MPRE Flashcards
A court may order an attorney to disclose any info protected by…
duty of confidentiality that is NOT subject to the attorney client privilege
Can a lawyer reveal confidential info to settle a dispute bw lawyer and client?
yes! a lawyer can reveal confidential info to settle a dispute bw lawyer and client
Can a lawyer reveal confidential info to prevent a client’s future criminal act unrelated to lawyer’s services?
NO, a lawyer may not reveal confidential info to prevent a client’s future criminal act unrelated to lawyer’s services
When can a lawyer represent opposing parties in the same lawsuit?
NEVER
How do you determine if a conflict exists bw current and former client?
- Look at scope of prior representation
- Could lawyer have obtained info from prior representation?
- Would info be useful to current litigation?
noisy withdrawal
The method by which a lawyer is permitted to resign If the organization does not correct a violation of the law
A lawyer who knows of a violation of law that will likely result in substantial injury to a corp may…
refer the matter to the highest authority of the corporation
The lawyer represents a corporation, not the corporation’s…
constituents (e.g., officers, directors, employees).
A lawyer may not contact a person that the lawyer________________ _________________ is represented by counsel
reasonably believes
A lawyer may not _____________ a person who is unrepresented by counsel
contact
Confidential info (for purposes of the ethical rules)
Any info relating to representation of a client, REGARDLESS of source
Attorney-client privilege
Protects confidential comms bw attorneys and clients from disclosure.
Ask: 1) Was comms in q bw attorney and client? 2) Was the comms confidential?
What info is covered by duty of confidentiality?
Any info obtained directly from the lawyer’s representation of their client is covered by the duty of confidentiality
Do lawyers have a general ethical obligation to report crimes they know of?
NO! Lawyers do NOT have any general ethical obligation to report crimes of which they have knowledge.
Does the crime-fraud exception to the duty of confidentiality apply to a crime committed by a non-client?
NO!
Would a lawyer be subject to discipline for failure to report a crime?
NO - lawyers don’t have any duty to report crimes they know about
crime-fraud exception
Permits a lawyer, in her discretion, to disclose info about a crime without subjecting herself to discipline for violating her duty of confidentiality
2 exceptions when an attorney can reveal confidential info:
(1) client expressly gives informed consent
OR
(2) disclosure is impliedly authorized to carry out representation.
Can the work product doctrine overcome a federal subpoena?
Yes an attorney should refuse to provide documents created under the work-product doctrine
Does attorney-client privilege to a company apply to underlying facts that an attorney discovered?
Not unless they come from confidential conversations with the client (or their employees)
Can facts from records and interviews with 3P be covered by attorney client privilege?
Nope
Can facts from records and interviews with 3P be covered by the work product doctrine?
Nope
Does revealing info related to client representation if the attorney believes it is necessary to respond to a court order, violate the duty of confidentiality?
Not if the attorney follows procedure.
How must an attorney respond to a court order (subpoena) requiring disclosure of confidential info?
Attorney must:
1) reasonably try to notify client and get informed consent to disclose
2) If client doesn’t consent, attorney should assert, on client’s behalf, all nonfrivolous claims the court’s order isn’t authorized or info is protected by attorney-client privilege or other law.
3) If court rejects these arguments, attorney must consult with client about appeal.
4) If no appellate review is sought, attorney may disclose.
Attorneys in a law firm may disclose to each other info relating to a client of the firm, unless…
a client has instructed that particular info be confined to specified lawyers
An attorney MAY reveal info related to representation that the attorney reasonably believes is necessary to prevent, mitigate, or rectify…
a substantial financial or property-related injury that has resulted, or is reasonably certain to result, from a crime or fraud furthered by client’s use of attorney’s services.
When is an attorney impliedly authorized to use or disclose confidential client info?
if it is appropriate to do so as part of the attorney’s representation
Can attorneys within a firm may disclose a client’s confidential info to one another as part of representation without a client’s consent?
Yes UNLESS client gave instructions that info should be shared only with specific attorneys, or ethical rules require attorneys be screened from representation to avoid conflicts of interest.
Attorneys within a firm may disclose a client’s confidential info to one another as part of representation, unless…
1) client gave instructions that info should be shared only with specific attorneys, or
2) MRPC require some attorneys be screened from representation to avoid conflicts of interest.
Does a client control the means or objective of representation?
Client controls only the objective of representation, not the means.
May a client have concerning the means of representation?
Yes, lawyer must consult with a client concerning the means of representation.
How does the MPRC suggest a disagreement be resolved?
MPRC do not state how to resolve a disagreement.
What should a lawyer do if they believe a client with diminished capacity is not acting in the client’s own best interests?
Lawyer can seek appointment of a guardian or conservator. They may NOT override client’s decision on the objective of representation, even if they believe it is in the client’s best interest
When can a client who retained a lawyer terminate the lawyer’s representation?
Any time, even without cause.
- even if the client hasn’t paid all the fees yet!
If accepting a case would create substantial financial hardship for a lawyer, is the lawyer required to reject representation?
NO. A lawyer MAY reject representation, but isn’t required to reject representation.
If accepting a case would require the lawyer to assert a frivolous claim, is the lawyer required to reject representation?
YES
If accepting a case would create a conflict of interest with an existing client, is the lawyer required to reject representation?
YES
$ separation rule for lawyers
A lawyer is obligated to segregate clients $ and lawyers $.
No co-mingling!
As a defense attorney, when can you NOT let your client testify?
if you KNOW his testimony will be false