Personality Disorders Flashcards
personality
personality captures patterns of acting, thinking, and feeling that characterize a given individual and distinguish that person from others
five factor model
Neuroticism, which captures the degree to which an individual is prone
toward experiencing unpleasant emotions like anxiety, sadness, and fear
Extraversion, which captures the extent of a person’s preference for
social interactions versus solitary activity
Openness to Experience, which captures how curious an individual is and
how receptive they are to new ideas, approaches, and events
Conscientiousness, which taps propensity for organization, punctuality,
and achievement motivation
Agreeableness, which reflects individual differences in people’s
preferences for co-operation and social harmony
dimensional frameworks
(1) personality traits are continuously distributed in
populations, and (2) personality pathology reflects extreme variants of typical personality
traits.
categorical approach
maladaptive personality functioning is assumed to manifest as a
number of discrete disorders, each defined by a polythetic criterion set - specified
number of symptoms from a larger list
weaknesses of the categorical approach
co-occurrence among personality disorders is excessive—far higher than what would be expected if each disorder emerged from unique underlying factors.
PD Unspecified Personality Disorder is more commonly applied than any other
PD diagnosis
polythetic criterion sets yield heterogeneous groups - five out of nine possible
symptoms—allowing for 246 unique combinations - may reduce the clinical utility
of applying a diagnosis at all
hybrid dimensional-categorical approach
traditional PD framework includes 10 diagnoses, the alternative model
retains only six
defines personality disorders by impairments in personality functioning and pathological
personality traits
three criterion of the alternative model
- Criterion A: a 0–4 scale of personality functioning in self identity and self-direction and
interpersonal domains (empathy and intimacy) - Criterion B: a dimensional system in which 25 traits are organized into five overarching
domains (antagonism vs agreeableness; detachment vs extraversion; disinhibition vs
conscientiousness; negative affectivity vs emotional stability; and psychoticism vs
lucidity) - Criterion C: a prototypal system of six personality disorder types (avoidant, schizotypal,
antisocial, narcissistic, obsessive-compulsive, and borderline)
current DSM taxonomy
- Criterion A: Behavioural patterns must manifest in at least two of the following areas:
cognition, emotions, interpersonal functioning, or impulse control. - Criterion B: Such patterns must be rigid and consistent across a broad range of personal
and social situations. - Criterion C: Patterns should cause clinically significant distress in social, occupational, or
other important areas of functioning. - Criterion D: Symptoms must be stable and of lengthy duration, with onset in
adolescence or earlier. - Criterion E: Behavioural patterns cannot be accounted for by another mental disorder.
- Criterion F: Patterns are not due to acute substance use (e.g., drugs or alcohol) or of
another medical condition.
other reasons for personality disorder diagnoses
- DSM includes diagnoses for personality change due to another medical condition, other
specified personality disorder, and unspecified personality disorder. - other specified PD when a person meets criteria for a general PD, exhibits symptoms
from a number of personality disorders, yet criteria for any single PD are not met. - Unspecified PD is applied when individuals meet general PD criteria, yet their core
symptoms are not captured by existing specific PD diagnoses
Cluster A disorders
Cluster A is defined by odd or eccentric features and includes paranoid, schizoid, and schizotypal PDs
Cluster B disorders
(dramatic, emotional, or erratic features) includes antisocial, borderline, histrionic, and narcissistic PDs.
Cluster C disorders
(anxious or fearful features) consists of avoidant, dependent, and
obsessive–compulsive PDs.
how should disorders be grouped instead?
group disorders by similar phenotypic features (i.e., how behavioural symptoms look on the surface) rather than by shared developmental factors or by a common underlying
structure
limitations affecting available research
base rates of these disorders are low and epidemiological research is fairly limited.
