PIL Generally Flashcards
What is a treaty?
VCLT Art 2 - written form, agreement between states
What is pacta sunt savanda?
VCLT Art 26 - treaties must be performed in good faith
Can domestic law excuse treaty violation?
VCLT Art 27 - no
What is the requirements for reservations?
VCLT Art 19 - reservations can’t be contrary to the object and purpose of the treaty
How are treaties interpreted?
VCLT Art 31:
According to their ordinary meaning
In good faith
In context
In light of object and purpose
Can look to subsequent agreement between parties.
Art 32: supplementary means include travaux.
When can a state get out of a treaty?
VCLT Art 62 - Fundamental change in circumstance - if change is essential basis of treaty
What is required for a treaty to be able to create a norm?
North Sea Continental Shelf Cases:
The part of the treaty can’t be able to be reserved by states or suspended during emergencies; it must have widespread and representative participation; state practice must be consistent.
Can custom be regional?
Yes - Asylum Case (Peru)
Can General Assembly Resolutions create custom?
Nicaragua - can contribute to norms, but only cautiously.
What are the sources of intl law?
ICJ Statute - Art 38
- treaties
- custom
- general principles as recognised by civilised nations
- writings of esteemed publicists/judicial decisions
What is the principle of Teoh?
Presumption that enacted law will comply with Australia’s international obligations (particularly ratified treaties)
What are the requirements of statehood?
Montevideo Convention
- Defined territory
- Permanent population
- Effective government
- Capacity to enter into legal relations with other states
Recognition???
What will determine an intl org level of personality?
- It’s constitutive document
- What is necessary for it to fulfil its functions?
UN Reparations Case; Legality of threat or use of nuclear weapons
What is the principle of non-interference?
UN Charter Art 2(7) - no interference in domestic affairs of other states
What are the bases of jurisdiction?
- Territorial (Belmarsh Prison Case)
- Nationality (Hague Convention Relating to Nationality; Natteboehm Case)
- Protective principle (controversial - Eichmann)
- Passive personality principle (your government can invoke its own laws to protect you overseas (USA v Yunis)
- Universal Jurisdiction
- Effects Doctrine (highly controversial - Hartford corp regulation extra-territorially)