Murder Flashcards
What four ways can mens rea be shown for murder?
- Intent to kill
- Intent to cause serious bodily harm (jdx)
- The presence of a depraved heart (i.e. recklessness)
- When the killing occurs in the courts of committing a statutorily enumerated felony
How do we show deliberation?
Planning, motive, and manner of killing (calculated or frenzied)
What are the three ways 2nd degree can be elevated to 1st Degree?
- The murder was committed using certain statutorily defined means (e.g. poisoning)
- The murder occurred during the commission or attempted commission of a statutorily enumerated felony
- The intentional killing was also premeditated and deliberated
how do we show premeditation?
quantity of time sufficient for deliberation. jdx on more than an instant or not depends on statute
What are the 4 elements of provocation?
- D was actually provoked (subjective);
- The reasonable person in D’s shoes (given facts and circumstances) would have been provoked (legally adequate provocation) (objective);
- D didn’t have sufficient time to cool off (subjective); and
- The reasonable person in D’s shoes wouldn’t have cooled off (objective).
How is 2nd degree murder moderated to voluntary manslaugher?
Provocation or imperfect self-defense
Felony Murder Limitations
- The Inherently Dangerous Limitation
- The Res Gestae Limitation
- The Merger Limitation
- The Agency Limitation
What are common mens rea terms?
knowingly, intentionally, recklessly, negligently
What are the 5 duties act?
- Special status
- Civil obligation (contract)
- Creation of risk of harm
- Voluntary assumption of care and seclusion of person from others
- Imposed by statute
What two ways is intent defined as?
Conscious object: If an actor’s conscious object or purpose is to cause a certain result or to engage in certain prohibited conduct
Knowledge to a virtual certainty: An actor intends a social harm if an actor knows to a virtual certainty their actions will cause the social harm or that they are engaging in prohibited conduct
What are two shortcuts for proving intent?
- Natural and probable consequences
- deadly weapon rule: deadly weapon directed at vital human body part
How is knowledge shown?
the defendant was “aware” of a fact or “correctly believed” that the fact exists
What are the 4 factors for determining if a a statute has strict liability?
- new crime
- public welfare offense (aimed at protecting public)
- penalties are relatively light or non-serious
- stigma is relatively low
Which kind of intent crimes are voluntary intoxication available for?
specific intent. It negates the intent (e.g. 1st degree murder negates prem. delib).
what are the elements for mistake of fact for specific intent crime?
Honest(good faith) mistaken belief that negates mens rea.
What are the elements for mistake of fact for a general intent crime?
Honeslty(subjective) and reasonably(objective) mistaken about a fact that negates mens rea.
What elements are needed for voluntary manslaughter?
(1) Intent to kill and (2) killed in heat of passion or imperfect self defense
Does response to provocation need to be sudden?
Most jdxs yes. Others allow for cumulative provocation by the victim.
What is a reasonable person?
an ordinary person of average intelligence
What are the 4 jdxs splits we need to be aware of?
Intervening cause, defense of habitation, attempts, and entrapment
What is the mens rea for depraved heart murder?
Gross recklessnes: the defendant was subjectively aware that his or her conduct created a substantial and unjustified rick of death, yet the defendant consciously disregards the risk.
What is the mens rea for involuntary manslaughter?
Gross negligence: the defendant should have been aware that his or her conduct created a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death but was unaware and engaged in that conduct. Was the risk of such a nature and degree that the failure to be aware of it constitutes a gross deviation from the standard of care that a reasonable person in the D’s situation would exercise? EX. street racing or drunk driving
What are the three elements of larceny?
- Intentional
- Trespassory (w/o permission) taking and carrying away of another’s personal property
- with the intent to permanently deprive the owner of the property