Mortgages Flashcards
What is the equity of redemption?
It is the mortgagor’s right to redeem the loan when he wishes to do so, recovering his property in an unencumbered state. But the mortgagee is entitled to have the loan monies repaid together with any interest that might have accrued.
When is the contractual date of redemption normally specified as?
6 months
When is the equitable right to redeem?
Allows redemption of the mortgage at any stage on reasonable notice to the lender.
What is the rule against irredeemability?
A mortgage cannot be constructed so that it is impossible to pay back the loan. Any attempt to limit this right to redeem may be void.
When is postponement of the right to redeem invalid?
Postponement struck down if it renders the right to redeem illusory.
In what case did the court hold that the postponed right to redeem the mortgage six weeks before the expiry of the leasehold was void?
Fairclough v Swan Brewery [1912]
In which case did the court hold that postponement of the right to redeem the mortgage will be struck down if it is oppressive or unconscionable but that unreasonableness is insufficient? What were the facts of the case?
Knightsbridge Estates Trust Ltd v Byrne [1940]
Commercial mortgage of freehold between two experienced parties but could not be redeemed for 40 years.
Who is the mortgagee?
The lender
Who is the mortgagor?
The borrower
Which case established that ‘once a mortgage, always a mortgage’? What does that phrase mean?
Seton v Slade (1802)
The borrower always has a right to repay the loan and to redeem their property.
In which case was a collateral advantage requiring the owner of a pub mortgaged to a brewery to buy all beer from brewery including after the mortgage was redeemed held to be an impermissible clog?
Noakes & Co Ltd v Rice [1902]
In which case was an additional term to a mortgage giving right of first refusal over sheepskins produced for 5 years held to be valid for the entire period even though loan paid off early? Why was it valid?
G & K Kreglinger v New Patagonia Meat & Cold Storage Co Ltd [1914]
Term held to be an independent condition of the loan freely and knowingly entered into.
Which case is authority for the fact that an option to purchase obtained as part of the mortgage transaction will always be void?
Samuel v Jarrah Timber and Wood Paving Corporation Ltd [1904]
If an option to purchase is obtained in a transaction independent of the the mortgage could it be valid?
Yes
Which case held that even when an option to purchase is obtained in a transaction independent of the mortgage, if it is held to be a variation of the original mortgage it will still be struck down? What were the facts?
Jones v Morgan [2001]
Option to purchase 50% share granted 3 years after the original mortgage but struck down as held to be a variation of the original mortgage.
What are the formalities for creating a legal mortgage in unregistered land? What is the authority?
ss. 85(1) and 86(1):
(1) mortgage by demise - grant of lease for 3000 years subject to condition that lease terminates once loan paid off
(2) charge by way of legal mortgage - created by deed
How do you create a legal mortgage in registered land? What is the authority?
s.23(1) LRA 2002 - create mortgage by charge by way of legal mortgage
What is the authority for the fact that a charge by way of legal mortgage constitutes a conveyance of land?
s.205(1)(i) LPA 1925
What is the authority for the fact that all conveyances of land must be made by deed?
s.52 LPA 1925
What is authority for the fact that a charge by way of legal mortgage must be registered as a charge at the Land Registry to operate at law?
s.27(2)(f) LRA 2002
When do you have an equitable mortgage?
If the legal mortgage is not registered or the formalities for creation have not been complied with.
What do you need to ensure you have to make sure you have an equitable mortgage? What is the authority for this?
You need a specifically enforceable written contract
s.2 LP(MP)A 1989 requires writing plus terms signed by both parties
What should you consider if you have no writing and no contract for an equitable mortgage, but you can show reliance to your detriment on an oral promise to create a mortgage where unconscionable for the bank to go back on their word?
A proprietary estoppel claim
In which case did the court hold that there was a mortgage by estoppel created because money had been lent on an assurance that a valid mortgage would be forthcoming?
Kinane v Mackie-Conteh [2005]
What is required for overreaching where mortgages are concerned?
Mortgage paid to 2 or more trustees
Right capable of being overreached - s.2(3) LPA 1925
Sale must be made by those persons and in those circumstances that constitute an overreaching transaction - s.2(1)(ii) LPA 1925
What is the basic priority rule? What is the authority?
s.28 LRA 2002
If the transferee is not a purchaser for valuable consideration the new owner takes the land subject to all prior proprietary rights.
What are the special priority rules? Where do you find the authorities?
s. 29(1) LRA 2002 - If you have given valuable consideration then you take priority if it is a registered disposition. It postponed any interest on the estate immediately before the disposition over any rights that are not protected.
s. 30(1) LRA 2002 - establishes the same concerning mortgages specifically.
When is the priority of a prior interest to the mortgage protected? What is the authority?
s. 30(2) LRA 2002
(a) (i) it is a registered charge of the subject of a notice in the register
(ii) falls within any of the paragraphs in schedule 3 (overriding interest)