Planning Flashcards
What is PoD – Production-oriented Design?
Production-oriented Design (PoD) adjusts product concepts and realization of their design to the requirements of production - including variance and variety.
It defines the basis for a cost-efficient Production
What is the definition of PoD – Production-oriented Design?
PoD is a continuous process for comprehensive product design improvement with regard to safety, quality, productivity and costs.
What are PoD findings based on?
Production-oriented Design (PoD) adjusts product concepts and realization of their design to the requirements of production - including variance and variety.
- Parts analyses (own parts and those of competitors)
- Quality analyses
- Lessons learned
- Further PoD sources and sensor
What are the objectives of PoD?
- Optimization of the resources and manpower needed for series production (e.g. re-use of existing production equipment)
- Stable production processes
- Improved quality
- Ensuring good ergonomics and construction feasibility
What are the benefits of PoD?
- Work content determined by product design
- Significant reduction of part numbers
- Implementation of Poka Yoke principles
- Take care of people needs
- Economical equipment order decisions
If a product contains fewer parts it will take less time for production, thereby reducing what?
Costs
The reduction of the number of parts has the added benefit of generally reducing what?
the total cost of parts
If the parts are provided with features which make it easier to grasp, move, orient and insert them, this will also reduce which two KPIs?
production time (eHPU) and production costs
Production oriented Design also gives the opportunity to support the workforce with what other elements?
- ergonomic solutions
- provides a guideline for economical planning, commissioning and order decisions
What are benefits of production-oriented design?
- ergonomic workplace design
- reduced number of parts per vehicle
- cost-efficient production
What is the definition of eHPV and mv?
The key performance indicator eHPV measures…
• … the design-related work content of a vehicle and is the
responsibility of Development (calculated time value from production planning)
The key performance indicator mv measures…
• …the non-design-related work content of a vehicle
Which statements regarding eHPV and eHPU true?
- eHPV: a whole vehicle is considered
- eHPU is part of HPU
- eHPU: a unit of a truck (e.g. an engine) is considered
Where do you start improving your eHPU-mv-ratio?
• reducing mv
Which activities are considered eHPU and which are mv?
eHPU
• adhesive bonding
• riveting
• screw driving
mv
• cleaning
• picking up material
• unpacking of parts
What two elements need to be improved for the overall optimization of productivity?
Both the product (eHPU) and the process (mv) must be improved
What are some example of how to improve the product design and thus the eHPU?
- Reducing number of parts
- Type of attachment
- Accessibility
- Ergonomics
- Fault prevention principles
For the reduction of eHPU, the focus is on which area?
The focus is on production, further departments support the value-adding process
Intensive involvement of production personnel in development meetings and prototype part evaluations is important
For the reduction of eHPU, the most important design element is what?
the value-adding time needed for assembly (“One touch production”)
For the reduction of eHPU, what are examined and guaranteed during the development process?
Principles of standard assembly
For cost comparisons, what is considered when evaluating the design, not only the price of the parts?
Process chain
The standardized planning process follows what logic?
CVDS- Commercial Vehicle Development System
In the planning process of a new project an overall timeline is created. The manufacturing engineering (ME) has defined what?
standardized planning process, synchronized to the CVDS by the quality gates
What is Commercial Vehicle Development System (CVDS)?
CVDS is the fundamental approach on how we set-up, control and deliver product projects in Daimler Trucks.
CVDS provides the basis for individual project leader schedules with all steering relevant processes.
What are the goals of CVDS?
- Methods for planning, reporting and steering are integrated into an all embracing project management.
- Transparency within truck and aggregate projects is increased.
- Worldwide standardization of the product creation process.
- Continuous improvement of the product creation process by product project application and role specialists.
The standardized planning process depends mainly on what?
the complexity of the commodities and its specific implementation time
e.g. different implementation time for CiW (Cab in White) as for Assembly, however same SOP (Start of Production).
What are the process steps for CVDS?
- Strategy development
- Pre-planning
- Concept planning
- Detailed planning
- Realization phase
What are elements of strategy development in CVDS?
Benchmarking (e.g. PoD) and best practice
Development of production tech. concept
What is a Lean Conformity Check (LCC)?
