Place Flashcards
What is place
A meaningful site combining location (in abstract space), locale (tangible aspects), and sense of place (feelings evoked, Yi Fu Tuan’s topophilia and topophobia)
What 3 things all occur and link in a place
Material structure (form a place is recognised by, can be a symbol e.g. Eiffel Tower), meaning (location becomes place as it becomes meaningful but meaning can change e.g. Twin Towers), practice (continually enacts place meaning)
How do place and space link
Yi Fu Tuan defines place as in binary opposition to space (humanist perspective), where place is bounded and secure and space is infinite and free. Space becomes place once it is lived in
Plato
An achieved place (topos) is finite, and is achieved using that which becomes, that which is the model for becoming and the setting for becoming
Aristotle
Place is at the start of becoming as anything to exist must be somewhere
Albertus Magnus
Suggested things work best where they belong
Varanius
Argued for ‘general geography’ focusing on the whole world not specific places
Heidegger
Suggested meaning is assigned to place by ‘dwelling’ - Nazi. Makes little sense in modern, hyperconnected life
1960s and 70s humanistic geography development characteristics
People not rational objects, unlike spatial science. 1977 Yi Fu Tuan Space and Place. Began looking at experience transforming place for individuals to be meaningful. Began looking at regional geography for specific places.
Vidal de la Blache in humanistic geography development
Examined the regional lifeworlds of French regions with different cultures
Shortcoming of humanistic geography development
Said little about power in place construction and contestation
Updated views on power’s effect on place: Marxist
Material structure can assign exclusionary shared meanings
Updated views on power’s effect on place: Harvey
Place is used in regressive and reactionary ways e.g. gated communities
Updated views on power’s effect on place: feminist
Home disputed as a symbol of universal attachment as patriarchal, can be exclusionary, place of order where children are symptoms of disorder
Updated views on power’s effect on place: general
Places cause exclusion by creating commonsense normative places that are ideological tools. However, places are constantly contested by the excluded so place meaning is unfixed
Relph
Argued places are becoming placeless as inauthentic so can’t be insiders, especially as people move about too much
Auge
Nonplace is a place of transit constantly referring to others and is a condition of life due to supermodernity
What causes supermodernity (Auge)
Faster info flows, increased individualism from overexposure, planet shrinking from time-space compression
What are the limits to Auge’s theory
The characteristics of nonplace and supermodernity have been remarked on before due to other advancements so may not have an effect
Historical theorist views about place and mobility (Tuan, Relph, Plato, Aristotle)
Tuan and Relph argued too much mobility limits sense of place. Plato and Aristotle argued processes make place
Merleau-Ponty
People have bodily ‘intentionality’ towards the world as they are conscious of it so form a place meaning as they move through it
Pred
Place is a process where people’s activities produce and are produced by social structures in power. Paths (movements in space and time) triggered by institutions form human and object biographies that coalesce to places. Institutions can also limit and direct paths, causing exclusion
Seamon
Body ballets are habitual movements coalescing to a place ballet that defines a place through constant reiteration
Why is there exclusion if the world is seen as made of fixed, divided places
People with mobile lives are seen as threats as people connect to areas with certain identities and protect them from others
Doreen Massey views on mobility
Mobility constitutes place as they’re formed by connections: a progressive sense of place. No longer clearly bounded as place represents processes