PDs are also associated with a number of inaccurate and harmful stereotypes
Personality disorders are more stigmatized relative to other psychiatric diagnoses
more likely to struggle with forming a therapeutic alliance, more likely to perceive these clients as attention seeking, dangerous, manipulative
Due to associated stigma, many clinicians are reluctant to diagnose PDs—particularly
among youth
broadest limitation is that most PDs are simply understudied
cultural considerations of personality disorder
- Researchers often rely on convenience samples from Westernized, educated,
industrialized, rich, and democratic nations - these disorders occur cross-culturally
- U.S. and Colombia report prevalence estimates of 7.6% and 7.9%, respectively,
whereas western Europe and Nigeria report far lower estimates of 2.4% and 0.9% - variability in study design and sample characteristics makes it difficult to determine
whether available estimates reflect true cross-national differences in PD prevalence - in the UK, White individuals have higher total PD prevalence rates in hospital settings
compared with Black or Asian individuals - Inconsistencies between inpatient and community samples may reflect problems with
health care accessibility for marginalized groups
cluster A - ecological momentary assessment
- ecological momentary assessment (EMA)
o paranoid features – cognitive diffculties
o schizoid traits – blunted affect, lack of caring relationships
o schizotypal traits – poor social functioning - schizotypal PD is the only disorder categorized as both a PD and schizophrenia
spectrum disorder in the DSM
paranoid personality disorder history
- paranoia originated in ancient Greece and translates to “out of one’s mind”
- nineteenth century - applying the term paranoid to persons exhibiting suspiciousness,
hostility, and systematized delusions - systematized delusions are logical and coherent, yet based on false grounds (i.e., beliefs that are highly improbable but not impossible
- Emil Kraepelin conceptualized paranoia as stemming from pathological misinterpretation
of real events
paranoid personality disorder - clinical features
- patterns of pervasive mistrust, suspiciousness, and resentment of others
- hypersensitive to interpersonal cues, assume innocuous stimuli have a special meaning
for them, inclined to interpret others’ motivations as spiteful or malevolent
paranoid personality disorder - DSM diagnosis
DSM-5-TR diagnosis requires at least four of seven symptoms, beginning by early
adulthood
of the seven DSM criteria, unjustified suspicion of infidelity was the least
commonly endorsed symptom and the least sensitive indicator for PPD
paranoid personality disorder - four suspiciousness symptoms
(1) global suspicion of harm,
exploitation, or deception from others without sufficient basis; (2) preoccupation with unjustified
doubts of loyalty or trustworthiness of friends or associates; (3) reluctance to confide in others due
to unwarranted fear that disclosed information will be used against them; and (4) perceiving benign
remarks or events as carrying hidden threats or demeaning meaning.
paranoid personality disorder - three hostility symptoms
(1) persistently bearing grudges; (2)
perceiving attacks on one’s character or reputation that are not apparent to others, and being quick
to counterattack or react aggressively; and (3) recurrent unjustified suspicions of infidelity from a
romantic or sexual partner.
paranoid personality disorder - prevalence
- mild symptoms of paranoia are relatively common in the general population (i.e.,
20%–30% - PPD affects only 1.21% to 4.4% of people
- women may be more frequently affected, yet the disorder may be more severe among
men
paranoid personality disorder genetic factors
- individuals with PPD appear to share more genetic similarities with delusional disorder
and unipolar depression than with schizophrenia
paranoid personality disorder - social factors
o Childhood maltreatment is associated with hostile attribution biases
- deficits in cognitive-affective information processing may constitute one pathway to PPD development
Paranoid Personality Disorder – Diagnostic Overlap and Comorbidity
seldomly appearsasastand-alonedisorder
delusional disorder with a specified persecutory type
schizotypal personality disorder is also defined in part by experiences of paranoia
Schizoid Personality Disorder – History
- term schizoid was introduced in 1908 to describe a condition characterized by social
detachment, pursuit of vague interests, and both emotional sensitivity and emotional
numbness
Schizoid Personality Disorder – early DSM 5
- schizoid personality disorder was introduced in the DSM-I
o first two editions, this condition was conceptualized as a form of schizophrenia
characterized by shyness, emotional sensitivity, avoidance of intimate
interpersonal relationships, eccentric behaviours, and an inability to directly
express aggression or hostility
o DSM-III - divided the clinical features described above into three distinct
disorders: schizoid personality disorder, schizotypal personality disorder, and
avoidant personality disorder
Schizoid Personality Disorder – Clinical Features and Supporting Data