Lean Conformity Checks (LCCs) serve to determine the degree of implementation of certain TOS-Standard-Principles in a specific planning phase or in a production
The LCC is carried out based on what?
requirements in order to derive further fields of action
What principle specifications does the LCC use?
TOS Standard Principles
Lean Conformity Checks (LCCs) are integrated in what?
CVDS
They ensure that lean principles within the planning process are considered
The Station Development Process supports LCC.
In the station development process a mock up of a what is developed?
future work station
The procedure of the station development follows what logic?
PDCA
Plan in the Station Development Process is what?
Planning of improved process
Processes are simulated based on current planning status (“layout freeze” status)
“Do” in the Station Development Process is what?
Simulation of planned CiW & Logistic processes
During simulation walk ways, process times and material presentation are evaluated
“Check” in the Station Development Process is what?
Evaluation of process steps
Facts and figures identified by the team show need for process improvements
“Act” in the Station Development Process is what?
Directions for improvement
Countermeasures for process improvement are developed within the team
What are some impacts of using simple equipment to help create a station mock up?
- The station has been built up in 1:1 scale – pillars, logistic karts, welding station, equipment
- Besides card board, small containers, large containers, aluminum beams, tubes etc. are used
- Creativity of team needs to be stimulated
- Speed for build up increased day by day
What are elements of pre-planning in CVDS?
- Rough production concept
- Analysis of location factors - input from project lead - premise
- Creation of block layout
- Cost estimation
- Timeline
- Project approval preparation
What are elements of concept planning in CVDS?
- RFQ (request for quotation) and selection of supplier for planning support
- Concept development and evaluation of production and Logistics process
- Concept definition incl. technology selection
- Production concept layout
- Cost verification
- Timeline
- Project Spec Book production
What are elements of “detailed planning” in CVDS?
- Detailed process planning
- Manpower planning
- Validation by simulations and conformity checks
What are elements of the “realization phase” in CVDS?
- Installation coordination at supplier incl. Pre acceptance
- Installation coordination at plant
- Commissioning
- Training concept & documents e.g. in partnership with the equipment supplier
- Ramp-up incl. performance test & final acceptance
- Hand over to operations
- Lessons Learned
Q-Gate 1 marks the handover from where to where?
Planning department (ME) to Operations
Q-Gate1 marks the handover from Planning department (ME) to Operations. What are two options for this handover?
Model 1– Turnkey (separate responsibilities)
Model 2– Landlord (incremental behavior)
Model1 (“turnkey“) - separate responsibilities handover entails what?
- Planning purchases, set up, commissions and releases the equipment
- Planning ensures capabilities for serial production (takt time, output, OEE, part quality)
- Planning hands over the equipment at SOP in a “turnkey“ state
Model 2 (“Landlord“) - incremental handover entails what?
Planning is responsible for the concept to purchase
Commissioning and acceptance is done by planning and the affected areas of future operations etc.
Operations is involved into commissioning, acceptance and problem solving in an early phase – planning hands over total responsibility incrementally
Which activities happen in which step of the planning process of Truck Assembly Plants?
Pre-Planning
• Cost estimation
Concept Planning
• Project Spec Book
Detailed Planning
• Validation by simulations and conformity checks
Realization Phase
• Hand over to operations
What are the process steps for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
- Feasibility study and choice of site location
- Market requirements
- Rough Plant planning
- Design of layout options
- Layout evaluation and selection
- Implementation of new layout
How is the process for the creation and improvement of a plant layout? Put the steps into the correct order.
- Feasibility study and choice of site location
- Market requirements
- Rough Plant planning
- Design of layout options
- Layout evaluation and selection
- Implementation of new layout
Feasibility study and choice of site location entails what for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
- Make or buy?
- Choice of site location
- Production network
- Economic framework conditions
Market requirements entails what for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
- Demand analysis
- Trend analysis
- Capacity planning
Rough Plant planning entails what for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
• Future value stream:
o Product families
o Work content
o Detailing of future value stream
• Logistics concept
Design of layout options entails what for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
• Design principles: o Plant o Hall o Line and department o Workplace and machine
Layout evaluation and selection entails what for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
- Value benefit analysis
* Selection of layout
Implementation of new layout entails what for the creation and improvement of the Plant layout?
