Plan Engagements Flashcards
An internal auditor discovered an error in a receivable due from a major stockholder. The receivable’s balance accounts for less than 1% of the company’s total receivables. Would the auditor be likely to consider the error to be material?
No, if there will be further transactions with this stockholder.
Yes, because a related party is involved.
Yes, if relative risk is low.
No, because a small dollar amount is in error.
Yes, because a related party is involved.
Although encouraged by IIA Standards, which of the following is not usually found in the final internal audit reports?
Auditee’s advanced responses whether valid or not.
Auditee’s noteworthy accomplishments.
Auditee’s corrective action plans.
Auditee’s final comments prior to issuing the final audit report.
Auditee’s noteworthy accomplishments.
The following is the complete text of a deficiency finding included in the internal audit report for a bank:
The late charges were waived on an excessive number of delinquent installment loan payments at the Spring Street Branch. We were informed that an officer does not approve late charge waivers. Approximately $5,000 per year in revenues is being lost. In order to provide a better control over late charges waived and loss of income, we recommend that a lending officer be responsible for waiving late charges and that this approval be in writing.
Which of the following elements of a deficiency finding isnotproperly addressed?
Condition.
Effect.
Cause.
Criteria or standards.
Criteria or standards.
The finance department of a governmental unit has a computer based model for forecasting tax revenue to use in preparing annual budgets. The internal audit group has been asked to audit the model. A reasonable objective of the audit would be to:
Confirm that the model forecasts each kind of revenue within a small percentage of actual revenue.
Verify that for varying input values the model gives results consistent with revenue behavior.
Determine whether the programs used for this year?s forecast were identical to those used in the previous year.
Ensure that the model was modified so that it would have forecasted the previous year?s actual revenue.
Verify that for varying input values the model gives results consistent with revenue behavior.
An audit of an automated accounts receivable function for a single-plant furniture manufacturing company has just been completed. Significant findings include late posting of customers? payments, late mailing of monthly invoices, and erratic follow-up on past-due accounts. Which of the following managers should attend the exit conference for this audit?
Head of the audit team, controller, and vice president of information systems.
Director of internal auditing, chief financial officer, chief executive officer, and vice president of information systems.
Head of the audit team, manager of the accounts receivable department, and manager of the data processing department.
Director of internal auditing, chief operating officer, and controller.
Head of the audit team, manager of the accounts receivable department, and manager of the data processing department.
The internal auditing department encounters a scope limitation from senior management that will affect its ability to meet its goals and objectives for a potential auditee. The nature of the scope limitation should be:
Communicated to management, stating that the limitation will not be accepted because it would impair the audit department’s independence.
Noted in the audit work papers, but the audit should be carried out as scheduled and the scope limitation worked around, if possible.
Communicated, preferably in writing, to the board.
Communicated to the external auditors so they can investigate the area in more detail.
Communicated, preferably in writing, to the board.
Successful communication between the auditor and the auditee partially depends on achieving appropriate emphasis so both parties are aware of the most important points in their discussion. Which of the following approaches would provide themostemphasis in an audit report?
Calm discussion in a conversational tone.
Key points embedded in discussion.
Graphics, repetition, and itemization.
Solid paragraphs and detailed appendices.
Graphics, repetition, and itemization.
Which of the following is not an advantage of issuing an interim report?
Final report-writing time can be minimized.
A formal, written interim report may negate the need for a final report in certain circumstances.
An interim report can be conducted on an informal basis and may be communicated only verbally.
An interim report allows information requiring immediate attention to be communicated.
A formal, written interim report may negate the need for a final report in certain circumstances.
What action should an internal auditor take on discovering that an audit area was omitted from the audit program?
Perform the additional work needed without regard to the added time required to complete the audit.
Continue the audit as planned and include the unforeseen problem in a subsequent audit.
Evaluate whether completion of the audit as planned will be adequate.
Document the problem in the work papers and take no further action until instructed to do so.
Evaluate whether completion of the audit as planned will be adequate.
In the performance of an audit, audit risk is best defined as the risk that an auditor:
May not have the expertise to adequately audit a specific activity.
Might not select documents that are in error as part of the examination.
May fail to detect a significant error or weakness during an examination.
