Personal Property Essay Rules Flashcards
Bailment
A relationship created by the transfer of possession of an item of personal property by one called the bailor to another called the bailee for the accomplishment of a certain purpose
There is no bailment unless the bailee obtains
Physical custody over the property coupled with the intent to exercise control
Physical custody (left rug)
Intent to exercise control (agreed to clean it)
Consent + knowledge (of presence) (ticket)
The bailee’s ________ to possession is required, and the bailee must have ________ or ________ knowledge of the article’s presence
Consent; actual; constructive
The specific degree of negligence upon which liability rests varies with the type of bailment
Sole benefit of bailor - gross negligence
Sole benefit of bailee - slight negligence
Mutual benefit of parties - ordinary due care
Sole benefit of bailor
Gross negligence
Sole benefit of bailee
Slight negligence
Mutual benefit of parties
Ordinary due care
Bailment breach - burden of persuasion
Where the bailor seeks to recover for the bailee’s negligence, the bailor has the burden of persuasion that the bailee was negligent
Who has the burden of persuasion of the bailee’s negligence?
Bailor
The bailor can make out a p/f case of negligence by
Showing delivery of the goods to the bailee and the bailee’s failure to redeliver the goods, or redelivery of damaged goods
Limitation of liability - prof bailee
Public policy prevents a professional bailee from exempting herself from liability for her own negligence, although, she may, under proper circumstances, limit her liability. However, a professional bailee’s limitation is not valid unless the bailee knows, or should know, of the limitation and assents to it
Most courts hold that a claim check does not
Evidence a contract between the parties
A claim check is generally issued for
Purposes of identification, and the mere fact that a would-be contract provision is contained on the claim check is not sufficient proof that the bailor actually knew, or should have known, of this term
BFP of stolen goods versus true owner
A BFP of stolen goods is not protected against the claim of a true owner
Even a BFP can be held liable as
A converter
Negligence action
Where the bailor seeks to recover for the bailee’s negligence, the bailor has the burden of proving that the bailee was negligent. The standard of care for a bailment for the mutual benefit of the bailor and the bailee (for example, a bailment for hire) is ordinary due care
However, the bailor can make a p/f case of negligence merely by showing delivery of the goods to the bailee and the bailee’s failure to redeliver the goods or redelivery of damaged goods
Breach of contract action
Where the bailor seeks to recover under a breach of contract theory, the modern rule places the duty on the bailor to show that there was a bailment contract and that the bailee failed to perform on the contract by failing to return the goods or returning them damaged
T/F A delivery without acceptance by the bailee will not create a bailment, and the mere custody of a chattel is not sufficient in law to constitute possession
True
T/F It cannot be said a person is in possession of an article as a bailee unless she has knowledge or can be charged with knowledge of possession of the article
True
In VA, the right to appeal a decision to the CC is fairly broad. The ground applicable is that a decision of the GDC may be appealed to the CC within the same geographical area when the amount in controversy exceeds
$20
Lost property
When the owner has accidentally and involuntarily parted with its possession and does not know where to find it
A person who reduces lost property to possession becomes
It’s finder
Generally, the finder is entitled to possession of the property as against all except
The true owner
The true owner retains title unless
A sufficient time has run for the goods to be deemed abandoned and the possessor has a duty to find the owner
Although the normal bailment is consensual, a constructive bailment is created when
A person lawfully acquires possession of another’s personal property, other than by a bailment contract, and holds it under such circumstances that the law imposes on him the obligation to keep the property safe and redeliver it to its owner
A constructive bailment is created when
A person finds the lost property of another
Final judgment and decrees in cases originating in circuit courts can be appealed directly to the supreme court except when
1) The amount in controversy is purely pecuniary and the amount involved on appeal is less than $500, or
2) Appellate jurisdiction is assigned to the court of appeals, which includes cases involving circuit court review of administrative decisions, domestic relations cases, workers’ compensation cases, and some criminal cases
Abandoned property
Owner voluntarily relinquishes ownership with intent to give up both title and possession/control
Title to abandoned property acquired if
Finder has possession w intent to assert title and control
Lost property
Owner accidentally and involuntarily parted w possession
Owner doesn’t know where to find property