Parliament Flashcards
What does public law do?
Arranges the relationships between an individuals and the state.
What does private law do?
Audits the relationships between individuals.
What is public law?
Public law is about when the state is allowed to kill you.
Because we are a small country, do we face the same problems as other, bigger nations?
Yes, despite our size we face the same issues.
What problems/issues do we face as countries?
- How do we survive and thrive together?
- We usually want different things how can we co-exist despite our disagreements?
How do we survive and thrive together?
We have rules that allow us to co-exist despite our disagreements. Everyone has to follow the common rules even if they don’t agree with them. These rules and the need to follow them underpins our state.
What measures can the state use to ensure people follow our common rules?
Can go up to and as far as killing someone.
i.e. Armed offenders squad are allowed to kill people
Where does public law come from?
History.
Do we always have good reasons for doing things other than history?
Nope.
How can public power help ordinary people? (example)
Public power can help people do things they are not ordinarily allowed to do.
i.e. On top of university fees payed by the individual, the government pits in far more money on top. We only pay about 75%. If the government did not do this, many people would not be able to study.
Which limits apply to public power?
- The cabinet manual.
- The consitution.
What does the constitution set out?
Who has public power, how they can use it, the restraints of this power, etc.
Examples of constitutional documents?
- NZBORA
- ToW
- BOR
- Magna Carta (some parts)
- Electorial Act
Key documents that underpin how our system of law works.
When was the Waitangi Tribunal established and where?
TOW Act – 1975.
Why was the Waitangi Tribunal established?
Established Waitangi tribunal to look at claims of breaches of the treaty.
What are the three proposals about the treaty by the current government?
- To make a legislative document defining the principles of the treaty.
- To take out treaty references in legislation so that the courts no longer have to apply the principles of the treaty
- Even if there needs to be some consultation, this should not amount to having separate authorities only acting for maori.
Equality
We all get the same, the same stuff, opportunities etc
Equity
We get what we need to get to the same place.
What can we do as the people if we disagree with the government?
- Protest
- Submissions
- Etc.
Should we as a society prohibit people from wearing gang parafanalia in public?
What are the arguments?
In favour:
- Reduce public intimidation
- The gang patches are branding for the group
- They advertise the group
- If we take away the patches, we might make the gangs smaller or eradicate them
Against:
- Maybe it is a sticking plaster over a deeper problem, this would only fix the surface level issue
- If people join because they are on the margians may be drawn to it more because it is illegal
- Freedom of Expression.
What does the constitution set out?
It outlines the elements of public power
- Who has power
- What powers
- Who has certain positions and why
- What can people do with that position
- Why can they or cant they do certain things
- Extents of use of power
Which methods does the constitution use to outline public power?
Legal and political.
What was the Luxon house contravercy?
Facts:
- As a matter of law, the PM may get up to $52,000 if they don’t want to live in premier house.
- This is totally legal. Chris Luxon took the allowence as he did not want to live in premier house.
- The public thought it was hypocritical and hated it.
- His government is telling people that there is not a lot of money and we need to cut back. While he is legally acting in his actions, it is contradictory to his words.
Held:
- Public reaction matters. Political response to a public decision impacts how decisions are made. It holds those with public power accountable to the people they hold this power over.
What is Parliament?
- The central foundational institution
- The interface of the law and politics
- It consists of the sovereign (represented by Governor General) and the House of Representatives
- Make and amend legislation
Role of the sovereign?
- Largely ceremonial
- Where the role is legally significant, the role is carried out on the advice of the prime minister
- A bill becomes law when the sovereign or the governor general assents to it and signs it in token of such interest – s16 constitution act
Who actually holds the GG’s power?
The Prime Minister - GG must act on their advice
When will the GG not follow the PM’s advice?
When the PM does not have majority support in the house.
What part of parliament really matters?
The House of Representatives - these are the people who have the power to decide what becomes law etc.