May not be able to properly evaluate an activity because of its poor internal accounting controls.
May fail to detect a significant error or weakness during an examination.
An internal auditor is assigned to perform an audit of the company’s insurance program, including the appropriateness of the approach to minimizing risks to the company. The company self-insures against large casualty losses and health benefits provided for all its employees. The company is a large national firm with over 15,000 employees located in various parts of the country. It uses an outside claims processor to administer its health care program. The company’s medical costs have been rising by approximately 8% per year for the past five years, and management is concerned with controlling them.
Which of the following analytical review procedures would provide themostinsight into the reasonableness of the increase in health care costs?
Develop a comparison of overall health insurance costs incurred by the company with similar costs incurred by companies in the same industry.
Obtain the government index of health care costs for the comparable period of time, and compare the rate of increase with that of the cost per employee incurred by the company.
Obtain a bid from another health care administrator to provide the same administrative services as the current health care administrator.
Develop a comparison of the costs incurred with similar costs incurred by other companies.
Obtain the government index of health care costs for the comparable period of time, and compare the rate of increase with that of the cost per employee incurred by the company.
In the preparation of an audit program, which of the following items is not essential?
The preparation of a budget identifying the costs of resources needed.
A review of material from prior audit reports.
The performance of a preliminary survey.
A review of performance standards set by management.
The preparation of a budget identifying the costs of resources needed.
The scope of an internal audit is initially defined by the: Preliminary survey. Scheduling and time estimates. Audit program. Audit objectives.
Audit objectives.
An audit report recommendation should address what attribute of an audit finding? Cause. Effect. Criteria. Statement of condition.
Cause.
During an exit conference, an auditor and an auditee disagreed about a well-documented audit finding. Which of the following would describe an appropriate manner to handle the situation, assuming that it cannot be resolved prior to issuing the audit report?
Present the finding giving all of the facts and conclusions resulting from the testing.
Change the finding to agree with the auditee’s position.
Present both the audit finding and auditee’s position on the finding.
Defer reporting the item and plan to perform more detailed work during the next audit.
Present both the audit finding and auditee’s position on the finding.
The following data were gathered during an internal auditor’s investigation of the reason for a material increase in bad debts expenses. In preparing a report of the finding, each of the items might be classified as criteria, cause, condition, effect, or background information.
1.Very large orders require management’s approval of credit.
2.Audit tests showed that sales personnel regularly disregard credit guidelines when dealing with established customers.
3.A monthly report of write-offs is prepared but distributed only to the accounting department.
4.Credit reports are used only on new accounts.
5.Accounting department records suggest that uncollectible accounts could increase by 5% for the current year.
6.The bad debts loss increased by $100,000 during the last fiscal year.
7.Even though procedures and criteria were changed to reduce the amount of bad-debt write-offs, the loss of commissions due to written-off accounts has increased for some sales personnel.
8.Credit department policy requires the review of credit references for all new accounts.
9.Current payment records are to be reviewed before extending additional credit to open accounts.
10.To reduce costs, the use of outside credit reports was suspended on several occasions.
11.Since several staff positions in the credit department were eliminated to reduce costs, some new accounts have received only cursory review.
12.According to the new credit manager, strict adherence to established credit policy is not necessary.
Effect is best illustrated by items numbered:
5, 6, and 7.
3, 4, and 12.
2, 10, and 11.
1, 8, and 9.
5, 6, and 7.
Upon reviewing the results of the audit report with the audit committee, executive management agreed to accept the risk of not implementing corrective action on certain audit findings. Evaluate the following and select thebestalternative for the internal auditing director.
Notify regulatory authorities of management’s decision.
Internal audit responsibility has been discharged, and no further audit action is required.
Conduct a follow-up audit to determine whether corrective action was taken.
Perform additional audit steps to further identify the policy violations.
Internal audit responsibility has been discharged, and no further audit action is required.
An internal auditor is assigned to perform an audit of the company’s insurance program, including the appropriateness of the approach to minimizing risks to the company. The company self-insures against large casualty losses and health benefits provided for all its employees. The company is a large national firm with over 15,000 employees located in various parts of the country. It uses an outside claims processor to administer its health care program. The company’s medical costs have been rising by approximately 8% per year for the past five years, and management is concerned with controlling them.
