MPRE Condensed Flashcards
Sources of Regulation – The State
1) Courts (rules of the court & case law)
2) Bar Associations (integrated - required membership)
3) Congress/State Legislatures
Sources of Regulation – Federal System
1) federal courts (case law, court rules)
2) government attorneys (subject to the ethical regulations where the attorney practices)
Sources of Regulation – Multiple States
subject to regulations in each state admitted (no matter where the lawyer practices or incident occurred)
Admission to Practice – The Application
1) must not knowingly make false statements
2A) must not fail to disclose known information
2B) must not knowingly fail to respond to demand for information
Admission to Practice – Good Moral Character –Investigation
1) Burden on applicant to prove good moral character
2) Duty to cooperate
Admission to Practice – Good Moral Character – Conduct Relevant
All Aspects reflecting honesty and integrity (all charges/litigation, even acquitted)
1) Criminal - Moral Turpitude (intentional dishonesty or violence – except adolescent misbehavior and civil disobedience)
2) Can rehabilitate moral character
3) False Statements is evidence of lack of moral character
4) Can deny application for failure to uphold federal/state constitution (not just for communism)
Admission to Practice – Citizenship/Residency
Not required
Citizenship – violation of equal protection clause
Residency – violation of privilege and immunities clause
Misconduct
1) Violate the Rules of Profession Conduct
2) Crimes (dishonesty, breach of trust, violence)
3) Dishonesty/Fraud/Deceit/Misrepresentation (any conduct)
4) Conduct Prejudicial to admin of justice
5) stating/implying ability to influence officials
6) assisting a judge’s violation of judicial code
7) harassment or discrimination in law practice
Misconduct - Violate the Rules of Profession Conduct
1) Violate/Attempt to violate any rule of PR
2) knowingly assist/induce another person to violate rules
3) use the acts of another person to violate the rules
Misconduct - harassment or discrimination in law practice
knows or should reliable know is discrimination based on protected classes (race, religion, gender, etc.)
Exceptions
1) limit practice to serving underserved community
2) provide legitimate advice
3) promote diversity/inclusion
Duty to Report Professional Misconduct
MUST report when a lawyer
1) knows (actual knowledge or inferred) other lawyer violated the rules AND
2) raising a substantial question of the lawyers moral character
Applies to reporting judges
May report if only suspected misconduct
subject to discipline for failing to report (except if knowledge was gained through confidential info.)
Disciplinary Process
1) Complaint
2) Screening
3) Hearing (Due process required and 5th Amendment)
4) Burden of proof on prosecuting party
5) Attorney entitled to review by court (dismissal cant be reviewed)
6) Sanctions
Disciplinary Process – Sanctions
1) Private or Public Reprimand/Censure
2) Suspension
3) Disbarment (permanent – readmission after proof of rehabilitation)
Impact in other Jurisdictions
1) Other States – not necessarily binding (conclusive proof)
2) Federal – comptent evidence
Disciplinary Process – Choice of Law
1) when compliant happened before a tribunal then ethics rules of the tribunal’s jurisdiction
2) all other situations, where the conduct occurred
3) Not subject to discipline if conduct is proper in a jurisdiction where lawyer reasonably believed the predominant effect will occur
4) Conflicts of Interest law through agreement (if there is a reasonable belief the predominant effect will occur in the agreed jurisdiction)
Disciplinary Process – Disability
disabled lawyer (impairment – drugs/alcohol) suspension from practice until rehabilitation
Unauthorized Practice
admitted in one jurisdiction doesnt permit practice in another jurisdiction
subject to the disciplinary rules of both jurisdictions
Except
1) Temporary Permission
2) Permanent Permission
Unauthorized Practice - Temporary Permission
1) Association with Local Lawyer
2) Special Permission to Practice in local tribunal
3) mediation/arbitration arising out of a practice in admitted state
4) other reasonably related practices arising out of practice in admitted state
5) Foreign Lawyers (great scrutiny)
Unauthorized Practice - Permanent Permission
1) Lawyers employed by their only client (in-house counsel)
2) legal services authorized by federal/local law (patents)
Unauthorized Practice - Non Lawyers
Practice of law –
1) requiring legal knowledge and skill
2) advice concerning binding legal rights
3) activity is traditionally performed by lawyers
Not filing in blanks on standard documents or preparing taxes
Sanctions - injunction, contempt, criminal conviction (assisting attorney subject to discipline – allowed to delegate work, must supervise/ultimate responsible)
Can hire suspended/disbarred to do layperson work
Lawyer-Client Relationship
contractual relationship (rules varied by agreement - construed against attorney) fiduciary duty/Agency
Creating Lawyer-Client Relationship
attorney free to refuse service for any reason (ethical obligation to accept a fair share of unpopular matters)
manifests of intent and lawyer agrees
Estoppel (client reasonably relies on lawyering providing services)
tribunal appoints lawyer (should not reject except for good cause – 1. violation of ethics rules 2. unreasonable financial burden 3. repugnant client would impair representation)
Lawyer-Client Relationship Implied/Reasonable Reliance
lawyer’s assent is implied when lawyer fails to clearly decline representation and client reasonably relies (reliance = question of fact)
unanswered letter = unreasonable reliance (no relationship)