Net Assessment Flashcards
What are the six perspectives of NA? Bracken, NA: A Practical Guide
- Strategic Interactions
- Longer Time Spans
- Getting Things Right with a Little Thought
- The Importance of Socio-Bureaucratic Behavior
- Strategic Asymmetries
- The Multifaceted Nature of Strategy
Name the Five Sequential Steps of Net Assessment.
Page 98, Karber, NA for SecDef
- Measurements – collecting empirical data in a comparable format;
- Estimates – discovering, describing and distinguishing those elements that are unmeasurable but important;
- Analysis – evaluating competitive strengths, weaknesses, vulnerabilities and opportunities;
- Balancing – anticipating opportunities for the application of strength to vulnerability in juxtaposed postures;
- Triumph – identifying and projecting into the future opportunities for the conversion of favorable balances (i.e. imbalances) into political outcomes.
Describe what the first step in a NA process consists of. That is, describe Measurements, as it relates to NA.
Page 98, Karber, NA for SecDef
Measurements – collecting empirical data in a comparable format.
Describe what the second step in a NA process consists of. That is, describe Estimates, as it relates to NA.
Page 98, Karber, NA for SecDef
Estimates – discovering, describing and distinguishing those elements that are important but unmeasurable and not overly depending upon quantitative data that are incomplete or unknowable when significant qualitative factors need to be considered.
Describe what the third step in a NA process consists of. That is, describe Analysis, as it relates to NA.
Page 98, Karber, NA for SecDef
Analysis – evaluating competitive strengths, weaknesses, vulnerabilities and opportunities and their change over time.
Describe what the fourth step in a NA process consists of. That is, describe Balancing, as it relates to NA.
Page 98, Karber, NA for SecDef
Balancing – anticipating opportunities for the application of strength to vulnerability in juxtaposed postures over time.
Describe what the fifth step in a NA process consists of. That is, describe Triumph, as it relates to NA.
Page 98, Karber, NA for SecDef
Triumph – identifying and projecting into the future opportunities for the conversion of favorable balances (i.e. imbalances) into political outcomes.
NA heavily relies on the analysis of _____-_____ ________ in order to explore possible alternative security futures.
Long-Term Trends
JMSS, Vol 12, Issue 2 Winter 2010
Name other disciplines whose insights are incorporated into net assessments.
Economics, Military History, Political Science, Organizational Behavior, Psychology, Cultural Anthropology, Demography, Strategic Culture and Life Sciences.
Pg 3, JMSS, Vol 12, Issue 2 Winter 2010
Net Assessments fall into which two categories?
Geographical and Functional
__________Net Assessments examine the military balance of a particular region, such as the middle east or northeast Asia.
Pg 4, JMSS, Vol 12, Issue 2 Winter 2010
Geographic
___________ Net Assessments examine the military balance in specific military domains such as air, land, maritime, space or nuclear.
Pg 4, JMSS, Vol 12, Issue 2 Winter 2010
Functional
Name some common military balance material and non-material factors.
Force Structure and Posture, training, officer education, leadership, personnel and manpower, facilities, logistics, national defense policy, and defense spending.
According to Cohen’s “Net Assessment: An American Approach”, there are four pillars of a NA. Name them.
- Trends (long-term)
- Doctrine (or concepts of operation)
- Asymmetries (areas of comparative advantage)
- Scenarios (war games as an example)
What would an example NA outline consist of?