Pharmacy Practice and the Law- Exam 1 Flashcards
Chapter 1
******Federal vs. State Law
- When a State law conflicts with either the US Constitution and/or Federal law, the Federal law will preempt (=displaces) State law under the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution
- Conflicts generally exist when state law is less strict than federal law
******Stare Decisis- Law Made By Courts: Common Law Cont.
- Stare decisis
- Opinions are binding on lower courts in the same jurisdiction and serve as precedent
- Not an inflexible principle
- Reasons for deviating from precedent include factual distinctions and changing times or circumstances
*****Law Made By Administrative Agencies
- Infamous 4th branch of Govt
- Administrative Agencies
- Admin agencies are created by legislature to:
- implement desired changes in policies
- administer a body of substantive law
- usually have considerable and broad authority
► to perform legislative, judicial, and executive functions
- Create “law” (with the effect of law passed by the legislature and signed by executrive) by
- enacting policies, rules, procedures, and regulations►Notice and Comments
- rendering decisions at hearings
- Administrative Agencies
*****Law Made By Courts:
Common Law
- Common law refers to judicial opinions and was adopted from the English judicial system
- Story: mortalcombat with prosecutor
- Judicial opinions: Decisions of the court
- Enforceable legal opinions as if legislative created law
- Expanding the common law
- Interpreting statutes and regulations
- Binding on lower courts in the same jurisdiction
- Persuasive in other jurisdictions
- Enforceable legal opinions as if legislative created law
*****Law Made of Administrative Agencies-
Legislative Function
- Promulgate Regulations- Legislative function
- Regulations interpret, define, and add detail to statuses
- Regulations enacted via notice and comment rulemaking
- Validity tests of a regulation
- Within the scope of Board’s authority
- ultra vires
- Within the scope of Board’s authority
*****Law Made of Administrative Agencies-
Judicial Function
- Exercise Judicial Fx thru enforcement actions
- these are discretionary with the agency
- FDA would not institute action for lethal injection
- these are discretionary with the agency
- Render decisions pursuant to “hearings” resembling court proceedings
- Resemble Civil and Criminal proceedings
- evidence is presented, arguements made, judgment rendered and “sentencing” imposed
- Loosely bound by state decisis
- Resemble Civil and Criminal proceedings
*****Law Made of Administrative Agencies-
Legislative Function Continued
- Based upon statutory authority
- Can’t create new law without statute allowing
- OR Board to discipline technicians
- Reasonable relationship to public health safety and welfare
- Eg- dress code or north facing front door = invalid
- Like all pharmacists must wear lab coats
- But when would a “dress” code be vaild??
- Eg- dress code or north facing front door = invalid
*****Nature and Role of Law
- Stare Decics- the doctrine of precedent
- to stand by decisions and not disturb the undisturbed
- The law is still flexible enough to create a new outcome for different fact patterns
- ALL lower courts are required to follow decisions from higher courts
- US Supreme Court should follow past SCOTUS decisions
- to stand by decisions and not disturb the undisturbed
*****Relationship of Common Law to Statutory Law
- Virtually impossible to write a law that is NOT ambiguous, vague, or confusing when applied to specific situations
- Deliberately written this way to provide flexibility in settling disputes
- Void for vagueness
- Courts do not like to invalidate statues unless they have no choice
- Presume the constitutionality of a statute and make every attempt to interpret the statute in a way that results in a resonable and fair application of the law to the facts of the case
*****Resonable Doubt
- Proof of such a convincing character that you would be willing to rely and act upon it without hesitation in the most important of your own affairs
- Why do criminal cases require it- deprivation of a defendant’s liberty or even his or her life
****Civil Court Procedures Statute of Limitations
- Limits the period of time in which a case can be filed
- Generally, the SoL is usually 1-6 years
- In Colorado the SoL for
- Contract (oral or written) issues- 6 yrs
- Injury claims- 2 yrs
- Property damage- 2 yrs
- NO SoL for exceptionally heinous crimes like murder
****Civil Court Procedures: The Trial
- All evidence must be
- relevant to the case
- more probative (affording proof or evidence) than prejudicial
- Burden of Proof- level of legal proof required
- Objections
- attempt to restrict the introduction of evidence or testimony
- might constitute issues of law for appeal
- After all evidence is presented, the judge instructs the jury as to the applicable law to apply
****Civil Court Procedures Discovery
- Pretrial process where each side must give the other side all the facts, evidence, and names of witnesses upon which it will rely to present its case
- Should be no surprises at trial
- **Deposition: **Out of court testimony by a witness under oath
- Interrogatory: List of written questions that witness must respond to under oath
****Federal vs. State Law
- Federal authority to regulate drugs generally arise from the Interstate Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution
- Regulation of drug distribution often results in professional regulation as well
- Still needs to bear some relationship to Interstate commerce
- State authority to regulate generally derives from the Tenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and under its inherent State police powers
- State laws must bear a reasonable relationship to the public health safety and welfare
- Eg: OTC drugs only sold in licensed pharmacies
****Law Made by Administrative Agencies
- Infamous 4th branch of Govt
- Administrative Agencies
- Agency “direction” is “controlled” by Exectutive branch (and sometimes Legislative branch) via top executive appointments (with Legistlative confirmation) by Executive branch
- Administrative Agencies
******Legislatures: Statutory Law **
- U.S. Congress (federal laws)
- State Constitutions
- State Legislatures (state laws)
- Political Subdivisions (ordinances)
- Cities, towns, etc.
****Limits of the Law
- Certain human relationships
- families, professions, religious groups
- courts lack the expertise to deal with these specialized relationships
- families, professions, religious groups
- De minimis violations
- Overly harsh punishments
- NO pharmacy can operate withour occasional, very minor technical legal violations
- no real advantage to pursuing infrequent and De minimis violations
- BUT boards will take action for multiple repeats of same or similar offense
***Civil Court Procedures Parties
- Plantiff- Person bringing the action
- Defendant: Person action is brought against
- In the initial proceedings, the Plaintiff’s name appears first in title of case
- Plaintiff v. Defendant
- Plaintiff must prove “standing”: that the challenged conduct has caused the plaintiff injury and that there is a legally protectable interest
***Civil Court Procedures: Pre-Trial Motions
- Each party may file various motions with the Court
- Motion to Dismiss (12b action)- failure to state a claim for which relief can be granted
- Motion for summary judgment: One party attempts to convince the judge that the other sides claims have no merit even if correct
- Motions in limine (a motion made at the start of a trial requesting that the judge rule that certain evidence may not be introduced in trial)
- Exclusions/ inclusions of certain evidence
- Exclusions- that evidence can’t be brought up in trial and if so, could be grounds for mistrial
- Inclusions- that evidence does not have to go through the same admission of evidnce procedure
- Exclusions/ inclusions of certain evidence
***Criminal Court Procedures
- A criminal defendant can be either indicted or arrested
- Indictments are issued by a grand jury when it determines that enought evidence (probable cause) exists for an arrest and trial
- If arrested, at a preliminary hearing the judge must determine if there is enough probably cause for an arrest; and if so, defendant must enter a plea at an arraignment
- nolo contendere- “I do not wish to contend”
***Criminal Court Procedures
- The parties may agree to a “plea bargain” where the defendant agrees to a lesser charge rather than face a trial
- Burden of proof for all evidence in a criminal proceeding- beyond a reasonable doubt
- Defendant has many rights
- # 1- not to self incriminate
- right to a speedy trial
- right to jury trial (generally)
- Etc, etc