The auditor needs to determine the scope of the proposed audit of insurance coverage by the company. Which of the following statements is (are)correctregarding the potential scope of the audit?
I.Since it is an internal audit, the audit department should concentrate on processing that occurs within the company and not on auditing the correctness of transaction processing by the health care processor.
II.The auditor should interview management prior to beginning the audit to understand (1) its concerns and (2) the underlying assumptions made and rationale used when making the self-insurance decision.
III.The auditor should consider engaging an actuarial consultant to better understand the risks involved in order to help determine the scope of the audit.
II and III.
Both I and II.
I only.
II only.
II and III.
An oral audit report may be most appropriate when:
Higher-level management needs a summary of individual audits.
It is used only for internal reporting within the internal auditing department.
A permanent record of the report is needed.
Emergency action is needed.
Emergency action is needed.
Which of the following is not a major purpose of an audit report? Get results. Inform. Persuade. Assign responsibility.
Assign responsibility.
An auditor has submitted a first draft of an audit report to an auditee in preparation for an exit interview. The following is an excerpt from that report:
The audit was performed to accomplish several objectives.
+Verify the existence of unused machinery being stored in the warehouse.
+Determine whether machinery had been damaged during storage.
+Review the handling procedures being performed by personnel at the warehouse.
+Determine whether proper accounting procedures are being followed for machinery kept in the warehouse.
+Calculate the current fair market value of warehouse inventories.
+Compare the total value of the machinery to company accounting records.
It was confirmed that, of the 30 machines selected from purchasing records for the sample, 13 were present on the warehouse floor and another 5 were on the loading dock ready for conveyance to the production facility. Twelve others had been sent to the production facility at a previous time. An examination of the accounting procedures used at the warehouse revealed the failure by the warehouse accounting clerk to reconcile inventory records monthly, as required by policy. A sample of 25 machines was examined for possible damage, and all but one was in good condition. It was confirmed by the auditors that handling procedures outlined in the warehouse policy manual appear to be adequate, and warehouse personnel apparently were following those procedures, except for the examination of items being received for inventory.
When communicating with auditees, there exist both situational factors and message characteristics that can damage the communication process. An auditor has only limited control over situational factors but has substantial control over message characteristics.
Which of the following would seem to be a message characteristic that the auditor who prepared the above report overlooked?
Sequence of message.
Nature of the audience.
Prior encounters with the auditee.
Noise.
Sequence of message.
An internal auditor is assigned to conduct an audit of security of a local area network (LAN) in the finance department of the organization. Investment decisions, including the use of hedging strategies and financial derivatives, use data and financial models that run on the LAN. The LAN is also used to download data from the mainframe to assist in the decisions. In determining the scope of the audit, which of the following items should be consideredoutside the scopeof the security audit?
The ability of the LAN application to identify data items at the field or record level and implement user access security at that level.
Interviews with users to determine their assessment of the level of security in the system and the vulnerability of the system to compromise.
The level of security of other LANs in the company that also utilize sensitive data.
Investigation of the physical security over access to the components of the LAN.
The level of security of other LANs in the company that also utilize sensitive data.
The following data were gathered during an internal auditor’s investigation of the reason for a material increase in bad debts expenses. In preparing a report of the finding, each of the items might be classified as criteria, cause, condition, effect, or background information.
1.Very large orders require management’s approval of credit.
2.Audit tests showed that sales personnel regularly disregard credit guidelines when dealing with established customers.
3.A monthly report of write-offs is prepared but distributed only to the accounting department.
4.Credit reports are used only on new accounts.
5.Accounting department records suggest that uncollectible accounts could increase by 5% for the current year.
6.The bad debts loss increased by $100,000 during the last fiscal year.
7.Even though procedures and criteria were changed to reduce the amount of bad-debt write-offs, the loss of commissions due to written-off accounts has increased for some sales personnel.
8.Credit department policy requires the review of credit references for all new accounts.
9.Current payment records are to be reviewed before extending additional credit to open accounts.
10.To reduce costs, the use of outside credit reports was suspended on several occasions.
11.Since several staff positions in the credit department were eliminated to reduce costs, some new accounts have received only cursory review.
12.According to the new credit manager, strict adherence to established credit policy is not necessary.
