New Criminal Law Flashcards
What is the CL definition of murder?
The unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought.
What is malice aforethought?
- Intent to kill
- Intent to inflict great bodily harm
- An extreme recklessness and disregard for human life.
- Intent to commit an inherently dangerous felony.
What is the CL definition of 1st degree murder?
- unlawful premeditated and deliberated killing.
- killing committed in a certain manner articulated by legislature (lying in wait, poison, torture, explosives)
PETL
What is the CL definition of 2nd degree murder?
- Intentional killing without premeditation and deliberation.
- Intent to seriously injure.
- Depraved heart killing.
What is the Felony Murder Rule under CL?
Death occurs during the commission or attempted commission of an inherently dangerous crime.
When is the “end of life?”
When someone is brain dead.
What is the CL definition of Voluntary Manslaughter?
Unlawful, intentional killing, mitigated by sudden heat of passion or adequate provocation.
(Would a reasonable person have responded in the manner that the defendant did under the same circumstances?)
-No time to cool off
-Mere words are usually not adequate provocation
What is the CL definition of Involuntary Manslaughter?
Accidental death caused by:
- lawful act in culpable manner (reckless or gross negligence)
- unlawful act (not a felony)
What is the CL Misdemeanor Manslaughter Rule?
A death that occurs during the commission or attempted commission of a misdemeanor is is an involuntary manslaughter.
What is the CL Felony Murder Rule?
A death that occurs during the commission or attempted commission of a felony is murder.
- Typically 1st degree murder; especially if the felony was inherently dangerous.
- Certain crimes are automatically 1st degree; arson, kidnapping, robbery, burglary, and rape.) FABRRK
- The felony is still going when the defendant’s are in flight. (Felonious escape)
- Causal connection between the defendant’s act and victims harm (“but, for” cause of death)
What is the CL Doctrine of Merger for the Felony Murder Rule?
Felony must be independent and not merge with the act of killing. Ex: Assault + Death DOES NOT = felony murder because the assault would merge with the killing.
What are the 3 approaches to the Felony Murder Rule being applied to accomplices?
- “Agency/In Furtherance of”
(Majority View; most limiting)
-If one of the felons shoots, all co-felons are liable.
-Co-felons can be liable for death of a third party
-If police office shoots one of the felons are the co-felons liable? No. - Proximate Cause Approach:
-Felon is liable for ALL reasonably foreseeable deaths; whether they were shot by a co-felon, police officer, third party, etc. - Provocative Act Doctrine:
Whomever fires first or creates the situation, is liable for all deaths.
What is the MPC definition of Criminal Homicide?
Purposely, knowingly, recklessly, or negligently causes death of another.
What is the MPC definition of Murder?
A. Purposely or knowingly
B. Recklessly by manifesting extreme indifference to human life
C. Felony of 1st degree (robbery, rape, arson, burglary, kidnapping, felonious escape.)
D. During commission or attempted commission of a felony.
What is the MPC definition of Manslaughter?
A. Recklessly (death that results from conscious disregard for known risk)
B. Committed under extreme mental disturbance with reasonable explanation
-Does not require provocation or cooling off period.
-“Extreme mental disturbance” (subjective)
-“Reasonable explanation” (objective)
Considered: Age Gender Physical Disabilities Physical Characteristics GAPP
Not Considered: Intellectual Disabilities Psych Temperament PIT
What is the MPC definition of Negligent Homicide?
Criminal negligence.
What is the MPC definition of Felony Murder Rule?
Restricted to enumerated felonies: Arson Rape Robbery Burglary Kidnapping Felonious escape
FABRRK
Defendant may rebut with evidence that conduct was not reckless.
Prosecutor must prove mens rea beyond a reasonable doubt.