- Planning
- Relocation
- Ramp-up
What two analyses form a key foundation for the design of a Plant layout?
The demand and trend analysis
What does the trend analysis forecast?
The trend analysis forecasts • Volume development • Variant development • Price development • Functionality development • Expectations re. delivery time
What does the demand analysis forecast?
The demand analysis forecasts • Seasonal fluctuations • Product life cycle/age • Variant postponement • Product families
Alongside the short-term effects on the Plant design, the demand and trend analyses show what?
the necessary long-term adaptations for the future layout
What are some options for reacting to trend developments?
Volume is sinking..
- Orientation toward future base capacity
Product diversity is increasing..
- Integrate extendibility of variance (individualization) into planning
25% price reduction forecast in the next five years
- Include price developments in planning, e.g. in production methods (objective = to reduce costs [CIP])
Increase functionality will increase production time of the products
- Integrate extendibility of work content into planning
The Plant Layout and the organization must be designed how in order to enable appropriate reaction to fluctuations in demand?
Flexibly
What predictions can be derived from a trend or demand analysis?
trend analysis
• Price development
• Variant development
• Volume development
demand analysis
• Product life cycle/age
• Product families
What are possible reactions for fluctuations in demand?
- increase working hours
* reduction of takt time
What are possible adaption strategies to the following trend developments?
volume is sinking
• Orientation toward future base capacity
product diversity is increasing
• Integrate extendibility of variance (individualization) into planning
25% price reduction forecast in the next 5 years
• Include price developments in planning
increased functionality will increase production time of the products
• Integrate extendibility of work content into planning
What are options for closing the gap in demand capacity?
Organizational:
• Increase working hours
o Overtime
o Additional shift
• Reduction of takt time
• Improve processes
o Quality levels
o Availability levels
o Reduction of waste
Technical:
• Investment in capacity for order peaks (only expedient after
above levers exhausted)
What is the ideal Plant layout from the TOS perspective?
The best possible specifications of the TOS philosophy would be a fishbone design
What are the features of a fishbone diagram?
- Smooth, synchronized production in a string of pearls over the whole process chain
- Delivery of purchased parts and sub-assemblies in a synchronized sequence
- Pull production with demand oriented, high-frequency material supply in small quantities
- No buffer inside the Plant, direct connection of sub-processes to the main line in one-piece flow
- Continual product flow without buffer and maximum flexibility
- Production in customer takt in all production steps
- Minimized order lead time, shorter than customer expectation
- Material flow routes are short and do not cross
In reality the design of Plant layouts is always a compromise between what?
between TOS requirements and real general conditions
What are TOS requirements for Plant layouts?
- Integration of all relevant TOS methods
- Lean and stable processes with minimum stock levels
- Synchronized value stream in customer takt
- High machine availability (OEE) with min change over times
- Logistics in continual flow
- Smooth volume flows
- Max flexibility
- Min variability
- Waste-free processes
- built quality instead of proved quality
What are factors to consider for Plant design?
- Optimum compromise between existing general conditions and the TOS requirements.
- The layout design not only takes external factors into account e.g. market requirements), but also internal ones (e.g. organization)
What are TOS requirements for General conditions?
- Product design/variety of variants/priority diagram
- Vertical integration
- Sales fluctuation
- Construction-related restriction
- Brown field/green field
- Political conditions including ability to outsource
- Supplier integration and ability to deliver
- Ergonomics
Think about the following examples and think about whether they are categorized as waste, variability or inflexibility?
waste
• Large storage areas
• waiting times between processes
• long distances between assembly lines and storage facilities
variability
• No regulated delivery window
• Complicated material supply
• Traffic jams on transport routes
inflexibility
• No extendible area
• Inflexible work-time models
• narrow pillars
What are the key design factors for green field and brown field planning?
- Organizational specifications
- Technical specifications
- Logistical specifications
Which of the following statements are true regarding the specifications? You need to consider …
- … the future value stream.
* … the takt time.
What are some examples of waste in an unfavorable layout?
- Large storage areas, buffers
- High costs for transportation
- Long routes between processes and halls
- Processes positioned far apart, many storage areas
- High effort for controlling of processes
- High waiting times between processes
- Large rework areas
What are some examples of variability in an unfavorable layout?
