compensating for social and economic disadvantages to level the playing field.

23
Q

Cohen’s two socialist principles

A

Cohen’s socialist principles may refer to his views on egalitarianism: (1) The socialist principle of community, which rejects economic structures that cause power relations and class divisions; and (2) the principle of equality of opportunity, which aims for a society where each individual’s chance of success is not influenced by factors such as socioeconomic background.

24
Q

Oakeshott’s definition of conservatism/its main features

A

Michael Oakeshott viewed conservatism not as a creed or doctrine but as a disposition, valuing tradition and order and exhibiting a general skepticism toward the idea of transformational change based on abstract principles. Conservatism for him emphasized the importance of the familiar, the tried and tested over the new and unknown, and the view that change should be evolutionary rather than revolutionary.

25
Q

The market globalist arguments covered in the final lecture

A
  1. Globalization is about the
    liberalization and global
    integration of markets
  2. Globalization is inevitable and
    irreversible
  3. Nobody is in charge of globalization
  4. Globalization benefits everyone
  5. Globalization furthers the spread of
    democracy in the world
    These would typically highlight the benefits of globalization from an economic perspective, emphasizing the growth, increased wealth, efficiency, and innovation that can arise from a global market. Market globalists advocate for the removal of trade barriers, liberalization of economies, and the belief that open markets lead to mutual benefits internationally.
26
Q

The justice globalist arguments discussed in the lecture

A

Justice globalists emphasize fairness, equity, and environmental sustainability in the discourse of globalization. They often advocate for policies that protect workers’ rights, the environment, and ensure that the benefits of globalization are shared more equally, including supporting a redistribution of wealth from richer to poorer nations.

27
Q

The new global deal demanded by the justice globalists

A

The “new global deal” sought by justice globalists would likely involve comprehensive measures to redress inequalities generated by global capitalism. These would include international agreements to secure labor rights, environmental protections, and progressive taxation to fund global public goods.

28
Q

Why Susan Okin rejects group rights? Under what circumstances are group rights acceptable?

A

Susan Moller Okin was concerned that group rights, especially in the context of minority cultures, often serve to entrench traditional gender roles and can undermine the rights of women within these groups. She argued that group rights are acceptable if they do not violate the individual rights of the group’s members, particularly the rights of vulnerable members such as women.

29
Q

Why Susan Okin rejects Kymlicka’s multiculturalism

A

Okin criticized Will Kymlicka’s theory of multiculturalism for not paying enough attention to the potential for group rights to perpetuate intra-group inequalities, especially gender inequalities. She argues that Kymlicka did not account sufficiently for the ways in which group rights could clash with the feminist goals of equality.

30
Q

The relationship between capitalism and freedom according to Friedman.

A

Milton Friedman argued in “Capitalism and Freedom” that capitalism is a necessary condition for political freedom because it preserves the opportunity for personal choice, limits the power of the state, and provides a check against centralized power through decentralized economic decision-making.

31
Q

How populism can undermine liberal democracy

A

Populism can undermine liberal democracy by challenging its fundamental principles—such as the rule of law, minority rights, and the separation of powers—with its majoritarian approach that presents the will of the majority as the singular expression of the people’s will. Populist leaders may erode democratic institutions by consolidating power and marginalizing dissent.

32
Q

The Asian values argument

A

The Asian values argument suggests that Asian cultures emphasize community and social harmony over individual liberty, and as such, a different conception of human rights and democracy is more appropriate for Asian nations than typical Western models. This often serves to justify non-democratic governance practices in some Asian states.

33
Q

Amartya Sen’s response to the Asian values argument

A

Amartya Sen contested the Asian values argument by asserting that values of liberty and democracy are not solely Western but universal. He further contends that experiences across Asia demonstrate the compatibility and desire for democratic institutions and human rights.

34
Q

The conservative disposition to change

A

Conservatives generally prefer society’s evolution to its reformation, suggesting that change should be incremental, organic, and emerge conservatively from the existing traditions and societal norms.

35
Q

Oakeshott’s conservative man

A

For Oakeshott, the conservative man is not ideologically driven but is defined by his disposition. This individual is characterized by a distrust of rationalist ideologies, preferring the familiar to the unknown and novelty. They believe in continuity and stability, seeking change only when it conserves or improves the societal order, often relying on tradition and accumulated wisdom.