Natural (Moral) Law Flashcards
What does legalism mean?
A set of prefabricated moral rules or laws
What does deontological mean?
Ethics is concerned with the nature of acts themselves, rather than their outcome - they are right and wrong intrinsically
What does telos mean?
The end or purpose
What does Aristotle believe everything has?
A purpose
How is purpose revealed?
By its design
What is the aim of telos?
To fulfil telos is the supreme good to be sought
What happens if something does not reach its purpose?
It has not realised its potential
What is Plato’s Euthyphro dilemma?
Views 2 possible versions of the universe
1) God (1) moral laws (2) humans (3), God commands moral laws because they are absolutely true in themselves and separate from God
2) God (1) humans (2) God commands humans to do certain things and are good, because God has commanded them
What is Plato’s Euthyphro dilemma?
Views 2 possible versions of the universe
1) God (1) moral laws (2) humans (3), God commands moral laws because they are absolutely true in themselves and separate from God
2) God (1) humans (2) God commands humans to do certain things and are good because God has commanded them
What is a quote from Plato’s Euthyphro dilemma?
“Loved by the God because it is pious, or pious because it is loved?”
What are the problems that the Euthyphro dilemma proposes?
If there is an objective standard of right or wrong, what does that make of God?
What is Divine Command theory?
The view that moral rules are true because they have been commanded by God
Who are three critics against the traditional Natural Law?
A.J. Ayer, Emil Brunner and Leibniz
What is A.J. Ayer’s criticism?
- commanding something does not make it right
- no morality can be founded on authority, even if the authority is divine
What is the criticism of Emil Brunner?
- if things were not commanded by God, they would not be right or wrong
- “hate your neighbour” could have been the command
- DCT makes moral codes appear arbitrary
What is Leibniz’s criticism?
Why praise God for what he’s done, as he would equally be praised for doing the contrary