Mortgages Flashcards
Santley v Wilde
a conveyance of land as security for the payment of a debt or the discharge of some other obligation
s1(2)(C) LPA 1925
a mortgage is capable of being a legal interest
s52(1) LPA 1925
to be legal, it must be created by deed
s1 LP(MP)(A) 1989
the requirements for a valid deed - it must be headed ‘deed’, it must be signed by the grantor, attested by a capable witness, and delivered (dated)
s27(2)(f) LRA 2002
Registered -the mortgage must be substantively registered as it is on the list of registrable dispositions
s4(1)(g) LRA 2002
Unregistered - mortgage triggers compulsory first registration if not protected by holding title deeds
s2(4)(i) LCA 1972
Unregistered land - where protected by title deeds can be registered as Class C(i) charge
s2(4)(iii) LCA 1972
or C(iii) land charge
Legal mortgage
binds the world once it has been registered
Equitable mortgage
s32 LRA 2002 Notice must be entered on the charges register of the freehold, which will make it binding on any purchaser - s29(2) LRA. If no Notice, void against a purchaser for value - s29(1) LRA 2002
Options to purchase
will prevent the M’OR’s equitable right to redeem. If the MEE exercises the option, the M’OR cannot repay the loan and get their land back unencumbered by the mortgage
Samuel v Jarrah
options to purchase within the mortgage deed are void. Option granted on the same day as mortgage was void
Reeve v Lisle
option in a transaction independent of the mortgage may be valid. Option was granted 12d after mortgage, formed a separate bargain in the eyes of the court
Jones v Morgan
if option linked to mortgage, option will be void. Would prevent equitable right to redeem by M’OR
Warmborough v Garmite
the court will look at the ‘substance’ of the transaction to ascertain its true nature/determine
Brighton CC v Audus
applied Warmborough. Its overall character was not a mortgage
Postponement of legal redemption date
the date from which the MO is able to repay the loan and interest in full to discharge the mortgage (equitable right to redeem begins immediately after the legal date expires
Toomes v Consent
equity won’t allow a mortgage term that prevents redemptions all together
Knightsbridge Estates v Byrne
legal date of redemption pushed back to 40year after start of mortgage term, but upheld: arm’s length business transaction, freely and willingly entered into + MO received a very low interest
Fairclough v Swan Brewery
lease had 17.6 years to run and legal redemption was pushed back to 6 weeks before the lease was due to expire - struck down - the MO would not get back substantially the same property - a lease with 17years to run
Collateral advantage
residential = unlikely to uphold, commercial = uphold the collateral tie
Biggs v Hoddinott
collateral tie which isn’t unscoscnionable or repugnant to right to redeem and doesn’t last longer than the duration of the mortgage. The court said no = the business entered with eyes open
Noakes v Rice
collateral tie not usually allowed to go beyond duration of mortgage.
Kreglinger v New Patagonia
If the collateral tie goes beyond the duration of mortgage, must be genuinely independent of the mortgage transaction
Esso Petroluem v Harper’s
must also not be in restraint of trade
Holles v Wyse
court has the power to strike down an unconscionable or penal interest rate
Cityland v Dabrah
No legal advice, vulnerable, trusting naive. Lender - bargaining position, rate was 19% pa + 57% total amount of the loan. Effective 38% when the borrower went into default. Was changed = the court changed the 19% rate with 7%
Multiservice Bookbinding v Marden
Rate 2% above the bank rate, loan couldn’t be deemed for 10years BUT it was beneficial - it was okay
Falco Finance v Gough
late payment by 1 day increased rate by 5% to 14% for the entire term - STROKE OUT
Davies v Directloans
rate of 21.6% when market rate was 17% was justified as MO had poor credit history and ME was taking risk. 4.6% above market rate was not improper
Paragon Finance v Nash
rate of 2-4% above market area was justified as ME itself was suffering financial difficulties + had a higher cost of borrowing on the international money markets