Performance Management Flashcards
What are the different strategic mentalities within multinational companies?
- International strategy mentality
- Domestic focus, product development for domestic market, non-responsive to local environment, controlled by headquarter - Multi-domestic strategic mentality
- Difference between domestic and foreign market demands, modifies products and marketing to local environment, decentralized decision and responsibility - Global strategic mentality
- Sees the world as a unit, standardized and homogenous products, non-responsive but powerful, CEO to VP product A worldwide, CEO to VP product B worldwide - Transnational strategic mentality
- Responsive to local needs, independent network of worldwide operations
What are the advantages/disadvantages of decentralization?
Advantages:
- Motivation for local managers
- Local knowledge
- Faster and closer decision making
Disadvantages
- Dysfunctional competition and friction
- Goal congruency and sub-optimization problems
- Top-management lose some control
What is the aim of performance management?
The process of formulating organizational goals and ensuring that goals are being met in an effective and efficient manner. The aim is that local performance should the consistent with overall corporate objectives. Design a PM system that support the strategy and structure
What is action control?
The actions taken - 4 basic forms:
- Behavioral constraints
- E.g., not being able to pay invoice above 10.000 kr. Without manager approve – avoiding fraud - Pre-action reviews
- Action accountability
- Checklists - Redundancy
- Doing things twice, backups
Pros:
- formulation of rules and routines
- documentation of best practise
Cons:
- jobs may be difficult to routine
- may discourage creativity
What is result control?
The results produced - tying performance to rewards
Decentralization: Typically, some that we see that evolves and do this to hold units responsible for the bottom line(profit). Measuring and how to reach the profit goals is up to the manager of the decentralized unit –> beneficial for the decentralized managers, but based on extrinsic rewards to might not reflect the more qualitative side
Pros:
o Results accountability, behavior can be influenced, pay for performance motivation
Cons:
o Joint controllability and conflicts
o Dysfunctional employee motivation
- Extrinsic rewards
What is people control?
- The types of people employed and their share values and norms
- Recruit the right people, sales culture and training
Also self control: exercised by the person, will control themselves and others
Intrinsic ruled, seen within professional areas – one might not be good enough to having pure self-control
Control own behavior and control other’s behavior (=culture control)
What are the different responsibility centers?
Revenue, cost, profit and investment
What is the advantages/disadvantages of the system approach by Anthony?
Advantages:
- Decentralization and hierarchy of decision making
- Long term planning
- Idea of being in control
Disadvantages:
- Strategic plan formulated by top-management (no look at lower levels)
- One way top-down communication of goals
- Result controls
What are the advantages/disadvantages of Simons diagnostic and interactive control?
Levers of control:
- Belief system
- Boundary systems
- Diagnostic control systems
- Interactive control systems
Advantages:
- Look-out function at lower-level management
- Interactive formulation and communication of goals
Disadvantages:
- Diagnostic system is not interactive
Tell about the expense center
Manager and employees control input in monetary terms but not output in monetary terms and not investment
Standard cost centers: when the amount of inputs required to produce each unit of output can be specified
Discretionary expense centers: no strong relation between inputs and output
Tell about the revenue center
Manager and employees control output in monetary terms but not input in monetary terms and not investments
Measurements: (budget-actual), revenues per salesman
Problems measurements: price decisions, marketing costs
- Problem: sales department can increase the marketing costs to increase revenue, but perhaps not controlled for these costs. Then they should rather be controlled on CM as they then also must consider the costs and not only revenue
Alternative: pseudo profit center: management is made responsible for profit due to an artificial transfer price for goods from another center
- Manufacturing department sell to the sales subsidiary and have an artificial transfer price, so make them responsible for some profit/CM center, since they might have a say on the price which means that the actively can control the CM
What are the three ideal technical qualitiess of a PMS?
- Responsibility – controllability
a. Need to be a match between the responsibility and controllability – need to be controlled on what you can control/be responsible for - Ability to measure the results effectively
a. Cannot only look at one thing and neglect the other - Must know the right norm
–> the quality criteria are important but need to have an eye out for the pragmatic effect (needs to fulfill the goal of the system, what is the effect in practice)
How can one evaluate a PM system?
There is no best form of control, what works in one situation may not work in another.
Evaluation:
1. Best fit
- What can they control and what type of responsibility center fits with this?
- Pro-active judgment of response
- Observation of pragmatic effects
What are the problems of controllability and measurebility?
- Interdependency between the units
- What gets measured gets done
- Dysfunctional employee behavior
- Intrinsic motivation vs. extrinsic
What are the differences between the mechanical (Anthony) and the actor approach?
Mechanical:
- measurements represent the objective truth
- observes at a distant
- automatic reward
Actor:
- measurement and reflection
- interactive observation
- considered reward
Explain the profit center
Manager and employees control both input and output in monetary terms but not the level of investment
Types of centers o Contribution margin center o Complete and incomplete o Pseudo profit --> Could be responsible for the CM (hence only variable costs), or pseudo profit where they are responsible for actions they cannot control (transferred in costs, indirect costs)
Aim: the reporting system should not create goal congruence
What is the issue with profit centers in regards to controllable vs. influenceable
Indirect/fixed costs that are allocated by a centralized decision
important: we investigate the decisions about why the costs are allocated. What does the allocation consist of? How is HR allocated, is it on numbers of employees or just divided to all units, are the units able to influence the allocation? It is beneficial to hold units accountable if they can influence this allocation (e.g., number of employees determine HR allocation)
What is the general transfer price rule?
Transfer price: outlay costs + opportunity costs
What are the main objectives of transfer prices?
- Should include goal congruent decisions = the system should be designed so that decisions optimizing business unit profit will also optimize company profit
- Should provide a measure of the performance of the division manager
- Preserve or maintain divisional autonomy
What are the general principles for market vs. negotiated prices vs. cost based prices
- Competitive or imperfect at capacity = market prices
- Imperfect competition (external+internal purchase/selling, difference in operating at or below capacities across departments) = negotiated prices
- No external market = ABC, marginal, or standard
What is the strategic approach to transfer pricing?
Another view is that the transfer price should reflect the strategy.
Needs to consider if the product is in the start or middle of the Lifecyle, whether the technology is important or not, and if the company is diversified and high or low integrated.