Philosophy Quotes and Secondary Arguments Flashcards
Religious Language- Ayer vs Wittgenstein
Ayer- Wittgenstein provides no hierarchy of games- we should, in theory be just as accepting of superstition as we are of actual theology
Ancient Influences- Aristotle criticism of Plato
How can the Form of the Good apply to all objects? - a human is not good in the same way a horse may be
God’s Attributes- Molina
Natural, middle and free knowledge (real, possible and hypothetical)- only natural is necessary to God
Religious Experience- Mackie
If mystical experiences are psychologically explainable, they can have no authority and cannot be automatically believed
Religious Experience- Feuerbach
Humans project fears of mortality and unanswerable questions onto God
Religious Language- Ferre
Language can describe but not define God
Soul, Mind and Body- Anscombe
A body is needed to point, but cannot explain the meaning of it
Religious Experience- Swinburne
Reasonable probability of God’s existence if all other arguments are taken into account
Religious Language- Maimonides
Positive statements about God are improper- Via Negativa is the only way
Religious Language- Ayer
To speak of God is meaningless- not practically verifiable
Teleology- Hume quote
‘How hostile and destructive’
Cosmology- Emmet
God could not have started existence as he is timeless- no chronology
God’s Attributes- Kraal
‘God and goodness are identical’- Euthyphro Dilemma is false, not a question of which came first
God’s Attributes- Hick
God cannot be omnibenevolent if he created hell
Ontology- Descartes
The quality of existence can no more be separated from God than three angles totalling 180 can be separated from the idea of a triangle
God’s Attributes- Craig (2)
God may be everlasting- change does not necessarily signal improvement as is argued
Time needs to be viewed as one unitary thing rather than a continuous process to consider God as timeless
Cosmology- Dawkins
Universe is a purposeless ‘brute fact’- against Leibniz’s sufficient reason
God’s Attributes- Anselm
God exists in 4 dimensions outside of time, cannot be understood in ideas of linear chronology
God’s Attributes- Pike
God is everlasting- timelessness would rid humans of free will and make reality as a simulation
Cosmology- Russell
‘I should say that the universe is just there and that is all’- against Leibniz’s sufficient reason
Religious Experience- Hume
Draws attention to human ‘love of fantastical’ and bizarre- stories often exaggerated or embellished
Religious Experience- Lash
James makes religion dependent on a few pattern-setters
Religious Experience- James quote
‘They point with reasonable probability to the continuity of our consciousness with a wider, spiritual environment from which the ordinary man is shut off’
Religious Experience- James vs Mackie
Religion and neurological fallacy perfectly compatible
One never brings up ‘author’s neurotic constitution’ in science
Religious Language- Weismann quote
‘A statement which cannot be conclusively verified is simply devoid of any meaning’
God’s Attributes- Swinburne
God is everlasting- eternal present for God implies all earthly moments take place all at once
Ancient Influences- Russell
Plato’s Theory of the Forms falls into ‘a bottomless pit of nonsense’
God’s Attributes- Cullman
God is everlasting- moves through time with us and knows all that is logically possible to know
God’s Attributes- Lafleur
God is everlasting- if he existed outside of the bounds of time, he would have no means of interaction- no religious significance or omnipotence
Religious Language- Barth
God cannot be defined with language and worldly experience- only with direct revelation
God’s Attributes- Kenny
Boethius seems to suggest that all earthly moments take place at once- evidently untrue