Offer and Acceptance Flashcards
The three essential elements required to form a legally binding contract.
- consideration
- intention to create legal relations
- agreement
An offer must be
- valid (clear, certain, addressed to the offeree)
- communicated to the offeree
- not rejected, revoked or lapsed
An acceptance must be
- A mirror of the offer
- made by the offeree in response to the offer
- communicated to the offeror
A valid offer: an expression of willingness to contract on specific terms made with the intention that it is to become legally binding as soon as it is accepted by the person to whom it is addressed
Treitel
If the reasonable person would have considered the terms to be as proposed by the other party, despite his intention, then the contract is valid
Smith v Hughes
There is an invalid offer when the subjective knowledge of an error defeats the objective appearance of an agreement - also known as ‘snapping up’
Hartog v Colin & Shields
For a valid offer the parties must demonstrate an intention to enter into a legal relationship
- Language of ‘may’ was not sufficient (Gibson v Manchester CC)
- Language of ‘will’ was sufficient (Storer v MCC)
An invitation to treat (ITT)
- the preliminary stage of negotiations
- an ITT is not an offer
Adverts
- the general rule is that an advert is an ITT i.e. not an offer
An advert containing few details was not an offer but an ITT
Partridge v Crittenden
- Partridge was not convicted of offering wild birds for sale.
The display of goods is also an ITT
Fisher v Bell
Placing goods on supermarket shelves is also and invitation to treat. The offer is made by the customers at the till.
Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots Chemists
Parking machines are offering as they are ready to receive the money and the acceptance takes place when the customer puts his money in the slot
Thornton v Shoe Land Parking.
The court regarded a pile of deck chairs as the offer and the act of sitting down on them as acceptance
Chapelton v Barry UDC
Exception: where an advert is clear and certain enough to demonstrate an intention to be bound, and is from the product’s manufacturer, an advert may constitute an offer.
Grainger v Gough
An advert conched in a certain language may be an offer, if it is a unilateral offer.
Carill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co
A unilateral offer:
one that prescribes an act, the performance of which constitutes acceptance
Offer and acceptance over the telegram was not in fact concluded when the title deeds were not sent.
Harvey v Facey
A letter outlining the conditions for acceptance was found to be merely a preliminary statement as to the price rather than an offer capable of an acceptance.
Clifton v Palumbo
The council’s letter to the tenant outlining the purchase price was deemed to be no more than an invitation to treat
Gibson v Manchester CC
Invitation to Tender
- where the parties are invited to provide offers.
- this is not an Invitation to Treat nor an offer.
P1 sent in the highest offer, but was not accepted. P2 did not commit to selling to the highest bidder and so was free to choose which offer was accepted or to accept none.
Spencer v Harding
Exceptions to invitations to tender
- if the party calling the bids makes a commitment in relation to the tender.
- Blackpool Aero Club v Blackpool BC (not checking their mailbox before the deadline)
- Harvela Investments v Royal Trust of Canada (agreed to sell to the highest bidder)
At auctions, offers are made by the bidders, and are only accepted by use of the auctioneers hammer. Items can be withdrawn at the auctioneers or bidders discretion at any time before the hammer falls
Payne v Cave
The refusal of an auctioneer to accept a low bid and then to subsequently withdraw an Item from auction is a breach of a unilateral contract.
Barry v Davies
An offer must always be communicated to the offeree in one of three ways, so as to give the offeree a chance to accept or reject it
Taylor v Laird
- Orally
- In writing
- by conduct
An offer can be terminated by
- rejection
- counter offer
- battle of the forms
- withdrawal / revocation
- lapse
Counter offer
- an attempt to accept an offer on new terms
- this is a rejection of the first offer
- this also terminates the original offer
The proposal to by a farm for a different offer was deemed to be a counter offer
Hyde v Wrench
An enquiry as to the offer is not a counter offer and therefore does not terminate the offer
Stevenson v McLean
An exploratory letter inquiring as to a reduction in price is not to be considered as a counter offer.
Gibson v Manchester CC
Battle of the forms
parties doing business exchange paperwork which in fact constitutes a written dispute over whose terms are to govern the deal.
The stamping of a delivery note was deemed a counter offer and the acceptance of this offer was the driving of the lorry into the warehouse - an acceptance by conduct.
BRS v Arthur Crutchley
The signing and return of a buyers’ tear off slip had made the contract on the buyers terms.
Butler machine tool Co