- Complicated material supply
- Traffic jams on transport routes
- No regulated delivery window
- Material supply via bottlenecks (in accordance with equipment used)
- Quality-sensitive equipment at critical locations
- process content
- process flow
- process duration
What are some examples of inflexibility in an unfavorable layout?
- Inflexible work-time models
- No extendible area
- Inflexible construction
- Multi-story construction
- Pits/columns/bottlenecks/dead ends
- Type of conveyor
- Central machines/supply
- Legal restrictions
For both green field and brown field planning what three key design factors do we need to take into account?
- Technical specifications
- Logistical specifications
- Organizational specifications
What are the characteristics in green field planning?
Technical specifications
• New design of value streams and processes
• Layout approaches the ideal value stream
Logistical specifications
• New planning of the information and product flows
• Integration of new suppliers and supply concepts
Organizational specifications
“Everything” can be specified completely from scratch.
It is important to distinguish between planning of new and existing products. This goes for plant planning as well. We call this distinction what in Rough Plant Planning?
green field (new plants) and brown field (existing plants).
What are the characteristics in brown field planning?
Technical specifications
• Value-stream adjustment due to existing processes (ass. sequence)
• Layout adjustment due to structural specifics (e.g. buildings)
• Many compromises on the route to the future value stream
Logistical specifications
• Consider existing supplier agreements
• Existing information systems must be adjusted
Organizational specifications
Clear need for change for radical conversion vs. continuous improvement
What are the 3 columns of rough plant planning?
1st Future Value Stream
2nd Logistics Concept
3rd Organizational Structure
Plant layout has a significant impact on what?
process performances (e.g. eHPV/MV)
Plant layout is a consequence of the processes according to what?
the value streams to build the final product
In a first approach, there should be no restrictions to what?
implement a layout as close as possible to the value stream
What compromises need to be taken when implementing a value stream?
- Short distances between processes vs. expandability
- Space for subassembly close to main line vs. extending distances between processes
- Space for material supply via dock doors vs. building size
- Building size/shape vs. investment & energy costs
What provides the basis for making decisions on the detailed design of the future value stream?
analysis of the variant-related work content
The over-cautious consideration of operational losses can result in what?
excessive capacity requirements on plants and machinery
What is classic dimensioning?
- Determination of target cycle time by means of downward calculation
- All losses in the current form accepted in planning
- Less available time requires rapid, i.e. large and complex machines
What is lean dimensioning?
- Rule of thumb: target cycle time = takt – 10%, corresponding upward calculation**
- Max. permitted losses specified in planning (constant pressure to improve in plan)
- Greater available working time enables use of simple and small machines
1st column of rough plant planning is?
Future value stream
2nd column of rough plant planning is?
Logistics concept
The logistics concept has a key influence on the layout planning.
Aspects relevant to layout in determining the logistics concept are?
A. Receiving & Shipping Area
B. Delivery concept
C. Kitting & Warehousing
D. Line feeding
The delivery concept is?
- Supplier Logistics Center (SLC)
- Direct delivery – JIS
- Suppliers’ park/ industrial park
- Trailer park (warehouse on wheels)
Standard Supply Forms
The kitting and warehousing concept is?
- On the line (point of installation)
- Supermarket
- consideration of autonomous processes
Supermarket
The Receiving & Shipping Area concept is?
- Packaging costs
- Returns of empties
- Combination/ separation of goods in and goods out
- Goods-in process (GI control)
- suitable for autonomous equipment (vehicles / robots…)
The line feeding concept is?
- Parts density at point of installation
- Transport routes
- Internal/ external suppliers
- suitable for autonomous equipment (vehicles / robots…)
Line delivery
What are some prerequisites for the logistics concept?
- Lines should run parallel to the building facade
- Direct delivery to stations with a delivery volume > 50 m³ per day and part
- Direct delivery requires a distance of approx. 65 - 90 m between the buildings
When designing internal logistics it is important to ensure what?
minimum distances and easy delivery of large components
3rd column of rough plant planning is what?
Organizational structure
What are the two organizational structures?
- Functional structure
2. Product-oriented structure
What is functional structure?
“performance-oriented” layout:
- Locate similar processes close together
What is product-oriented structure?
