Non-Freehold Estates Flashcards
The 4 landlord-tenant estates are:
- Estate for Years (Tenancy for Years)
- Periodic Tenancy
- Tenancy at Will
- Tenancy at Sufferance
Estate for Years (Tenancy for Years)
- This estate must specify 2 dates:
- a definate beginning date; and
- definate ending date
- To satisy Statute of Frauds, any tenancy for years over 1 year must be in signed writing
- A 1 year tenancy may be oral
- No notice is required between landlord or tenant to terminate the tenancy for years
Periodic Tenancy
- Key word is repeating
- This estate rolls on and on for the period specified in the grant until one party gives proper notice
Ways of Creation for a Periodic Tenancy
- By express agreement
- By Implication - no agreement as to duration
- By Operation of Law
Creation of Period Tenancy by Implication
If the lease does not specify how long the tenancy is to last, then it is presumed to be a periodic tenancy measured by the rent payment
Cretion of Periodic Tenancy by Operation of Law
Occurs in 2 situations:
- Oral Lease that Violates the Statute of Frauds
- Landlord’s acceptence of a rent check results in a periodic tenancy by operation of law, even though the lease violates the statute of frauds.
- The period covered by the rent check the landlord accepted determines the period of the tenancy.
- Holdover Tenant
- Lease expired, but tenant remained on the property
- When the landlord accepted the rent check from the holdover tenant, a periodic tenacy was created and the period of the tenancy is determined by the rent check.
Termination of a Periodic Tenancy
- Either party can terminate a periodic tenancy by giving notice.
- To be valid, the notice must satisfy two independent criteria:
- Enough Time
- An amount of time equal to the length of the period of the tenancy except in the case of a year-to-year tenancy, which generally requires 6 months notice.
- Effective Date
- To be valid, the effective date specified in the notice must be at the end of the period of the tenancy
- Enough Time
Tenancy at Will
- Either party can terminate this tenancy at any time by giving the other party notice of the termination and a reasonable time to vacate the premises
- This can also be terminated by operation at law. Look for:
- Death of either party
- Waste by tenant
- Assignment by tenant
- Transfer of title by landlord
- lease by landlord to 3rd party
Tennancy at Sufferance
This tenancy refers to the bare possession of the property by the tenant when the tenant wrongfully holds over
Landlord’s Options in a Tenancy at Sufference
- Sue to Evict
- sue in trespass to remove the tenant and to recover damages for the holdover
- Impose a New Periodic Tenancy
- If the old, expired tenancy was for less than a year, the new tenancy willbe measured by the period covered by the rent payment
- In the case of residential property, the new period will usually be month-to-month
- In the case for leases of commercial property , the landlord can elect to impose a tenancy will be year-to-year if the expired tenancy was year-to-year
Tenancy at Sufferance: Raised Rent Situation
If the landlord gives the tenant notice of the increase in rent before the experation of the lease, then the landlord may properly demand payment of the higher rent amount if the tenant holds over
Duties of a Tenant
- Pay Rent
- Maintain Premises
Tenants Duty to Maintain the Premises
- if the lease is silent, the tenant just has to not commit waste
- If the lease contains a covenant to repair:
- the modern majority view is that once the tenant covenants to repair, the tenant is liable for everything, including normal wear and tears - unless the agreement expressly excludes this responsibility from the tenant’s covenant to repair
Landlord Remedies
- All states allow the landlord to sue for damages and to terminate the lease, thereby evicting the tenant
If the Tenant Unjustifiably Abandons, the Landlord has two remedial options:
- Landlord accepts the tenant’s offer of abandonment
- Landlord treats the abandonment as a surrender and the landlord retakes the property.
- Tenant has no further rent obligations
- Landlord relets the premises, holding the tenant liable for any deficiency
- Under the modern majority view, the landlord must make a reasonable effort to relet the property in order to mitigate the tenant’s damages.
- Tenant is liable for any deficieny