Other Torts Flashcards
Elements for public nuisance claim
1) D unreasonably interfered with a public right (typically right to health, safety, or property); and
2) P suffered a distinct and different harm from the public at large
Who has standing to bring a public nuisance claim?
- Government (common), or
- Individual (must show that she is suffering from a different and distinct harm than the public at large)
Elements of private nuisance claim
Substantial and unreasonable interference of P’s use or enjoyment of their land
What constitutes substantial and unreasonable interference for a nuisance claim?
Substantial: Offensive, inconvenient, or annoying to a reasonable, ordinary person
Unreasonable: Injury outweighs utility of behavior
What are the remedies for nuisance?
- Injunctions;
- Damages
Differentiate between nuisance and trespass
Nuisance:
- No physical invasion required (can be light, smells, etc)
- Continuous
- Substantial interference
Trespass:
- Physical invasion required
- Does not need to be continuous
- Does not need substantial interference
Elements of defamation
1) Defamatory statement;
2)** Concerning P**;
3) Published to a third party (either intentionally or negligently);
4) That damages P’s reputation
If matter is of public concern or P is a public figure, must also show →
5) D acted with actual malice
2 types of defamation
1) Libel (written)
2) Slander (spoken)
What types of statements are considered defamatory?
Those that diminish respect or goodwill towards P or deter 3rd parties from dealing with them
What type of statements are not considered defamatory?
Hyperbole: no reasonable person would believe the statement
Pure opinions: cannot be proved true or false
⚠️ Note: Opinions can be defamatory if speaker implies knowledge of facts
What constitutes publication for defamation?
D intentionally or negligently makes statement to a third party (someone other than the person bringing the action)
⚠️ Note: If third party learns of the statement through the grapevine, no defamation claim
What is the re-publication rule?
If someone repeats or re-publishes a defamatory statement, they can be held liable (even if they claim they don’t know whether or not the statement is true)
Can the dead be defamed?
No
Define
Libel
Defamatory statement that is written, published, or expressed in physical form
Are defamatory TV and radio broadcasts considered libel?
Yes
Elements of trade libel
- Publication;
- Of a disparaging statement about quality of P’s business or service;
- That D knew was false or acted with reckless disregard for its truth; and
- P suffered economic harm
What type of damages does P have to prove to recover for libel?
General damages are presumed, P doesn’t need to prove special damages
Define
Slander
Defamatory statement made orally
What damages need to be proven for slander?
Special damages, i.e, calculable damages
⚠️ Note: Special damages do not need to be proved for slander per se
Define
Slander per se
Defamatory statement that doesn’t require proof of special damages.
Accuses P of either:
* Misconduct that reflects poorly on P’s profession;
* Committing a crime involving moral turpitude;
* Having a loathsome disease; or
* Sexual misconduct or impropriety
If defamation involves a matter of public concern, what must P prove?
- Statement was false; and either:
- Actual malice (public figure) or negligence (private figure)
Define
Matter of public concern
- Relates to the political, social, or other concerns of the community; or
- Newsworthy issue that is of general concern to the public
Who is considered a public figure for defamation?
Household names, those who have widely known fame
What constitutes actual malice for defamation?
-
Knowing the published information was false; or
* Recklessly disregarding the truth or falsity of the statement