“process-oriented” layout:
- Locate upstream and downstream processes as closely to each other as possible
- Layout design with help of “value stream manager”
Layout development takes place on several levels. What are they?
Level 0: Site Level 1: Lean Plant layout Level 2: Lean Building Layout Level 3: Lean Line Layout Level 4: Workplace
What are the levels in layout development? Bring them into the correct order, starting from level 0.
- Site
- Plant
- Building
- Line
- Workplace
What are the technical aspects of Level 1: Lean Plant layout?
- Highly flexible
- Straight material flow
- Expansion areas in several directions with buildings simple to extend
- Fishbone connection of departments/ functions to one another
- Covered/ roofed loading/unloading areas
What are the logistics aspects of Level 1: Lean Plant layout?
• Supplier integration
o Integrated industrial park with connected transportation technology
o JIS, JIT or logistic center (see Reference Value Streams)
• Adequately dimensioned transport routes, access, maneuvering
capabilities
What are the organizational aspects of Level 2: Lean Building Layout?
- Central and accessible communication and quality zones
* central administration area (spine)
What are the technical aspects of Level 2: Lean Building Layout?
• Flexible hall/production facilities
• Production/material flow on one level
• Fishbone connection of ancillary lines to main flow (decoupling only demand-oriented*)
* e.g. before bottlenecks, on tool change and changeover times
What are the logistics aspects of Level 2: Lean Building Layout?
- Docking capabilities for trucks
- Direct, logical material flow without crossings or switches
- Shop stock areas (no buffers)
What are the organizational aspects of Level 2: Lean Building Layout?
- Staff rooms close to workplace
- Sufficient communication areas for info boards, production meetings
- Support areas (e.g. maintenance, tool preparation) close to production
The linking of pre-assemblies to the main line (fishbone, FIFO) has significantly different effects on the building layout than?
a consumption-controlled system (fill-up pull)
What are the technical aspects of Level 3: Lean Line Layout?
- Suitable assembly system
- Flow principle with batch size 1
- Flexible production facilities and media supply/removal
- Automation only where required (quality, weight, work safety, dirt)
- Technical fixed points aligned
- No dead ends, pits, cranes, elevators
- Restricted areas outside the line
- Observance of standard assembly criteria
What are the logistics aspects of Level 3: Lean Line Layout?
- Avoid crossings and switches
- Large-volume fast-moving items at the end of the line
- Driving route suited for delivery by transport train trolleys
- Avoidance of buffer areas
What are the organizational aspects of Level 3: Lean Line Layout?
• Adequate information areas and staff rooms close to workplaces
What are the different effects on the building layout concerning fishbone principle & consumption control via supermarkets?
- Small storage areas
- JIS-capable production
- High control effort consumption control via supermarkets
- Increased space requirements for shop stock
- Increased storage requirement on the line
- Supplier integration via JIT or SLC
What are quantitative performance indicators for the selection of Plat layout?
Investment:
- Construction measures
- Technical building equipment
- Production machines
Running costs:
- Personnel costs
- Logistics costs
- Energy costs
- Capital costs
Time taken to recoup investment
What are the qualitative criteria for the selection of the Plant layout?
Buildings/equipment:
- Flexibility for new equipment
- Layout of ancillary areas
- Space requirements/ consumption
- Future extendibility
- Successor compatibility
Logistics:
- Material flow – internal
- Material flow – external
Assembly process:
- Critical processes
- Accessibility of vehicle
- Transparency/communication
To determine the fulfillment level for Qualitative and quantitative value benefit analysis for layout assessment, the alternatives are assessed using what?
the weighted criteria on a scale. Parallel to this quantitative performance indicators are determined.
What are Future requirements for a Plant layout?
☝️ Realization of one-piece flow across all processes
☝️ Short material routes with as little buffer as possible
☝️ Smooth, synchronized material flows (internal/external)
☝️ Future extendibility
☝️ No monuments (low, flexible level of automation instead of hi-tech, no rigid fixed installations)
☝️ Flexibility of building and equipment for fluctuation in demands and trends
☝️ Handling of multiple product variants on one line
☝️ Handling of small quantities per model variant
☝️ Close involvement of logistics partners
What are quantitative and qualitative criteria for selecting plant layouts?