Criteria are best illustrated by items numbered:
3, 4, and 12.
1, 8, and 9.
2, 10, and 11.
5, 6, and 7.
1, 8, and 9.
An audit report relating to an audit of a bank categorizes findings into “deficiency findings” for major problems and “other areas for improvement” for less serious problems. Which of the following excerpts would properly be included under “other areas for improvement”?
Many secured loans did not contain hazard insurance coverage for tangible property collateral.
The bank is incurring unnecessary postage cost by not combining certain special mailings to checking account customers with the monthly mailing of their statements.
At one branch a large amount of cash was placed on a portable table behind the teller lines.
Loan officers also prepare the cashier’s checks for disbursement of the loan proceeds.
The bank is incurring unnecessary postage cost by not combining certain special mailings to checking account customers with the monthly mailing of their statements.
During the course of an audit, the auditor makes a preliminary determination that a major division has been inappropriately capitalizing research and development expense. The audit is not yet completed, and the auditor has not documented the problem or determined that it really is a problem. However, the auditor is informed that the director of internal auditing has received the following communication from the president of the company:
The controller of Division B informs me that you have discovered a questionable account classification dealing with research and development expense. We are aware of the issue. You are directed to discontinue any further investigation of this matter until informed by me to proceed. Under the confidentiality standard of your profession, I also direct you not to communicate with the outside auditors regarding this issue.
Which of the following would be an appropriate action for the director to take regarding the questionable item?
Immediately report the communication to the Institute of Internal Auditors and ask for an ethical interpretation and guidance.
Continue to investigate the area until all the facts are determined, and document all the relevant facts in the audit work papers.
Inform the president that this scope limitation will need to be reported to the chairperson of the audit committee.
Immediately notify the external auditors of the problem to avoid aiding and abetting a potential crime by the organization.
Inform the president that this scope limitation will need to be reported to the chairperson of the audit committee.
It is important that the auditor be able to carefully distinguish between a scope limitation and other limitations on the audit. According to the IIAStandards, which of the following wouldnotbe considered a scope limitation?
I.The divisional management of an auditee has indicated that the division is in the process of converting a major computer system and has indicated that the information technology portion of the planned audit will have to be postponed until next year.
II.The audit committee reviews the audit plan for the year and deletes an audit that the director thought was important to conduct.
III.The auditee has indicated that certain customers cannot be contacted because the organization is in the process of negotiating a long-term contract with them and does not want to upset the customers.
IV.None of the responses is correct.
II only.
An internal auditor in a retail company reports to the corporate director of internal audit. The auditor is assigned to audit a regional division. The audit reports are to be sent both to the corporate office and the division controller in the region. The auditor has been on location for six months and has submitted monthly reports, each month auditing a part of the operation as assigned by corporate internal auditing. This month, for the first time, the auditor has audited the inventory controls, following procedures established by the corporate internal auditing staff.
After seeing the audit report on inventory control, the divisional controller called and requested a meeting with the auditor. At the meeting, the divisional controller loudly and abusively criticized the accuracy of the auditor’s work, the soundness of the auditor’s methods, and the results presented in the reports. In the past, while not always agreeing with the auditor’s conclusions, the divisional controller always had rational discussions and developed appropriate follow-up steps to correct the problems the auditor found.
The divisional controller could have handled the situation better by:
Accepting the report because the auditor has consistently done good work, and this one report is not that important.
Changing the methods used by corporate audit.
Discussing the objections to the inventory report with the auditor to get agreement on changes and appropriate additional work.
Accepting the report but informing the director of internal auditing that the report was unsatisfactory.
Discussing the objections to the inventory report with the auditor to get agreement on changes and appropriate additional work.
An internal auditor in a retail company reports to the corporate director of internal audit. The auditor is assigned to audit a regional division. The audit reports are to be sent both to the corporate office and the division controller in the region. The auditor has been on location for six months and has submitted monthly reports, each month auditing a part of the operation as assigned by corporate internal auditing. This month, for the first time, the auditor has audited the inventory controls, following procedures established by the corporate internal auditing staff.
