November Exam Cards Flashcards
Statement
- claim or assertion
- proposition+ assertion
- made/ advanced by a speaker that commits to the truth of that statement
Premise
- statements given as reasons for believing conclusion
- assumed/ taken for granted
- supports the conclusion—
Conclusion
- statement that’s is advanced/defended in argument
- supported by premises
- not taken for granted
Argument
- group of two or more statements one of which is the conclusion
- premises support conclusion if the assumption that the premises are all true increases the probability that the conclusion is true
- can be valid and have fallacies
- being deductively valid or non-deductively strong a necessary but not sufficient condition for being a good argument
Compound argument
- two or more arguments
- linked by common statements
- include intermediate conclusions
Rational argument
- premises support the conclusion
* premises are true/ there is good reason to believe they are true
Intermediate conclusion
- supported by premises
- therefore is a conclusion
- but acts as a premise in the overall argument
Proposition
- an expressed thought/ idea that is “truth conditional”
* can be true or false
Conditional statement
- links to or more propositions
- through if…then
- one proposition is a condition for another proposition
- may be asserted without any of the individual propositions being asserted
- if antecedent is true, consequent is true
- consequent may be true even if antecedent is not true
Antecedent
- governed by if
* truth of antecedent is sufficient but not necessary for truth of the consequent
Consequent
- conditioned by/ flows from antecedent
- truth of consequent is necessary but not sufficient for the truth of antecedent
- truth of consequent is possible without the truth of the antecedent
Explanations
- consists of two propositions
- not intended to support truth of its propositions
- intended to establish an explanatory relation between the propositions
Explanandum
- a proposition describing the event/state of affairs
* taken for granted
Explanans
- one or more propositions
* describes the causal or other factors thought to explain the state of affairs
Implication
• one proposition logically implies another if the argument from the first to the second is valid
Cognitive biss
- natural pattern of reasoning that impedes the process of reaching rational or logical conclusions
- confirmation bias
- availability heuristic
Confirmation bias
- skews non-deductive reasoning
- people tend to be biased in favor of beliefs or hypotheses that they like
- people tend to be biased in favor of confirming evidence rather than disconfirming evidence even when they are personally indifferent toward the hypothesis or belief in question
Ad hominem fallacy
- undermine a claim by appealing to negative or prejudicial features of the character, views, interest, circumstance of one or more persons who support that claim
- criticisms/ suggestions irrelevant to the question of whether the conclusion is true
Irrelevant appeal to authority fallacy
• conclusion advanced or strength of claim that X accepts proposition
• X doesn’t have real authority on the subject matter
• a non expert is entitled to trust an experts opinion 1) there is consensus
2) reasonable to believe that the field is rationally grounded
Irrelevant appeal to popular opinion fallacy
• irrelevant to its truth or falsity
Irrelevant emotional appeal fallacy
Emotions not relevant to truth not falsity of conclusion
Argument from ignorance fallacy
- based on the claim that is opposite
- has not been proved/ established
- to make a claim one must show evidence, cannot claim: there is no evidence that it doesn’t therefore it does
- if p not p
Straw man Fallacy
- attack position- misrepresentation or misinterpretation- easier to criticize
- attacking something weaker than the actual argument
False dilemma fallacy
- fails to cover all the relevant alternatives
* presupposes too few alternative possibilities
Fallacy of ambiguity
• strength/validity disappears when the argument is re-expressed without the use of ambiguous words or expressions