Patent Bar Flashcards
PLTIA
Patent Law Treaties and Implementation Act; went into effect December 18, 2013; stated you don’t need a claim in an application to secure a filing date; can revive priority application in order to keep priority if accidentally abandoned (2 month window); Changed the rule to UNINTENTIONALLY abandoned (instead of unintentionally or unavoidably)
GATT (general agreement on tariffs and treaties)
Went into effect June 8, 1995; Changed patent life from 17 years to 20; began provisional application practice;
Jan 1 1996: Date of invention in any WTO country could be used to swear behind a reference in a US case
Number of claims in a design patent
One
Design patent claim preamble
“The ornamental design as shown and described”
1 year response period
Grace period for filing under pre-AIA 102(b) and exception period under AIA 102
Deadline after issue for copying a claim of an issued patent or published application for interference
Deadline for replacing provisional application
Foreign priority deadlines
1 year for utility and plant applications
6 months for design
What can never be added to an application
New Matter
Basis for reexamination
Only patents and printed publications
6 month rule
Cannot file a response more than 6 months after an official action (statutory limit), cannot extend past 6 months
Must respond to ALL parts of the action
What is the term of a patent? (non-design)
20 years from first non-provisional filing date (Before June 8, 1995 it was 17 years from date of issue)
What is the term of a design patent?
Before May 13, 2015 14 years from issue; after that 15 years from issue (Hague Agreement)
When can you suspend prosecution
Only when there are no outstanding actions
Recording of an assignment must
be in English or feature a translation
Continuations, divisional’s, and continuation-in-parts must be ______ with their parents
Copending
2 year deadline
Deadline for filing broadened reissue;
Time limit for reviving patent lapsed for failure to pay maintenance fee
5 Years
The maximum time of term extension for delay in appeal under PTE (patent term extension)
How do you calculate the filing deadline for a preissuance submission?
- the LATER of (a) 6 months after the date on which the application is published, or (b) the date of the first rejection;
- the EARLIER of this date or the notice of allowance
AIA Phase 2
September 16, 2012; date for new AIA oath/declaration requirements, supplemental examination, preissuance submissions, inter partes review (instead of inter partes reexamination), PGR, and covered business method review
March 16, 2013
Implementation of AIA 102 and first to file system
Extension of time to pay issue fee
CANNOT EXTEND
Broadening claims in reexamination
CANNOT BROADEN
How to make changes to an inventor’s oath/declaration
Cannot amend, must submit new/amend ADS
Terminal disclaimer appplies when
Obviousness type double patenting
Recapture
In a reissue, cannot broaden to claim subject matter given up during prosecution
Only residents/nationals of a country can _____
File a PCT there
______ are prohibited in supplemental examination
Interviews
No _____ may be filed in a supplemental examination
Amendments
What do you need to obtain a filing date?
Only a specification
Issue fee can be paid late if
Unintentional or unavoidable
If patent is lapses because the issue fee inadvertently wasn’t paid, it can be ____ within _____
Revived within 2 years
Ways to obtain a foreign filing license
1) Filing receipt
2) Petitioning the commissioner to ask for one
3) Automatically 6 months from filing (ALL patents)
Petition to make special (4 things)
1) Applicant’s age or health
2) Renewable energy
3) Environment
4) Terrorism
Inventoris dead/incapacitated/lost
Substitute statement in lieu of
Patent issues and you think your claims are too narrow, so you ______
File a reissue (within 2 years)
Obtain a filing date the day you mail something
Express Mail
Extensions of time in a reexamination must be filed ____
Before the deadline to respond
Ways to correct priority claims in an issued patent
1) Reissue
2) Certificate of correction (if its a continuation and the parent’s priority claim is good)
You’ve received a final rejection and want to enter an amendment that’s been refused and don’t want to appeal
RCE or continuation
You want to bring prior art to the attention of the patent office in an application which you are not a part of
1) Protest
2) Third party pre-issuance submission
Application was filed in a foreign country without a foreign filing license
Obtain a retroactive foreign filing license
Minor mistake in your patent when its issued
Certificate of Correction
Minor mistake in your patent that was the mistake of the patent office
Certificate of Correction (no fee)
When can all issues be considered in reexamination?