After seeing the audit report on inventory control, the divisional controller called and requested a meeting with the auditor. At the meeting, the divisional controller loudly and abusively criticized the accuracy of the auditor’s work, the soundness of the auditor’s methods, and the results presented in the reports. In the past, while not always agreeing with the auditor’s conclusions, the divisional controller always had rational discussions and developed appropriate follow-up steps to correct the problems the auditor found.
This particular audit was not the auditor’s best work, and the auditor realizes this. The auditor should:
Ask for time off for training in the weak areas.
Explain the personal problems that kept the auditor from working as hard on this report as could be expected.
Ask the divisional controller to identify specific areas in which the report is deficient, and, if the objections are justified, revise the report.
Defend the work now and try to improve it in the future.
Ask the divisional controller to identify specific areas in which the report is deficient, and, if the objections are justified, revise the report.
Assume your company is considering purchasing a small toxic waste disposal company. As internal auditors, you are part of the team doing a due diligence review for the acquisition. Your scope (as auditors) would most likelynotinclude:
A review of the purchased company’s procedures for acceptance of waste material and comparison with legal requirements.
An evaluation of the merit of lawsuits currently filed against the waste company.
Analysis of the company’s compliance with, and disclosure of, loan covenants.
Assessment of the efficiency of the waste company’s operations and profitability.
An evaluation of the merit of lawsuits currently filed against the waste company.
An internal auditor in a retail company reports to the corporate director of internal audit. The auditor is assigned to audit a regional division. The audit reports are to be sent both to the corporate office and the division controller in the region. The auditor has been on location for six months and has submitted monthly reports, each month auditing a part of the operation as assigned by corporate internal auditing. This month, for the first time, the auditor has audited the inventory controls, following procedures established by the corporate internal auditing staff.
After seeing the audit report on inventory control, the divisional controller called and requested a meeting with the auditor. At the meeting, the divisional controller loudly and abusively criticized the accuracy of the auditor’s work, the soundness of the auditor’s methods, and the results presented in the reports. In the past, while not always agreeing with the auditor’s conclusions, the divisional controller always had rational discussions and developed appropriate follow-up steps to correct the problems the auditor found.
Despite never having said so, the divisional controller had always thought the auditor’s work was substandard. The divisional controller could have handled the situation better by:
Calling the corporate director of internal audit and insist that the auditor be replaced.
Documenting shortcomings regularly and reporting them to the director of internal auditing.
Discussing the auditor’s work with other internal auditors to compare the auditor’s methods with others used in the company.
Providing training on auditing of inventory controls so the auditor would do a better job the next time.
Documenting shortcomings regularly and reporting them to the director of internal auditing.
A company recently experienced a substantially reduced net profit from sales of product line A. Line A is produced in a dedicated machine shop. The internal auditors have been assigned the task of determining the cause of the reduced net profit. Which of the following wouldmost likelyidentify the problem?
Interviews with the staff engaged in the production of line A.
An analysis of the financial and operational reports.
A walk-through of the machine shop.
A review of prior audit results.
An analysis of the financial and operational reports.
Which of the following is a proper step in an audit program? Definition of audit objectives. Planning for audit reporting. Observation of procedures. Notification of the audit.
Observation of procedures.
An auditor has submitted a first draft of an audit report to an auditee in preparation for an exit interview. The following is an excerpt from that report:
The audit was performed to accomplish several objectives: verify the existence of unused machinery being stored in the warehouse, determine whether machinery had been damaged during storage, review the handling procedures being performed by personnel at the warehouse, determine whether proper accounting procedures are being followed for machinery kept in the warehouse, calculate the current fair market value of warehouse inventories, and compare the total value of the machinery to company accounting records. It was confirmed that of the 30 machines selected from purchasing records for the sample, 10 were present on the warehouse floor and another 5 were on the loading dock ready for conveyance to the production facility. Twelve others had already been sent to the production facility at a previous time. An examination of the accounting procedures used at the warehouse revealed the failure by the warehouse accounting clerk to reconcile inventory records monthly, as required by policy. A sample of 25 machines was examined for possible damage, and all but one was in good condition. It was confirmed by the auditors that handling procedures outlined in the warehouse policy manual appear to be adequate, and warehouse personnel apparently were following those procedures, except for the examination of items being received for inventory.
When communicating with auditees, both situational factors and message characteristics can damage the communication process. An auditor has only limited control over situational factors but has substantial control over message characteristics.
