NHS Hot Topics Flashcards
What is euthanasia and what are the 2 types?
- Ending a patient’s life who is suffering from an incurable and/or painful disease
- Active: Acting person deliberately intervenes to end a life, e.g. injecting substances
- Passive: Causing death by withholding or withdrawing treatment
- Can be voluntary or involuntary
- Illegal in the UK
What is assisted suicide?
Physician intentionally gives a patient the means to take the lethal medication themselves
What are some arguments in support of euthanasia?
- Some illnesses cause intolerable suffering, to end their lives would be the compassionate thing to do
- Provides autonomy to the patient - one of 4 pillars of medical ethics
- Public increasingly supports assisted dying
- By current UK law patients who want to end their lives must travel abroad to do so
What are some arguments against euthanasia?
- Conflicts with principle of non-maleficence
- Legislation could be used to justify assisted dying in vulnerable groups, e.g. those with disabilities and mental illnesses
- Potential negative consequences of legislation (premature ending of lives) outweigh small number of people this would benefit
What are current problems with the ambulance service?
- Ambulance wait times are longer than guidelines
- Due to shortage of paramedics, crowded EDs, high demand
- Government has allocated more money and given NHS workers a pay rise
What is consultant led elective care and what are some current problems with it?
- Non-emergency medical care that is planned in advance and led by a consultant
- High number of people on waiting lists
- Very long waits for treatment compared to pre-pandemic
- ‘Hidden backlog’ of people who would normally present for treatment but chose not to or had referrals cancelled
What are the current problems with A&E waiting times?
- Significantly longer than the target, causing delays
- Results in an increase in ambulance response times
What are current problems with care in the NHS?
- High level of vacancy and more positions
- Led to decreased level of support and increased number of unpaid carers
- Due to low pay and regulations that make it impossible for someone from EU to gain work in the UK in the care sector
What are the current problems with the number of doctors and dentists in the NHS?
- Low number of GPs and unavailable dentists
- Leads to more ED admissions
Why have A&E waiting times increased?
- Fewer hospital beds
- Ageing population
- Unnecessary A&E attendances
- Staffing shortages
What strategies might reduce strain on A&E departments?
- Assemble GPs, A&E staff, urgent care teams, pharmacists to create new emergency and urgent care hubs
- Investing more in primary care
How do GLP-1 agonists like Ozempic work?
- Activate GLP-1 receptor in pancreas
- Slow gastric emptying and rate of digestion, inhibits release of glucagon, stimulates insulin production
Explain the dual use of Ozempic.
- Intended to be used in adults with type 2 diabetes to reduce hyperglycaemia
- A common side effect is weight loss, but the drug has not been approved for this purpose.
- However, body may get used to the drug and establish a new normal, causing weight to plateau.
What are some ethical issues with the use of Ozempic as a weight loss drug?
- Increased consumer demand has led to shortage of supply for type 2 diabetics
- Usage has large implications: weight regain, lifelong implementation
- Uncertain as to its efficacy over a long period of time
- Decrease in access has raised counterfeit concerns, especially for pharmacies
What are some reasons behind the increased pressure on Primary Care services?
- Increasing demand due to rising life expectancies and an ageing population
- Recruitment issues
- Unnecessary appointments
- Closing practices
- Low public satisfaction
What are some recent solutions in Primary Care to reduce strain on GP practices?
- Medical schools trying to correct misconceptions about GP and encourage more students to consider it
- International recruitment (short-term)
- ‘golden hello’ scheme which pays newly qualified GPs when they start careers in struggling geographical areas
What is organ donation?
- Act of giving an organ to someone who is in need of a transplant
- Certain organs (e.g. kidney) can be donated while alive, but most come from people who have died.
What are some challenges with organ donation?
- Demand is significantly higher than supply:
- Only small proportion of deaths (e.g. stroke/brain injury) allow for organ donations as most do not leave viable organs for use
- These deaths are becoming less common
- Difficult to find a match
What is an opt-in system for organ donation? What are some of the benefits and drawbacks of this?
- Doctors can only use a person’s organs after death if they signed up to a register during their life
- Argued to be most valid and ethical form of consent
- Potential donors don’t register or are unaware of the option
What is an opt-out system of organ donation? What are some drawbacks?
- If a person has not registered, they are considered to have no objection to being an organ donor after death (presumed consent)
- Adopted by England, Wales, Scotland
- Aim to increase numbers as only those with strong opposing views will bow out
- ‘Less valid’ as people may be unaware
How does organ donation in England work?
- Soft opt-out system: 18+ are automatically added, and must actively withdraw to opt-out.
- Families are still consulted before organ donation goes ahead
What is abortion, and how is it done?
The medical process of ending a human pregnancy so it doesn’t culminate in the birth of a baby.
- surgical abortion - operation to remove pregnancy from the womb
- medical abortion - 2 pills taken, which inhibit progesterone and induce contractions to pass pregnancy
- recently second pill was legalised to take at home
What are some arguments opposing abortion (pro-life)?
- human life begins at the point of conception
- child could be adopted rather than taking an innocent life
- abortion can cause psychological distress for woman
- all children have great potential, and abortion may kill a child that could be very important to society or the world
What are some arguments supporting abortion (pro-choice)?
- all abortions are carried out early when foetus cannot exist independently outside mothers womb - hence it is not murder
- in cases of rape or incest, forcing a woman to have the child will be more psychologically damaging than abortion
- abortion may be necessary to save woman’s life in certain cases
Briefly describe the Jim the Horse Tetanus Scandal.
- Jim was a milk wagon horse who had symptomatic signs of tetanus and was eventually euthanised
- Used to produce serums containing diphtheria antitoxin:
- horses inoculated with bacteria, then antitoxin rich serum removed from blood
- Serum led to death of 13 children, as it was found to be contaminated with tetanus - batch not tested before use
- mislabelling of samples as free of contamination when actually contaminated
- later found that Jim was not immunised against tetanus
What were the key factors that led to the Jim the Horse Tetanus scandal, and how can incidents like this be prevented in the future?
- Distribution of antitoxin organised poorly and not tested appropriately + mislabelling of samples
- Maintain patient safety - establish medical protocols and ensure supervision within the team to ensure safe medical practice. Apply quality assurance measures.
- Ensure informed consent as patients did not know Jim was not vaccinated against tetanus
What is whistleblowing? What policies are implemented in the NHS to encourage it?
- Raising concerns to an official channel rather than discussing with colleagues
- NHS England runs ‘freedom to speak up’ policy, offering info and supporting staff to raise concerns.
What are some ethical dilemmas and barriers associated with whistleblowing?
- Challenging as there are risks, such as being fired from job or challenging ability to practice medicine
- however, ethically correct as it is beneficent and non-maleficent aiming to protect patients