- Investment
- Buildings/equipment
- Logistics
- Running costs
What is LCA and why is it important?
Low cost automation are self-developed, intelligent automation solutions for logistics, manufacturing processes and assembly.
What are the objectives of LCA?
- Reduction of costs for automation
- Continuous productivity increase
- Reduction in waste, variability and inflexibility
What are the additional potentials that can be realized by means of LCA in addition to reducing the funding requirements?
- Respect for people
- Flexibility
- Consistent quality management
What is respect for people in LCA?
Respect for people
Ensure safety
Ergonomic workplace design
Separate work carried out by persons and machines
What is flexibility in LCA?
Flexibility
… in the case of system modifications
… in the case of short-term adjustments to the environment
What is Consistent quality management in LCA?
Consistent quality management
Improve the quality of the movement sequences
Product quality reflects the process quality
Why do we need Low Cost Automation at Daimler?
LCA facilitates a significant reduction in costs for automation technology
Increase efficiency in all our processes
What is the goal of Low Cost Automation at Daimler?
Goal: Investment costs that are as low as possible and/or reduction in the fixed costs.
What basic principles should be adhered to for the Implementation of LCA?
- Safety, health, & quality requirements shall be adhered to
- Ensure reuse and use of simple, commercially available materials
- First eliminate waste, then implement the simplest of automation options
- Cost-efficient in-house production (amortization period: <1 year)
- It shall be possible to quickly specify and implement the idea (involve employees!).
- Take into account fault prevention (Poka Yoke, Jidoka).
- The idea should be simple* and – where required – can be implemented by internal specialists.
- “simple” means: Avoidance of complicated movement sequences, functions and structures. Keep it simple!
- The solution should be so flexible that it can be converted using in-house means.
Use simple* drive types in the sense of “KARAKURI”. - Rotational, linear and pendular movements that can be realized using simple mechanical elements.
What are the objectives of low cost automation?
- increase of productivity
- reduction in waste, variability and inflexibility
- reduction of costs for automation
Which principles should you follow when implementing LCA?
- First, optimize the process, then implement a simple automation.
- Use in-house solutions.
- Consider poka yoke.
- Use existing energy and transform it into useable movement.
Karakuri is a part of the LCA Basic Principles and describes what?
simple drive types and their usage
karakuri (からくり) is japanese for “mechanisms with wisdom”.
Karakuri puppets are what?
the origin of the idea to create simple automation solutions with a low-cost approach using basic mechanical principles.
karakuri (からくり) is japanese for “mechanisms with wisdom”.
Karakuri uses what?
the existing energy or force and converts this into movement in a simple way
What are the elements of a Karakuri?
- lever
- springs
- excentric wheel
- deflection rollers
- gear wheels
- Gravitational force, Belts etc
Which statements regarding Karakuri are true?
- Karakuri uses the existing energy and converts it into movement in a simple way.
- Low cost automation uses the karakuri principle.
The Redesign Procedure Model consists of which seven steps?
- Process analysis
- Questioning the process
- Check use of LCA
- Check whether a solution already exists somewhere else
- Idea generation
- Implementation
- Test
What is step 1 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 1: The existing process needs to be analyzed
- Analysis (description, layout, TOS snapshot…)
- Chart the walking distances via a spaghetti diagram
- KPI analysis
What is step 2 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 2: The process itself must be questioned
Objective: Reduce waste, then implement simple automation options
Process is non-value adding and also not necessary–Eliminate
Process is value-adding, but cannot be optimized– Keep
Process is non-value adding, but necessary– Optimize
Process is value-adding and can be optimized–Optimize
What is step 3 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 3: The Use of LCA Must Be Gradually Checked
Check need for automation, minimize waste, check use of simple drive types
What is step 4 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 4: Check whether a Solution Already Exists Somewhere Else
• Review already implemented ideas • Further investigate existing solutions (internal/external), e.g.: o Go & see o benchmarking o best-practice sharing
What is step 5 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 5: Creative, Low-Cost Ideas Are Generated
Brainstorming: • Brainstorm & cluster ideas • Make derivations • Mixed groups • No criticism, no idea "killers" • Quantity before quality • All contributions are valid • Let thoughts & ideas run free
Up Side Down Method:
• Ask questions in reverse
• Try not to solve the problem, but try to
rather make it worse
• Note ideas
• Reverse again and generate the solution
What is step 6 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 6: Implemented by CIP Workshop
- Plausibility check regarding idea (actual status, problem, etc.)
