Peace and Justice Flashcards
What is meant by the term ‘pacifism?
Opposition to war or violence as a means for settling disputes
-specifically: refusal to carry weapons on moral or religious grounds
Name 3 reasons why someone may identify as a pacifist?
Religious faith
Non-religious belief in the SofL
Practical belief- war is wasteful
What are the 4 types of pacifism?
Absolute pacifism
Conditional pacifism
Selective pacifism
Active pacifism
Outline the basic principles of absolute pacifism
Believes it’s never right to take part in war- even self- defence
-Think that the cost of human life is too high
Hard position to take- unwavering view= uncomfortable position
Usually basic principle
Outline the basic principles of conditional pacifism
Against war and violence in principle
BUT
accept circumstances where it’s better than the alternative
Outline the basic principles of selective pacifism
Only oppose wars involving weapons of mass destruction
- believe there are degrees of ‘bad’
– either because:
War is unwinnable
or
Uniquely devastating consequences
Outline the basic principles of active pacifism
May refuse to fight in wars
OR
some may help for good (e.g. drive ambulances)
–>conscientious objectors
What are the 2 arguments against pacifism?
Outline them
Pacifism can’t be national policy
Doesn’t work on national scale, naive to believe it would
BUT, UN plays part in spreading pacifism through international disputes
Just War
Because the world isn’t perfect, not all wars are wrong
-moral obligation to protect country?
pacifism has no place in the face of extreme evil
How many conscientious objectors were there in WW1?
16,000
How many conscientious objectors were there in WW2?
59,000
What’s the timeline of pacifism and JWT within Christianity?
Jesus- pacifist
Roman Empire adopts Christianity (300 AD)
Auqustine started JWT
- actions of RE didn’t fit w/ pacifist philosophy
Aquinas adds to conditions
UN adds to conditions
What are the conditions of Just War Theory?
1) Must be started by a proper authority
- - an organisation that doesn’t represent the people of an area can’t give up those people’s lives
2) Must have a good chance of success
- - wasteful otherwise
3) Must promote good over evil
- -fought w/ the intention to benefit lives
4) MUST use no more force than necessary
- -noble?
5) Must be last resort
- -can’t be a light decision
6) Must have a just cause/ good reason
- -wasteful otherwise
Why was Just War Theory made?
The actions of the Roman Empire didn’t fit with the pacifist ideals of the religion that they had adopted
What are the Christian arguments supporting pacifism?
Sanctity of Life - gift from God Murder is wrong - 'You shall not murder' God doesn't want us to fight - 'Blessed are the peacemakers, they will be called the children of God' - 'For those who live by the sword die by the sword' Jesus was a pacifist
What are the Christian arguments against pacifism?
We have the right to defend ourselves
Murder is different to killing
Soldiers could be considered peacemakers- ‘Blessed are the peacemakers…’
Sacrifice
- Jesus sacrificed himself, follow his example?
Jesus was a pacifist- BUT, he never addressed full war, only small conflicts
‘The Lord is a warrior’
What is the general Christian attitude to pacifism?
Quakers= pacifist
Most others= accept war as necessary evil
– have to follow JWT
How may a Christian put their beliefs about pacifism and conflict into action?
May join the army to help fight
Help those who are affected by war (e.g drive ambulances, relief work)
What are the conditions of a holy war?
Has a religious goal
Authorised by a religious leader
There will be a spiritual reward at the end
Who is a famous Christian who was against war?
Martin Luther King
Who is a famous Christian who supported war?
George Bush