If a supplemental examination initiates it
Two things that the six month rule doesn’t apply to
1) Appeal brief
2) notice of missing parts
Only section of 102 that you can use to reject a claim
102(a)
The only people that are barred from getting a patent
PTO employees
1.53(d) continuations/divisionals
Only design patents
Claim limit for prioritized examination
4 independent, 30 total, no multiple dependents
Applications not allowed for prioritized examination
Designs, provisionals, reissues, reexamination, PCT applications that haven’t entered the national stage
Applications allowed for prioritized examination
Utility non-provisional patents, continuations, plant applications, PCT applications that have entered the national stage, RCEs (only can apply once)
Prioritized examination is terminated when
Anything closing prosecution (allowance, final rejection)
Actions that cancel prioritized examination and place it on regular docket
Adding too many claims, extending time.
Prioritized examination must be _____
Ready for examination (fee, claims, everything included)
Who can file a derivation proceeding?
Any 3rd party
When can you file a derivation proceeding?
Within 1 year of first publication of the claims of earlier invention
For a derivation proceeding, claims must be _____
The same or substantially the same
Which patents can undergo derivation?
Only AIA
Inter Partes Reexamination ____
Does not exist anymore
Who can file an IPR?
3rd party
What can you rely on to file IPR
Only patents and printed publications
When can you file an IPR
9 months after issuance or after PGR is completed
Must be a _____ to file IPR
Reasonable likelihood of success
IPR is only available after______
September 16 2012
Who can file post grant review?
Anyone
Which patents are available for post grant review?
Only AIA
Which patents are subject to IPR?
All patents
When can you file a post grant review?
Within 9 months of issuance
What can be used in a post grant review?
All patentability issues
What is the threshold for post grant review?
Preponderance of evidence (high threshold)
Who can file a covered business method?
Bank/financial service company that has been sued
When can you file a covered business method?
After post grant review is completed
Which patents are subject to covered business method?
All patents related to banking, finance, etc.
Which issues can be brought up in covered business methods?
All patentability issues
Who can file reexamination?
Anyone
When can reexamination be filed?
Until 6 years after the expiration of the patent.
Which patents are subject to reexamination?
All patents
What is the standard for initiating a reexamination?
Substantial new question of patentability
What happens at the conclusion of reexamination?
Reexamination certificate
What can you not do in reexamination?
Broaden claims
Certificate of Correction to correct priority claim
Only for continuations when the parent’s priority is perfected
Terminal disclaimer doesn’t apply when
Same invention type double patenting
When can a patent be revived?
When it was unintentionally abandoned (not unavoidably, that was removed with PLTIA)
To patent a plant it must have been
Asexually produced
Extensions of time in reexamination are _______
Not automatic, only for cause
When are you officially withdrawn from representing a client?
When the Commissioner approves your request
Five month response period
Maximum automatic extension of time
Multiple dependent claims cannot _____ on _____
depend on multiple dependent claims
What must you do in a restriction requirement
Elect claims
Access to an unpublished, abandoned application
Mentioned in an issued patent
What must be identified on an inventor’s oath or declaration?
Must identify: inventor’s legal name (every inventor on an application must execute one), application, and inventor’s mailing address
How are dates of USPTO actions calculated?
All dates are calculated from MAILING DATE from the USPTO which is stamped on the action
When are maintenance fees due after issue of a patent?
3.5 years, 7.5 years, 11.5 years
Three months response period
Normal shortened statutory period to respond to Official Action;
Unextendable pay period to pay issue fee and file formal drawing;
When will applicant receive filing date at the patent office?
Rule 1.53(b)-
Filing date is the date on which the specification (with or without claims) is received at the PTO
No new matter may be introduced after the filing date
What is the minimum requirement to receive a provisional filing date?
Specification and any necessary drawings
If cover sheet is missing or fee not paid or no drawings present, applicant will get a Notice of Missing Parts and have TWO MONTHS to complete
Rule 1.53(c)
Two month response requirements
Period for responding to ex parte quayle action (what is this??);
Deadline for response to Notice of Missing Parts;
Period for responding in reexam;
All deadlines on appeal are two months;
Deadline for filing petition after decision on reconsideration by the examiner
130 Affidavit
Rule 1.130- Grace period affidavit (AIA rule)
Applicant can disqualify prior art disclosure made by inventor if it falls within the ONE YEAR grace period by submitting a 130 affidavit
The only way to assert that a piece of prior art qualified under 102(a)(1) or 102(a)(2) under the AIA actually falls within exceptions under 102(b)(1) or 102(b)(2)
Must be submitted before close of prosecution; use when art has been cited against you
Continued prosecution application (CPA)
Rule 1.53(d) -DESIGNS ONLY
CPA is a request to expressly abandon prior application as of the filing date of the CPA–method of continuing prosecution on an application
A continuation or divisional (not CIP) may be filed as a CPA if filed before payment of issue fee on prior application OR before abandonment of prior application OR befor eterminatoin of proceedings on prior application
How can you correct inventorship in an application?