- Cost comparison regarding supplier
- Onsite meeting with CI workshop and professional design
- Check whether production is possible with available, simple commercially available materials, then start production)
- Creation of technical documents:
• Operating instructions
• Declaration of conformity
• Requirement specifications
• Fallback concept
• Maintenance concept
• Wiring diagram
• Spare parts list
• Hazard analysis - Acceptance by operator, production engineer, safety engineer, maintenance technician, planner
- Transfer to specialist department (possibly patent application)
- Documentation of solution (best
practice sharing)
What is step 7 of the Redesign Procedure Model?
Step 7: Testing and CIP
- Plan: Try out the solution in the area of
application - Do: Make minor improvements
- Check: Was the initial problem effectively
solved? - Act: Embedding, exchange, sustainability
Do you remember what an AGV is?
• Towing or transport system that is controlled automatically without a driver.
What does FMS stand for?
flexible manpower system
What is a flexible manpower system (FMS)?
A flexible manpower system is a comprehensive and plant-wide work system that can be adjusted to differing demand levels in order to produce with optimal employee productivity in any demand situation.
What could be a problem for companies?
Coordinate their resources as answer of fluctuating customer demand
Fluctuating Customer Demand Makes It Difficult for the Company to Coordinate its Resources. What are the problems?
- Order cancellation
- Fluctuating delivery capacity
- Build-up of stock
- Excessive workload
- Fluctuating workload
Rigid vs. Flexible Capacity Design
Capacities are often designed too rigidly and too high in order to ensure one’s own delivery capacity
What is Flexible capacity adjustment?
Capacity expansion via flexible capacity adjustment
What is Output Flexibility in FMS?
An FMS facilitates high productivity in every demand situation by varying the number of employees in the work system depending on the work content and customer cycle.
What could be a problem for companies?
• Coordinate their resources as answer of fluctuating customer demand
If regular production time is not enough, how can you expand capacity?
- working over-time
- additional shifts
- outsourcing (extended workbench)
How can an FMS help you when the customer demand increases?
• With more workers, takt time can be reduced to fit the customer takt.
There are three levels involved when designing a flexible manpower system, what are they?
- Workplace/machine
- Line/cell
- Plant/shop
How do you use FMS in Practice?
Component production
• FMS systems can be relatively well used
• Depends on the part geometry, layout & machine design
Press shop
• Not a typical application field (automotive industry)
Body shop
• FMS systems can only be used to a limited extent
• Depends on the insertion station design (as U-cell layout)
Paint shop
• Not a typical application field (automotive industry)
Assembly
• FMS systems can be relatively well used
• Depends on the part geometry, layout and workplace design
Which levels do you know when designing a FMS?
- line / cell
- plant / shop
- workplace / machine
In which facilities are FMSs usually used in practice?
- Component production
- Body Shop
- Assembly
What are FMS Principles?
- Workplace and machine design
- Material feed, loading/unloading
- Separation of employee/machine
- Line/cell design
- Synchronization of processes and standard WIP inventory
What is the First Principle: Workplace and Machine Design in FMS?
The systems have a narrow and deep design in order to reduce the walking and reach distances.
- Significant reduction in space requirement and routes for each cycle
- Increase in separation of employee/machine according to FMS
- Better walking time/working hours ratio
- Greater design options
- Alignment of front sides of machines
What is the before and after for ergonomic and uniform working heights?
Before:
Unergonomic posture at some workplaces; Material transport difficult due to changing heights => Employee fatigue
After:
Optimal posture at every workplace; Horizontal material transport (smooth movement) => Better access
What is the Second Principle: Material Feed, loading/unloading?
Optimal Material Feed from Rear
Loading and unloading are facilitated by optimal parts accessibility
Combined Loading and Unloading Processes
Which FMS principles for workplace / machine should you consider?
- uniform working heights
- combined loading and unloading processes
- narrow and deep design
What is Third Principle: Separation of Man and Machine?
The waiting time of personnel is reduced via the decoupling of manual and automated work
Acceptance of machine downtimes