Parliament Flashcards
Ways to hold the government to account - PMQs (governing party)
MPs are able to ask the PM easy questions to make the PM look good as well as the government
Ways to hold the government to account - PMQs (opposition)
Opposition MPs try to score points by asking questions to make the PM and government look stupid and incompetent - opposition leader can ask 6 questions
When do PMQs take place? And for how long?
Every Wednesday, for 30 minutes
Pros of PMQs
- Provides an opportunity for the Commons to challenge the PM
- Forces the PM to be well informed (and on the ball) about policy and wider news agenda
Cons of PMQs
- Too many questions asked by ‘friendly’ government backbenchers (who wants to make the PM look smart)
- PMQs have become an exercise in point-scoring rather than asking important, helpful questions
Ways to hold the government to account - Public Bill Committee (PBC)
Temporary committees, formed to scrutinise a bill after its second reading, with the power to take written & oral evidence, debate & amend the bill (legislative)
Pros of PBCs
- Can scrutinise the Commons passing any bills in any form and way they want.
- Makes the government think twice
Cons of PBCs
Amendments that are contrary to a majority government’s wishes are rarely accepted - contradicts links to Parliamentary Sovereignty
Ways to hold the government to account - Select Committees (SC)
Small groups of MPs or members of the House of Lords that are set up to investigate a specific issue in detail or to perform a specific scrutiny job
- SCRUTINISES government DEPARTMENTS
- a GOVERNMENT with a majority will also have a MAJORITY IN THE COMMITTEE
Pro of SC
More independent than PBCs - free to be critical
Work is respected because it’s evidence based (hearings are televised and reported in the media - increases influence)
Cons of SC
Majority of SC members are picked from governing party
Can cover only a limited range of topics in depth (avoids long-term investigations)
An example of SC
PAC held Amazon, Starbucks and Google to account in 2013 when they paid limited tax. They held multinational companies to account, so they can hold the PM and gov to account
How many Lords are there?
791 Lords (mostly life peers and 92 hereditary - most appointed by the PM)
What can the Lords do?
Can delay legislation for up to 1 year - due to the 1911 and 1949 Parliament Acts.
Scrutinises legislation and can force government to amend bills
What can’t the Lords do?
- Has no jurisdiction over financial matters
- Has no power to dismiss a government
- Don’t represent constituencies, but other interests
Pros of The Lords
Less partisanship and party loyalty than in the Commons (more independent)
-so can vote more freely and critically
- can argue and answer more clearly in debates
Cons of The Lords
- Can’t do anything long term
- e.g the 1949 Parliament Act meant the Lords could only delay legislation for up to a year
- House of Lords will not oppose the second or third reading of any government legislation promised in its election (SALISBURY ADDISON CONVENTION)