Rule 1.48-
Submit an updated ADS;
For any new inventor, need new oath or declaration
With incorrect inventorship, instead of filing petition to correct can instead file a continuation application with the correct inventors as long as one inventor remains in common between the parent and child apps
Application data sheet
Has to identify names of inventors, addresses, and priority entitlement the application has
Must be submitted within the later of: 4 months of filing or within 16 months of foreign filing
Rules for joint inventorship
Rule 1.45; Joint inventors must apply for patent jointly and each must make an oath or declaration
Inventors may apply for a patent jointly even if (a) they didn’t physically work together at the same time, (b) each inventor did not make the same amount or type of contribution, (c) each inventor did not make a contribution to the subject matter of every claim
Each inventor must contribute to the subject matter of at least one claim
131 Affidavit
Rule 1.131- Swearing back affidavit- PRE-AIA ONLY
Applicant can overcome a rejection based on prior art b establishing that the date of invention is before the prior art date- on a claim by claim basis
Must be submitted before final rejection
132 Affidavit
Rule 1.132; Applicant can overcome objection or rejection by submitting new evidence in an oath or declaration
May be used to establish that reference cited is applicant’s own work (i.e. if publication authorship is different from patent app inventorship)
Must be submitted before close of prosecution.
Who is considered an applicant?
Inventor OR owner (the AIA introduced the concept of owner being an applicant)
What is the shortened statutory period for responding to a restriction requirement?
One month
Broadening claims in a reissue
Only within 2 years of issue
Interviews before official actions?
Only continuation
Who can file a PCT at the USPTO?
US residents and nationals
If filed at USPTO, must be in English
Requirements for filing PCT
Have to:
-Request to be international
-Designate at least one PCT state
-List names of applicants
-Include spec, claims, drawings
-Include abstract and fee (can be late?)
What date did AIA go into effect?
September 16, 2011 (Signed into law; track I examination went into effect); September 16, 2012 (start of PGR, ended inter partes reexam, began ability to file in name of assignee instead of inventors); March 16 2013 (transition date for patents! first to invent–>first to file)
Derivation proceeding
Only applies to claims that are substantially the same
Has to be supported by substantial evidence
Only AIA
When can an appeal be filed?
After the final rejection or second office action
What is included in an appeal brief?
-Identify applicant
-List any related appeals and interferences by the same owner and in the same patent family
-Summary of claimed subject matter
-Arguments for each rejection (only have the record between you and the examiner to use as evidence, CANNOT bring new evidence that the examiner had not seen!!)
-Appendix with a copy of the claims being appealed
What is included in an appeal?
Identify the applicant, list appeals and interferences, list claims that are being appealed, argue each rejection
Why might you file an appeal instead of a request for continued examination (RCE)?
In an RCE, applicant would have same examiner and same rejections; if you can’t figure out how to overcome those rejections, then appeal can help get around this. BUT appeal is much more expensive
How long do you have after notice of appeal to file an appeal brief?
Two months to file appeal brief, can buy 5 more months
What is required in an appeal brief?
Claims appendix
When does jurisdiction pass to the board in an appeal?
When the reply brief is filed or when the deadline to file an appeal brief has passed
Rule 1.181
Have rejection designated as a new ground of rejection
Two possible courses of action in response to an Examiner’s Answer
1) File a 1.181 petition to have it designated as a new ground of rejection
2) submit a reply brief
4 possible changes in a rejection that constitute a new ground of rejection
1) Change in statutory basis (103 to 102, or vice versa) ((if it is based on the same teaching, it is NOT a new ground of rejection)
2) Examiner cites new calculations
3) Examiner cites new structures
4) Pointing to a different portion of the claim to maintain a “new matter” rejection
Dictionaries are considered ______
Standard references and can always be relied upon
Claims appendix should include _____
Claims involved in the appeal process