Organisations, movements & members Flashcards
What features of churches does Troeltsch identify?
- churches are large organisations
- they claim a monopoly of the truth
- they are universal, but more attractive to higher classes because they are ideologically conservative
What features of Sects does Troeltsch identify?
- sects are small exclusive groups
- draw their members from the poor and oppressed
- hostile to wider society & demand high level of commitment
- believe they have monopoly of religious truth
What features of denominations does Niebuhr identify?
- describes denominations as lying midway between churches and sects because
- they broadly accept society’s values
- impose minor restrictions on members e.g. no alcohol
What features of cults does Niebuhr identify?
- highly individualistic loose-knit usually without an exclusive belief system
- usually led by practitioners or therapists who claim special knowledge
- do not demand strong commitment from its followers
What organisations have arisen that lie outside the religious mainstream?
- New religious movements
How does Wallis explain how these new religious movements can be distinguished?
- by the worldview in which they have adopted
- world rejecting NRMs
- world accommodating NRMs
- world affirming NRMs
What is a reason for the emergence of NRMs?
- Wilson argues that periods of social change disrupt & undermine established norms & values producing anomie
What are the characteristics of world-rejecting NRMs
- similar to Troetsch’s sects e.g. Moonies, Children of God
- as they are critical of the outside world & seek radical change
- have conservative moral codes
What is the reason for rise of world rejecting NRMs?
- Wallis point to social changes from the 1960s e.g. the increased amount of time young people spent in education as well as a rise in radical political movements
- these factors led to their growth because young people adopted radical worldviews > thus world rejecting NRMS were attractive as they offered a idealistic way of life to young people
What are the characteristics of world-accommodating NRMs?
- formed due to breakaways of existing mainstream churches or denominations e.g. neo-Pentecostalists
- they focus on religious matters rather than worldly matters, seeking to restore the spirituality of religion
What is the reason for growth of world accommodating NRM’s?
- due to complaints surrounding mainstream religion
What are the characteristics of world-affirming NRMs?
- like cults e.g. Scientology
- as they accept the world as it is> very optimistic
- offer special knowledge that enable followers to unlock their own spiritual powers & success
What are the reasons for the growth of world-affirming NRMs?
- Bruce argues they have grew in popularity as a result of modernity
> work no longer provides meaning or a source of identity
> World affirming emerged to provide that sense of identity & techniques that promise success in this world
Evaluation of Wallis categorisation of NRMs
- Stark & Bainbridge argue that the only criterion which should be used to distinguish NRMs is the degree of conflict & tension between the religious movement & wider society > explanation suffers from faulty premise
- Wallis portrays these movements as static structures, ignores the diversity of beliefs that may exist within in NRM > more dynamic than portrayed
What two organisations do Stark & Bainbridge believe are in conflict with wider society?
- sects and cults