The objectives of an audit report are to inform and to influence. Whether these objectives are met depends on the clarity of the writing. Which of the following principles of report clarity wasviolatedin the above audit report?
I.Appropriately organize the report.
II.Keep most sentences short and simple.
III.Use active voice verbs.
IV.All of the above.
IV.
The following data were gathered during an internal auditor’s investigation of the reason for a material increase in bad debts expenses. In preparing a report of the finding, each of the items might be classified as criteria, cause, condition, effect, or background information.
1.Very large orders require management’s approval of credit.
2.Audit tests showed that sales personnel regularly disregard credit guidelines when dealing with established customers.
3.A monthly report of write-offs is prepared but distributed only to the accounting department.
4.Credit reports are used only on new accounts.
5.Accounting department records suggest that uncollectible accounts could increase by 5% for the current year.
6.The bad debts loss increased by $100,000 during the last fiscal year.
7.Even though procedures and criteria were changed to reduce the amount of bad-debt write-offs, the loss of commissions due to written-off accounts has increased for some sales personnel.
8.Credit department policy requires the review of credit references for all new accounts.
9.Current payment records are to be reviewed before extending additional credit to open accounts.
10.To reduce costs, the use of outside credit reports was suspended on several occasions.
11.Since several staff positions in the credit department were eliminated to reduce costs, some new accounts have received only cursory review.
12.According to the new credit manager, strict adherence to established credit policy is not necessary.
Condition is best illustrated by items numbered:
2, 10, and 11.
3, 4, and 12.
1, 8, and 9.
5, 6, and 7.
2, 10, and 11.
The following information is extracted from a draft of an audit report prepared on the completion of an audit of the inventory warehousing procedures for a division.
[#5]We performed extensive tests of inventory record keeping and quantities on hand. Based on our tests, we have concluded that the division carries a large quantity of excess inventory, particularly in the area of component parts. We expect this be due to the conservatism of local management that does not want to risk shutting down production if the goods are not on hand. However, as noted earlier in this report, the excess inventory has led to a higher-than-average level of obsolete inventory write-downs at this division. We recommend that production forecasts be established, along with lead times for various products, and used in conjunction with economic order quantity concepts to order and maintain appropriate inventory levels.
[#6]We observed that receiving reports were not filled out when the receiving department became busy. Instead, the receiving manager would fill out the reports after work and forward them to accounts payable. There is a risk that all items received might not be recorded or that failing to initially record might result in some items being diverted to other places. During our tests, we noted many instances in which accounts payable had to call to receiving to obtain a receiving report. We recommend that receiving reports be prepared.
[#7]Inventory is messy. We recommend that management communicate the importance of orderly inventory management techniques to warehouse personnel to avoid the problems noted earlier about (1) locating inventory when needed for production and (2) incurring unusually large amounts of inventory write-offs because of obsolescence.
[#8]We appreciate the cooperation of divisional management. We intend to discuss our findings with them and follow up by communicating your reaction to those recommendations included within this report. Given additional time for analysis, we feel there are substantial opportunities available for significant cost savings and we are proud to be a part of the process.
A major deficiency in paragraph #6 related to the completeness of the audit report is:
The factual evidence for the audit finding is not given.
The cause of the problem is not defined.
The risk is presented in an overdramatic fashion.
The recommendation is incomplete.
The recommendation is incomplete.
The following information is extracted from a draft of an audit report prepared on the completion of an audit of the inventory warehousing procedures for a division.
[#5]We performed extensive tests of inventory record keeping and quantities on hand. Based on our tests, we have concluded that the division carries a large quantity of excess inventory, particularly in the area of component parts. We expect this be due to the conservatism of local management that does not want to risk shutting down production if the goods are not on hand. However, as noted earlier in this report, the excess inventory has led to a higher-than-average level of obsolete inventory write-downs at this division. We recommend that production forecasts be established, along with lead times for various products, and used in conjunction with economic order quantity concepts to order and maintain appropriate inventory levels.
[#6]We observed that receiving reports were not filled out when the receiving department became busy. Instead, the receiving manager would fill out the reports after work and forward them to accounts payable. There is a risk that all items received might not be recorded or that failing to initially record might result in some items being diverted to other places. During our tests, we noted many instances in which accounts payable had to call to receiving to obtain a receiving report. We recommend that receiving reports be prepared.