- defined by detachment, withdrawal from social relationships, and a restricted range of
emotional expression in social settings
Schizoid Personality Disorder - Diagnostic criteria
- four of the following seven symptoms
o (1) no desire or enjoyment of close relationships, including family; (2) indifference
to praise or criticism from others; (3) little to no interest in having sexual
experiences with others; (4) almost always choosing solitary activities; (5) lack of
close friends/confidants other than first-degree relatives; (6) displaying emotional
coldness, detachment, or flat affect; and (7) taking pleasure in few, if any,
activities
Schizoid Personality Disorder – Prevalence
- 1% to 5%
- thought to occur more commonly among males
Schizoid Personality Disorder – Etiology
appears to share some genetic vulnerability with schizophrenia, yet to a lesser degree than schizotypal PD
heritability estimate of 0.29, indicating that a substantial portion of the variance in
schizoid PD is attributable to non-genetic factors
major depressive disorder (MDD) in childhood and adolescence prospectively predicts schizoid PD later in adulthood
Schizoid Personality Disorder – Diagnositc Overlap and Comorbidity
- DSM criteria demonstrate low internal consistency and poor diagnostic
efficiency—meaning symptoms are generally not sensitive or specific to schizoid PD - schizoid PD rarely occurs in the absence of another psychiatric condition— particularly
other PDs - 0.3%
schizoid PD and schizotypal (27–80% co-occurrence), avoidant (10–88%), paranoid
(0–62%), and antisocial PDs (0–40%
Schizotypal Personality Disorder – History
- term schizotypal captures schizophrenia-like symptoms that fall below the threshold for a psychotic episode - dementia praecox
- schizotypal features can, but often do not, develop into schizophrenia
- term “borderline schizophrenia” first appeared in the second edition of DSM
Schizotypal Personality Disorder – Clinical Features and Supporting Data
- patterns of eccentric behaviour (e.g., unusual mannerisms), cognitive and perceptual
distortions (e.g., believing in clairvoyance, hearing a voice whispering one’s name), and
impaired interpersonal functioning - much of the existing literature is based on samples with schizotypy and schizotypal PD
features, rather than with persons above the diagnostic threshold
o schizotypy captures a constellation of traits thought to create vulnerability for
schizophrenia
Schizotypal Personality Disorder - Diagnostic Criteria
- five of nine possible symptoms, beginning by early adulthood - transient psychotic
symptoms (lasting minutes to hours) that are lower in severity and frequency
o three dimensions of functioning - cognitive and perceptual (similar to positive
symptoms of schizophrenia), interpersonal (overlapping with negative symptoms
of schizophrenia), and disorganization
o cognitive and perceptual - (1) non-delusional ideas of reference, (2) odd beliefs and magical
thinking, (3) paranoia, and (4) unusual perceptual or somatic experiences
o interpersonal - (1) lacking close friends outside one’s immediate family, (2) persistent social
anxiety even with familiarity (usually due to paranoia rather than fear of judgment), and (3)
constricted or inappropriate affect
o disorganized - (1) odd/eccentric behaviours and appearance and (2) odd thinking/speech
Schizotypal Personality Disorder – Prevalence
- 0.8%
- lifetime prevalence estimates of 3.9%
- slightly more men affected than women
Schizotypal Personality Disorder - genetics
- heritability estimates are 0.61
- Family studies report prevalence rates of 4.2% to 14.6% for schizotypal PD among first-
degree relatives of individuals with schizophrenia - both over- and underactive dopaminergic activity appear uniquely associated with
schizotypal symptoms - Valine/Valine genotype is associated with low dopamine levels in the prefrontal
cortex and is linked to negative and disorganized schizotypal symptoms
Schizotypal Personality Disorder - childhood factors
- individuals with schizotypal PD were 10.45 times more likely to report experiencing any
form of childhood trauma
- severe childhood sexual abuse had the strongest association with cognitive-perceptual
symptoms (e.g., ideas of reference)
- severe emotional neglect was most strongly associated with interpersonal symptoms
(e.g., constricted affect)
Schizotypal Personality Disorder - Diagnositc Overlap and Comorbidity
- having schizotypal PD is associated with a 2.5 times higher likelihood of having a
substance use disorder, 7.6 times the likelihood of having any anxiety disorder, 7.5 times
the likelihood of having any mood disorder, and 6.7 times the likelihood for having PTSD
one year later - 26.5 times and 13.6 times higher likelihood of having a lifetime history of BPD and NPD,
respectively - greater risk for developing schizophrenia - 33.1% of schizotypal PD cases developed
into schizophrenia over the course of 20 year
Schizotypal Personality Disorder - treatment
antipsychotics, and produce mixed results, anxiety and paranoia appear
most responsive to psychotropic medication, psychotherapeutic intervention (including
CBT, cognitive remediation, psychodynamic therapy, and social skills training) also
yields mixed findings.