Other Torts Flashcards
What is a public nuisance?
An activity that is an unreasonable interference with a public right.
How is a claim for public nuisance brought?
- Brought by a government actor such as an attorney general.
- An individual action: the individual must show that she is suffering harm different and distinct from the public at large.
What are the elements of a private nuisance?
- A thing or activity
- That substantially or unreasonably
- Interferes with a π’s use or enjoyment of his land.
What mental state required for private nuisance?
The ∆ must be notified of interference and the ∆ continued action after being put on notice establishes intent.
What factors should be weighed in private nuisance claim?
- The value of the ∆’s activity
- Alternatives available to both ∆ and the π to minimize the harm
- The nature of the locality
- Extent of the plaintiff’s injury
And
- Who was there first?
What remedy is available for a nuisance?
- Injunctions
Or
- Damages
What is an injunction?
An equitable remedy sought by π that mandates a ∆ to stop an activity.
What must be shown for a π to obtain an injunction for a private nuisance claim?
- There is a nuisance
- π is suffering irreparable harm through the continuing nature of nuisance
And
- Damages are not an adequate remedy.
What are the elements of defamation?
- ∆ Published
- Defamatory material
- Concerning the π
- That caused reputation harm
What are false reputation harming communications?
Defamations
What is are the steps to analyzing a defamation claim?
Step 1: Determine if the communication defamatory
Step 2: Evaluate pleading issues
Step 3: Evidence of Publication
Step 4: Determine what the type of defamation is: libel or slander
Step 5: Determine if common law privileges are applicable Step 6: Analyze any first amendment issues
What are the elements of a defamatory statement?
- The statement can be believed to be truthful
- It subjects the π to:
a. Scorn
b. Ridicule
c. Contempt
Or
d. Deters 3rd parties from dealing with them
What statements cannot be defamatory?
- Hyperbole: no reasonable person would believe the statement
And
- Pure Opinions
Can the tort claim for defamation survive death?
No, the dead do not have defamation claims.
When is a communication reputation-harming?
It subjects the π to:
a. Scorn
b. Ridicule
c. Contempt
Or
d. Deters 3rd parties from dealing with them
What are pure opinions?
Statements that cannot be proved to be true or false.
How can a π assert defamation when the π is not named in the published statement?
The π must prove that is of or concerning her.
What is the limit on scope of defamation?
It only applies to identifiable persons. If said about a group generally it is not defamation.
What is publication in defamation?
When a ∆ intentionally or negligently permitted someone other than the π to come into contact with the defamatory statement.
What are the elements of publication?
- ∆ intentionally or negligently permitted
- A third party to hear the defamation.
What is the republication rule?
In addition to the defendant who originates the defamatory message, other persons who repeat the defamation will be liable for the defemation Republication may lead to liability even if the statement is disclaimed “∆ said, {defamatory statement}.” Multiplying a defamatory statement attaches liability to the multipliers.
What is libel?
A defamatory message embodied in a relatively permanent form (e.g. a writing, photo, media).
What are the types of defamations?
- Libel
- Slander
What are the elements of slander claim?
- Defamation
- Defamation message not in a permanent form (oral)
- Special damages which are specific economic damages flowing from the defamation
What is the effect of slander per se?
The π does not have to prove special damages, they are presumed.
What are the types of defamations that trigger slander per se?
Do not have to prove special damages if the defamation is about a π’s:
- Performance in business or trade
- Commission of a crime involving moral turpitude or infamous punishment (imprisonment or death)
- Having a loathsome disease (venereal disease or leprosy).
- Unchastity to a woman or general sexual impropriety.
When does a π not need to prove special damages for a slander claim?
When the defamatory statement is in a slander per se category.