[#7]Inventory is messy. We recommend that management communicate the importance of orderly inventory management techniques to warehouse personnel to avoid the problems noted earlier about (1) locating inventory when needed for production and (2) incurring unusually large amounts of inventory write-offs because of obsolescence.
[#8]We appreciate the cooperation of divisional management. We intend to discuss our findings with them and follow up by communicating your reaction to those recommendations included within this report. Given additional time for analysis, we feel there are substantial opportunities available for significant cost savings and we are proud to be a part of the process.
A major writing problem in paragraph #5 is:
The specific identification of “component parts” may be offensive to the personnel responsible for those parts and may reflect negatively on them.
The use of potentially emotional words, such as “conservatism” of local management.
The reference to other parts of the audit report citing excessive inventory write-downs for obsolescence is not appropriate. If there is a problem, it should all be discussed within the context of the specific audit finding.
The presentation of findings before recommendations. The report would have more impact if recommendations were made before the findings are discussed.
The use of potentially emotional words, such as “conservatism” of local management.
One purpose of the exit conference is for the internal auditor to:
Require corrective action for deficiencies found.
Review the performance of audit personnel assigned to the engagement.
Review and verify the appropriateness of the audit report based on auditee input.
Present the final audit report to management.
Review and verify the appropriateness of the audit report based on auditee input.
Which of the following individuals would normallynotreceive an internal auditing report related to a review of the purchasing cycle? The independent external auditor. The general auditor. The director of purchasing. The chairman of the board of directors.
The chairman of the board of directors.
The following information is to be included in a finding of an inventory control audit of a tent and awning manufacturer. The issue relates to overstocked rope.
I.The quantity on hand at the time of the audit represented a 10-year supply based on normal usage.
II.The company had held an open house of its new factory two months prior to the audit and had used the rope to provide safety corridors through the plant for visitors. This was not considered when placing the last purchase order.
III.Rope is reordered when the inventory level reaches a one-month supply and is based on usage during the previous 12 months.
IV.The quantity to be ordered should be adequate to cover expected usage for the next six months.
V.The purchasing department should review inventory usage and inquire about any unusual fluctuations before placing an order.
VI.A public warehouse, costing $500 per month, was required to store the rope.
VII.The purchasing agent receives an annual salary of $59,000.
Which of these statements should be in the cause section of the finding?
I only.
VII only.
II only.
VI only.
II only.
The following information is to be included in a finding of an inventory control audit of a tent and awning manufacturer. The issue relates to overstocked rope.
I.The quantity on hand at the time of the audit represented a 10-year supply based on normal usage.
II.The company had held an open house of its new factory two months prior to the audit and had used the rope to provide safety corridors through the plant for visitors. This was not considered when placing the last purchase order.
III.Rope is reordered when the inventory level reaches a one-month supply and is based on usage during the previous 12 months.
IV.The quantity to be ordered should be adequate to cover expected usage for the next six months.
V.The purchasing department should review inventory usage and inquire about any unusual fluctuations before placing an order.
VI.A public warehouse, costing $500 per month, was required to store the rope.
VII.The purchasing agent receives an annual salary of $59,000.
Which of these statements should be in the condition section of the finding?
VII only.
IV only.
VI only.
I only.
I only.
The internal auditing department of an organization has been in existence for ten years. It has established a charter, which has not yet been approved by the audit committee. However, the audit committee is chaired by the chief executive officer (CEO) and includes the controller and one outside board member. The director reports directly to the controller who approves the internal audit work plan. Thus, the auditing department has never felt the need to push for a formal approval of the charter. The organization is publicly held and has nine major divisions. The previous director of internal auditing was recently dismissed following a dispute between the director and a major auditee. The CEO accused the director of not operating “in the best interests of the organization.” A new director with significant experience in both public accounting and internal auditing has just been hired. Within the first month, the new director encountered substantial resistance from an auditee regarding the nature of an audit and the audit department’s access to records.
In considering the internal auditing department’s independence, which of the following facts, by themselves, could contribute to a lack of internal audit independence?
