Objective 2 Flashcards
Describe Risk Management Culture
Risk Governance and Organization Structure - clear definition of roles
Incentive Compensation Structure - align with long term goals
Risk Appetite Framework
Risk Reporting and Communication - frequent risk reporting around key risks
Describe successful Risk Appetite Framework
Thorough understanding of enterprise risk profile in relation to risk appetite.
Track record of containing risk exposures within the chosen tolerance and limits.
Well-defined framework.
Active involvement from Board and strong buy in from senior management
From ERM score: What is Risk Controls?
How is it scored?
Risk controls analyze the processes insurers employ to manage key risk exposures (i.e: Insurance risk, credit risk, etc).
Each material risk is scored: positive, negative or neutral
Describe Emerging Risk Management
Emerging risk management analyzes how the insurer addresses risks that are not a current threat, but could be in the future.
Eg: Regulation and medical developments.
Good Risk Model
The robustness and consistency of models is scored.
Captures material risk exposures and interrelation
Extensive validation
Rigorous model governance process
Describe Strategic Risk Management
Process which insurer facilitate the optimization of risk adjusted returns,
start with view of required risk capital
well defined process of allocation capital among different line of business/products.
Risk appetite
Risk preference
Risk tolerance
Risk limits
Risk appetite: Level of aggregate risk company chooses to take in pursuit of objectives
Risk preference: Qualitative statement
Risk tolerance: Quantitative statement to guide insurer in the selection of risk/Aggregate risk taking capacity
Risk limits: Quantitative boundaries to constrain specific risk taking activities.
Total Adjusted Capital =
Capital + Surplus
Describe Underwriting Risk: H2
Risk of underestimating the cost of insurance
Apply a risk factor against some measure for each health insurance product
Claim Fluctuation risk and Other Underwriting risk
Claim Fluctuation Risk
Grouping?
Formula?
Measure?
Five product groupings: Comprehensive Medical, Medicare Supplement, Dental and Vision, Part D, Other
Premium x Incurred Claim/Premium x Risk Factor x Managed care risk adjustment/discount factor
Measure: Underwriting Revenue
Describe Managed care risk adjustment factor?
Measure?
Category?
Not applicable to?
Reflects that certain contractual reimbursement leads to greater predictability in claims level and reduce the need of capital
Measure: Paid claims (not incurred)
Category: Not included, Contractual fee arrangements, Bonus payments, Capitation, Non contingent expenses - staff model HMOs.
Not applicable to Part D and Others.
Other Underwriting risk
Disability income: earned premium, individual and group not combined.
LTC: Premium, Incurred claim, Reserves
Other: Stop loss
Rate guarantees
Premium Stabilization reserves
Describe Asset Risk - Affliates (H0)
Risk that investment in stock of affiliated company may lose value
Require RBC - RBC x % ownership
Not require RBC - book value x 30%
Describe Asset Risk - Other (H1)
Risk that investments may default/decrease in value
Book value x risk factor
Cash/Bonds
Common Stock
Property & Equipment
Describe Credit Risk (H3)
Risk that amounts owed to health insurer will not be recovered. Receivables x %
Risk that capitated provider won’t fulfill contractual obligations. Annual cap x %
Describe Business Risk (H4)
Admin expense risk
ASO business risk
Guaranty fund assessment
Excessive growth risk
Change in RBC formula =
RBC ratio new = RBC ratio prior x H2 prior / H2 new
Allocating the benefits of diversification
Retain the difference centrally
Give full benefit of diversification to new business line
Start with stand alone capital requirements and then allocate diversification benefit
Consider marginal contribution of each additional business unit: Euler capital allocation principle, Standard deviation of losses, Value at risk/Tail Value at risk
Reinsurance Methods
Proportional
- Coinsurance: Fixed/excess share (final payout is fixed like Disability/LTC benefit per day), Quota share
- Modified coinsurance
- Funds withheld coinsurance
- Risk premium reinsurance
Non proportional:
- Extended wait
- Excess reinsurance - SSL and ASL (final payout is not fixed like medical reinsurance)
- Specified benefit
Challenges for new health insurers
Start up capital to meet requirements
Pricing
Networks
ORSA Section 2: Assessment of Risk Exposures
- Quantitative and Qualitative assessment of risk exposures
- Normal and stressed environments
- For each material risk categories
- Impact of stresses on capital
ORSA Section 3: Assessment of Group Risk Capital
Aggregate available capital is compared against various risks that can have an adverse impact
Assess risk over varying time horizons, valuation approaches and capital management strategies.
Comparative view against prior year
Capital needed to achieve business objectives, not RBC
ORSA Section 3: Assessment of Prospective Solvency
Demonstrate financial resources to execute multi year business plan
Describe management actions it will take to remedy capital concerns.
A feedback loop: project, action, re-project
Capital =
Asset - Liabilities
Five Main Areas/Subfactors of ERM
Risk Management Culture
Strategic Risk Management
Risk Controls
Emerging Risk Management
Risk Models
Insurer’s ERM Score - Describe Overall Score and List Subfactor Scores
Overall Score
- Very strong: all positive
- Strong: first 3 positive
- Adequate with strong risk controls: Strong risk controls, Neutral strategic risk management
- — no negatives—-
- Adequate: Neutral risk management culture, neutral risk controls
- Weak
Subfactor Scores
- Positive
- Neutral
- Negative
Considerations for the Scoring of Each Risk under ERM
Risk identification
Risk measurement and monitoring
Risk limits and standards
Risk controls: Procedures to manage risk within the limit
Execution of risk control program
Uses of Risk Models under ERM
Measuring the risk exposure
Testing risk correlation and diversification benefit
Evaluating risk mitigation strategies
Quantify capital requirements for a given risk profile
Key Areas of Analysis for Strategic Risk Management Score under ERM
Company’s strategic planning
Product pricing and repricing
Strategic asset allocation
Optimization of risk adjusted returns
Capital budgeting
Economic budgeting
Reinsurance strategy
Net retained risk profile
New risk-bearing initiatives
Main Risks for Life Insurers
Main Risks for Health Insurers
Life:
- Mortality
- Longevity
- Morbidity
- Policyholder behavior
Health:
- Morbidity
Two Key Items of Uncertainty of Reserving Risk for P&C
Level of reserves that will ultimately be needed to meet all liabilities
Timing of those liabilities
Significant Concerns for Health Insurers
and Key Risks Under ERM
Concerns:
- Changing regulations and legislation
- Rising medical cost
- Insufficient data: Less-than-perfect data in the underwriting and pricing processes
Risks:
- Underwriting
- Pricing
- Provider Renewal
- Claims Management
Key Elements Essential to All Insurers’ Operational Risk Controls Under ERM
Procedures in place to systemically:
- identify operational risks and
- to monitor,
- assess,
- and mitigate those identified risks
Sound business continuity plan (BCP) that has undergone multiple drills
Two Key Principles of ERM
Recognizes broad range of risks as either sources of capital or potential for losses
- ”Capital” risk can be negative (adverse effect) or positive (upside).
- Manage risks to exploit the upside possibilities
Holistic approach to managing diverse risks: Risks are not isolated in silos