I.The CEO accused the previous director of not operating “in the best interests of the organization.”
II.The majority of audit committee members come from within the organization.
III.The internal audit charter has not been approved by the board or the audit committee.
II and III only.
I only.
I, II, and III.
II only.
II and III only.
A governmental agency constrained by scarce audit and human resources wishes to know the status of its program for licensing automobiles. In particular, management is concerned about the possibility of:
+A backlog in new license applications, and
+Poor controls over the collection and processing of application fees.
The results of the preliminary survey and limited audit testing conducted by the internal auditing department revealed that the licensing process was operating as intended. No major deficiencies were noted. How should the internal auditing department proceed?
Complete the audit as scheduled to ensure that other issues do not exist that were not noted during the survey phase.
Send a memorandum report to the executive director and other concerned parties summarizing the preliminary survey results and indicating that the audit has been canceled.
Perform no further audit work, issue a formal audit report with the survey results, and discuss the results with management.
Perform no further audit work, discuss pertinent issues with management and the executive director, and prepare an audit program for future use so that another survey will not be necessary.
Send a memorandum report to the executive director and other concerned parties summarizing the preliminary survey results and indicating that the audit has been canceled.
The following information is to be included in a finding of an inventory control audit of a tent and awning manufacturer. The issue relates to overstocked rope.
I.The quantity on hand at the time of the audit represented a 10-year supply based on normal usage.
II.The company had held an open house of its new factory two months prior to the audit and had used the rope to provide safety corridors through the plant for visitors. This was not considered when placing the last purchase order.
III.Rope is reordered when the inventory level reaches a one-month supply and is based on usage during the previous 12 months.
IV.The quantity to be ordered should be adequate to cover expected usage for the next six months.
V.The purchasing department should review inventory usage and inquire about any unusual fluctuations before placing an order.
VI.A public warehouse, costing $500 per month, was required to store the rope.
VII.The purchasing agent receives an annual salary of $59,000.
Which of these statements should be in the effect section of the finding?
VI only.
II only.
III only.
V only.
VI only.
The following information is extracted from a draft of an audit report prepared on the completion of an audit of the inventory warehousing procedures for a division.
[#5]We performed extensive tests of inventory record keeping and quantities on hand. Based on our tests, we have concluded that the division carries a large quantity of excess inventory, particularly in the area of component parts. We expect this be due to the conservatism of local management that does not want to risk shutting down production if the goods are not on hand. However, as noted earlier in this report, the excess inventory has led to a higher-than-average level of obsolete inventory write-downs at this division. We recommend that production forecasts be established, along with lead times for various products, and used in conjunction with economic order quantity concepts to order and maintain appropriate inventory levels.
[#6]We observed that receiving reports were not filled out when the receiving department became busy. Instead, the receiving manager would fill out the reports after work and forward them to accounts payable. There is a risk that all items received might not be recorded or that failing to initially record might result in some items being diverted to other places. During our tests, we noted many instances in which accounts payable had to call to receiving to obtain a receiving report. We recommend that receiving reports be prepared.
[#7]Inventory is messy. We recommend that management communicate the importance of orderly inventory management techniques to warehouse personnel to avoid the problems noted earlier about (1) locating inventory when needed for production and (2) incurring unusually large amounts of inventory write-offs because of obsolescence.
[#8]We appreciate the cooperation of divisional management. We intend to discuss our findings with them and follow up by communicating your reaction to those recommendations included within this report. Given additional time for analysis, we feel there are substantial opportunities available for significant cost savings and we are proud to be a part of the process.
A major deficiency in paragraph #5 related to the completeness of the audit report is:
The report does not adequately describe the potential effect of the conditions noted.
The recommendations are not required and are not appropriate, given the nature of the problem identified.
There is no indication of the potential cause of the problem.
The report does not contain criteria by which the concept of excessive inventory is judged.
The report does not contain criteria by which the concept of excessive inventory is judged.
Several levels of management are interested in the results of the marketing department audit. What is thebestmethod of communicating the results of the audit?
Discuss results with marketing management and issue a summary report to top management.
Discuss results with all levels of management.
Write detailed reports for each level of management.
Write a report to the marketing management and give summary reports to other management levels.
Write a report to the marketing management and give summary reports to other management levels.